601–750
1 _uu_u_u_
_uu__uu_u_
_uu_uu_
_uu_u_u_u_
5 _u_u_u_
10 __u_u_u__
_u_u_
_uu_u_ _
_uu_u_ _
_uu_u_uu__
_uu_uu__
5 __u_ _
_uu_u_uu_u_uu_u_
_u_uu___u_uu_u_
_uu__
Philoctetes. Lewis Campbell. ed. Lewis Campbell. Oxford. 1879.
Philoctetes. Lewis Campbell. ed. Lewis Campbell. Oxford. 1879.
Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879) (OCR draft) (English) (Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879))
Provisional text from uncorrected OCR; expect errors.
mvp-comment-331-1 τίς ὁ πόθος 1
mvp-comment-331-2 ἵκετ’ 2
mvp-comment-331-3 θεῶν βία 3
mvp-comment-331-4 νέμεσις 4
mvp-comment-331-5 ἀμύνουσιν 5
mvp-comment-332-1 ὄνομα δ’ ὠνομάζετο 6
mvp-comment-333-1 Ἕλενος 7
mvp-comment-333-2
The statement of the
mvp-comment-334-1 ἀκούων 8
mvp-comment-334-2 λωβητὰ ἔπη 9
mvp-comment-335-1 ἐς μέσον 10 ἔδειξ’ 11
mvp-comment-336-1 τά τ’ ἄλλα … πάντα 12 καὶ 13
mvp-comment-337-1 τἀπὶ Τροίᾳ πέργαμ’ 14
mvp-comment-337-2 οὐ μή ποτε πέρσοιεν 15 οὐ μή 16
mvp-comment-337-3 οὐ δηποτε πέρσοιεν 17
mvp-comment-338-1 ἄγοιντο 18 ἀγάγοιντο 19 ἄξοιντο 20 ἄγοιντο 21
mvp-comment-338-2 νήσου 22
mvp-comment-338-3 617 The words οἴοιτο μὲν μάλιστα 23
mvp-comment-338-4 μάλιστα 25 οἴοιτο 26
mvp-comment-339-1 τούτων 27 μὴ τυχών 28
mvp-comment-339-2 κάρα τέμνειν 29 ἐφεῖτο 30
mvp-comment-340-1 τὸ σπεύδειν 31
mvp-comment-340-2 σοι καὐτῷ 32 πέρι 33
mvp-comment-341-1 ἡ πασα βλάβη 34
mvp-comment-342-1 πεισθήσομαι 35
mvp-comment-342-2 γὰρ 36
mvp-comment-342-3 ὧδε 37
mvp-comment-342-4 πρὸς φῶς ἀνελθεῖν 38
mvp-comment-342-5 οὑκείνου πατήρ 39
mvp-comment-343-1 συμφέροι 40
mvp-comment-344-1 τάδε 41
mvp-comment-345-1 ἂν 42 δεῖξαι 43
mvp-comment-345-2 νεὼς ἄγοντ’ 44
mvp-comment-346-1 οὔ· 45
mvp-comment-346-2 πλεῖστον ἐχθίστης 46
mvp-comment-347-1 ἄπουν 47
mvp-comment-348-1 πάντα λεκτά 48
mvp-comment-349-1 ὡς … ὁρίζῃ 49 ὁρίζει 50
mvp-comment-350-1 τοὐκ πρῴρας 51
mvp-comment-350-2 ἀνῇ 52
mvp-comment-350-3 στελοῦμεν 53
mvp-comment-351-1 οὔκ, ἀλλὰ 54 οὐκ 55 οἶδ)· 56 ἀλλ’ οὐχὶ 57
mvp-comment-352-1 ἀλλ’ 58
mvp-comment-352-2 χωρῶμεν … λαβὼν 59 λαβόνθ’ 60
mvp-comment-353-1 καίπερ οὐ πολλῶν ἄπο 61
mvp-comment-354-1 νεώς γε τῆς ἐμῆς ἔπι 62 ἔνι 63 ἔπι 64 ἔνι 65 νεώς 66 ἔνι 67 ἔνι 68
mvp-comment-355-1 πάνυ 69
mvp-comment-356-1 τί γὰρ ἔτ’ 70
mvp-comment-356-2 γάρ 71
mvp-comment-357-1 εἴ μοί τι τόξων 72 τόξα 73
mvp-comment-357-2 ἀπημελημένον 74
mvp-comment-357-3 παρερρύηκεν 75
mvp-comment-357-4 ὡς λίπω μή 76 λαβεῖν 77
mvp-comment-358-1 οὐ γὰρ ἄλλ’ ἔστ’, ἀλλ’ ἃ κ.τ.λ. 78 ἀλλ’ 79 ἄλλ’ 80 ἄλλος 81 ἃ βαστάζω 82 ταῦτ’ 83 ἄλλα γ’ ἔσθ’ ἃ 84
mvp-comment-359-1 ὥστε 85 ἔστιν 86
mvp-comment-359-2 θεόν 87 θεός 88
mvp-comment-360-1 ξυμφέρῃ 89 ἐρῶ 90
mvp-comment-361-1 καὶ μὴν … γε 91 πάρες 92
mvp-comment-362-1 ὅσια … θέμις 93
mvp-comment-363-1 ὅς γ’ 94
mvp-comment-363-2 φάος 95
mvp-comment-363-3 δέδωκας 96
mvp-comment-363-4 χθόν’ Οἰταίαν 97
mvp-comment-364-1 ἀνέστησας πέρα 98 πέρα 99 πέρα 100 ἔνερθεν 101 πέρα 102 μ’ ὕ 103 περ 104 ἀναστήσας πάρει 105 πέρα 106
mvp-comment-365-1 ταῦτα 107 παρέσται σοι 108 καὶ θιγγάνειν 109
mvp-comment-366-1 καὶ δόντι δοῦναι 110 δοῦναι 111 ἐπεύξασθαι 112 θιγγάνειν 113
mvp-comment-366-2 669 The acc. μόνον 114 δόντι 115 μόνῳ 116 μόνον 117 ς’ 118 ἀρετῆς 119
mvp-comment-367-1 εὐεργετῶν 120
mvp-comment-368-1
These three verses, called ‘manifesto spurii’ by Dindorf, are clearly genuine. If they are rejected, then Neoptolemus deigns no reply beyond
mvp-comment-369-1 εὖ δρᾶν εὖ παθὼν 121
mvp-comment-369-2 κτήματος 122
mvp-comment-370-1 χωροῖς ἂν εἴσω 123 καὶ σέ γ’ εἰσάξω 124 γε 125 σέ 126 χωροῖς ἂν εἴσω 127
mvp-comment-370-2 τὸ γὰρ 128 νοσοῦν 129 τὸ … νοσοῦν 130
mvp-comment-371-1 ἐξήκους’ 131
mvp-comment-371-2 ὄπωπα δ’ οὐ μάλα 132
mvp-comment-372-1 τὸν πελάταν 133
mvp-comment-372-2
The comparison with Ixion is the more forcible here, since reference has just been made to the gratitude shown by Philoctetes (672). Ixion was the great example of ingratitude. Cp.
Pind.
P. 2. 21
mvp-comment-372-3 λέκτρων … τῶν Διὸς 134 τῶν 135
mvp-comment-373-1 κατὰ δρομάδ’ ἄμπυκα … Κρόνου παῖς 136 Ἰξίονα 137 δέσμιον 138 Ἰξίονα 139 δέσμιον 140 Ἰξίονα 141
mvp-comment-373-2 (1) The poet's tendency to omit the proper name in mythical allusion, when the context made his meaning clear, might be illustrated from Ant, 133, where Capaneus is described, yet not named; and from 966—987 of the same play, where Cleopatra—whose fate is being compared with Antigone's—is only indicated as the mother of the Phineidae (980) and the daughter of Boreas (985).
mvp-comment-373-3 (2) δέσμιον 142 κατ’ ἄμπυκα … ἔβαλεν 143 δέσμιον 144 κατ’ 145 ἀν’ 146
mvp-comment-373-4 Ἰξίον’ ἀν’ ἄμπυκα δὴ δρομάδ’ ὡς ἔβαλεν 147 δέσμιον 148
mvp-comment-373-5 ἄμπυκα 149 δρομάδα 150
mvp-comment-373-6
Cp. Hesych.,
mvp-comment-374-1 τοῦδ’ 152
mvp-comment-375-1 οὔτ’ ἔρξας τιν’, οὔ τι νοσφίσας 153 οὔ τι 154 οὔτε 155 οὐκ 156 νοσφίσας 157 ἔρξας 158 νοσφίσας 159
mvp-comment-376-1 ἴσος ὢν ἴσοις 160 ἴσος ὢν ἴσοις 161 ἴσος 162
mvp-comment-376-2 L has ἴσως 163 ἐν ἴσοις 164 ἔν γ’ 165
mvp-comment-377-1 ὤλλυθ’ 166
mvp-comment-377-2 The MS. text here is ὤλλυθ’ ὧδ’ ἀναξίως· τόδε θαῦμ’ ἔχει με 167 τόδε τοι θαῦμά μ’ ἔχει 168 τότ’ ἂν εἰλυόμενος 169 ὤλλυθ’ ὧδ’ ἀναξίως 170 εἷρπε γὰρ 171 εἷρπε δ’ 172 ὤλλυθ’ 173 ὠλέκεθ’ 174 ὤλλυτο τῇδ’ 175 ἀναξίως 176 ἄλλᾳ 177 ἀλλ 178 αχ 179 ᾷ 180
mvp-comment-378-1 ἀμφιπλάκτων 181 κλύζων 182
mvp-comment-379-1 βιοτὰν κατέσχεν 183
mvp-comment-380-1 ἵν’ αὐτὸς ἦν πρόσουρος 184 ἦν 185 οἱ 186 πρόσουρος 187
mvp-comment-380-2 οὐκ ἔχων βάσιν 188 πρόσουρον οὐκ ἔχων βάσιν 189 πρόδουλον … βάσιν 190 οὔτιν’ ἐς ἔγχωρον 191
mvp-comment-381-1 κακογείτονα 192
mvp-comment-381-2
Compounds to which
mvp-comment-381-3 The schol. joined κακογείτονα 193 στόνον 194 κακογείτονα 195
mvp-comment-382-1 παρ’ ᾧ 196 ἀποκλαύσειεν 197
mvp-comment-382-2 ἀντίτυπον 198
mvp-comment-382-3 βαρυβρῶτα … αἱματηρόν 199 στόνον 200
mvp-comment-383-1 ὃς τὰν 201 οὐδ’ ὃς τὰν 202 οὐδ’ 203 τὰν 204 ὃς τὰν 205 οὐδ’ ὃς 206
mvp-comment-383-2 αἱμάδα 207 κηκι—ομέναν 208
mvp-comment-383-3 ἑλκέων 209
mvp-comment-383-4 ἐνθήρου 210
mvp-comment-384-1 εἴ τις ἐμπέσοι 211 ἑλών 212 ἑλεῖν 213
mvp-comment-384-2 Some read εἴ τιν’ ἐμπέσοι 214 εἵ τι 215 συμπέσοι 216 ἑλεῖν 217
mvp-comment-384-3 φορβάδος 218
mvp-comment-385-1 εἷρπε 219 ἂν 220 εἷρπε 221 εἰλυόμενος 222
mvp-comment-386-1 παῖς … ὡς 223
mvp-comment-387-1 ὅθεν 224 ὅθεν ὑπάρχοι 225
mvp-comment-387-2 εὐμάρεια … πόρου 226 πόρων 227 πόρον 228
mvp-comment-387-3 ἐξανείη 229
mvp-comment-387-4 δακέθυμος 230
mvp-comment-388-1 ἱερᾶς 231
mvp-comment-388-2 αἴρων 232
mvp-comment-388-3 ἄλλων 233 φορβὰν 234 τῶν 235
mvp-comment-388-4 ἀλφησταί 236
mvp-comment-388-5 ἀνέρες 237 α— 238
mvp-comment-389-1 πτανοῖς 239
mvp-comment-389-2 ἰοῖς 240
mvp-comment-390-1 ψυχά, ὃς 241
mvp-comment-390-2 ὃς μηδ’ 242
mvp-comment-390-3 ἥσθη 243
mvp-comment-390-4 οἰνοχύτου 244
mvp-comment-390-5 δεκέτει χρόνῳ 245 δεκέτη χρόνον 246
mvp-comment-391-1 λεύσσων 247 ὅπου γνοίη 248 προσενώμα 249 εἰς στατὸν ὕδωρ 250 γνοίη 251 προσενώμα 252 στατὸν … ὕδωρ 253
mvp-comment-392-1 ἀνδρῶν ἀγ 254
mvp-comment-392-2 ὑπαντήσας 255
mvp-comment-393-1 ἀνύσει εὐδαίμων 256
mvp-comment-393-2 ἐκ κείνων 257
mvp-comment-394-1 ποντοπόρῳ 258
mvp-comment-394-2 δούρατι 259
mvp-comment-394-3 πλήθει … μηνῶν 260
mvp-comment-395-1 πατρίαν 261 πατρῴαν 262
mvp-comment-395-2 Μαλιάδων 263 αὐλὰν 264 ὄχθας 265
mvp-comment-395-3 παρ’ ὄχθας 266 Σπερχειοῦ τε 267 Σπερχειοῖο 268 ὄχθαις 269
mvp-comment-396-1 ὁ χάλκασπις ἀνὴρ 270
mvp-comment-396-2 In this play Heracles figures especially as the former possessor of the invincible bow. Why, then, has Soph. here chosen an epithet, χάλκασπις 271
mvp-comment-397-1 πλάθει 272 πλάθη 273 θείῳ πυρὶ παμφαής 274
mvp-comment-397-2
*
mvp-comment-397-3
The burning of Heracles, and his apotheosis, are combined in some vase paintings. (1) A bowl (
mvp-comment-398-1 ὄχθων 282
mvp-comment-399-1 εἰ θέλεις 283
mvp-comment-400-1 ἀπόπληκτος ἔχει 284
mvp-comment-401-1 τί δ’ ἔστιν 285 τί ἔστιν 286
mvp-comment-402-1 τῆς παρεστώσης 287
mvp-comment-402-2 735 The intrans. κουφίζειν 288
mvp-comment-402-3 736 f. I follow A here (see cr. n.), for a reason which was felt by Hermann, but which has not been sufficiently considered by some other editors,—viz., that ἰὼ θεοί 289 ἰὼ θεοί 290
mvp-comment-402-4 τί θεοὺς ἀναστένων καλεῖς 291 θεοὺς 292
mvp-comment-403-1 κυρῶν 293
mvp-comment-404-1 διέρχεται 294
mvp-comment-404-2 βρύκομαι 295
mvp-comment-404-3 746 Written as above, the exclamations represent three successive cries of pain, each longer than the last, as the agony becomes sharper; they seem to suggest the convulsive movement of the lips from which the sounds are wrung.
mvp-comment-405-1 εἴ τί σοι ξίφος πρόχειρον 296 χεροῖν 297
mvp-comment-405-2 πάταξον εἰς ἄκρον πόδα 298
603. mvp-comment-427-1 ἴσως . . ἀκήκοας] 'For I dare say you have not heard of it.' The important share of Neoptolemus in the prophecy of Helenus is studiously concealed, and it is assumed that in his short stay at Troy the circumstance may have escaped him altogether. The true account is given by Neoptolemus afterwards, infr. 1337 foll. He himself in supr. 344 foll. had professed to attach slight importance to the assertion that he was destined to take Troy.
607. mvp-comment-428-1 ἀκούων] 'Called by,' i.e. deserving. αἰσχρὰ.. ἔπη] 'Names of disgrace and contumely.' On the meaning of the verbal adjective, see Essay on L. § 53. p. 98.
609. mvp-comment-429-1 ἔδειξ᾽.. ἐς μέσον] Displayed publicly to the Achaeans. ἔδειξε marks Odysseus' pride at bringing in his captive. Cp. infr. 616, δηλώσειν : 630, δεῖξαι: 944, φήνασθαι.
610. mvp-comment-430-1 The part of the prophecy which relates to Neoptolemus is thus slurred over.
611. mvp-comment-431-1 τἀπὶ Τροίᾳ πέργαμα] Cp.supr. 353.
612. mvp-comment-432-1 πέρσοιεν (as being the oratio obliqua of πέρσετε) seems to be an exception to the rule that οὐ μή takes after it not the future indicative, but the aorist subjunctive. But this is not a sufficient ground for altering the reading. Paley compares Plat. Crito, p. 44 B, οὐδένα μήποτε εὑρήσω.
613. mvp-comment-433-1 ἄγοιντο] The middle voice implies, 'Should bring for their purpose.' νήσου τῆσδ'] For the genitive of place, see Essay on L. § 8. p. 11, a. Observe the alliteration in νήσου .. ναίει .. νῦν.
614. mvp-comment-434-1 ταῦτα] Governed of ἤκουσε and resumed with τὸν μάντιν εἰπόντα, which is added to complete the sentence.
615ff. mvp-comment-435-1 The statement in supr. 593-7 is here repeated with some additional circumstances.
617. mvp-comment-436-1 οἴοιτο] The optative is used in turning the parenthetical οἴομαι into the oratio obliqua, as if ὅτι had preceded. Cp. Lys p. 130, Θηραμένης ἀναστὰς λέγει ὅτι ποιήσει ὥστε τὴν πόλιν ἐλαττῶσαι μηδέν· οἴοιτο δὲ καὶ ἄλλο τι ἀγαθὸν εὑρήσεσθαι.
618-619. mvp-comment-437-1 'And if he failed in this, he offered his head to any who chose, to cut it off.' For the order of words, see Essay on L. § 41, α. p. 77. κάρα governed (1) of ἐφεῖτο, and (2) οἱ τέμνειν, which is epexegetic inf. μὴ τυχών = εἰ μὴ τύχοι. For the sense, cp. II. 2. 259, μηκέτ᾽ ἔπειτ᾽ Ὀδυσῆϊ κάρη ὤμοισιν ἐπείη, κ.τ.λ.: Od. 16. 102 αὐτίκ᾽ ἔπειτ' ἀπ᾿ ἐμεῖο κάρη τάμοι ἀλλότριος φώς, εἰ μή, κ.τ.λ. τέμνειν = ἀποτέμνειν. Cp. καράτομος.
620. mvp-comment-438-1 τὸ σπεύδειν] The article probably refers to supr. 576, 7.
621. mvp-comment-439-1 κεἴ τινος κήδει πέρι] Sc. παραινῶ ἐκείνῳ τὸ αὐτό. The supposed stranger does not venture to compromise himself by giving this advice directly to Philoctetes. He alludes to supr. 585, 6.
622. mvp-comment-440-1 Οι ἡ πᾶσα βλάβη, ‘That utter pest.' see Essay on L. § 51. p. 95; and cp. El. 301.
624-625. mvp-comment-441-1 'The persuasion that has force to bring me back to Troy, would fetch me from the dead.'
626. mvp-comment-442-1 οὐκ οἶδ᾽ ἐγὼ ταῦτ] The professed Ἔμπορος is too discreet to mix further than he can help in such a hazardous business. Cp. O. Τ. 530, οὐκ οἶδ᾽· ὁ γὰρ δρῶσ᾽ οἱ κρατοῦντες οὐχ ὁρῶ. The purpose of his coming has been accomplished, and he retires. For the synaphea, cp. especially O. T. 555, ὡς χρείη μ᾽ ἐπὶ | τὸν σεμνόμαντιν, κ.τ.λ.
627. mvp-comment-443-1 σφῶν.. θεός] 'May heaven be with you both for your best good!' συμφέρειν is used nearly as συμφέρεσθαι in O. C. 641, τῇδε γὰρ ξυνοίσομαι (‘Your choice shall have my concurrence').
628ff. mvp-comment-444-1 Should have imagined it possible ever with cajoling words to bring and show me on his ship amongst the Argives.' Philoctetes has hitherto had his attention fixed on the Ἔμπορος, and has said ll. 622-5 half to himself. But as the stranger departs he turns to Neoptolemus with these indignant words.
629. mvp-comment-445-1 ποτ᾿ ἄν with δεῖξαι = ὅτι δείξειεν ἄν ποτε. λόγοισι μαλθακοῖς] Cp. O. С. 774, σκληρὰ μαλθακῶς λέγων.
630. mvp-comment-446-1 δείξαι] Cp. supr. 616, δηλώσειν. δεῖξαι νεὼς ἄγοντα = δεῖξαι ἐκ νεὰς ἄγοντα ἐπὶ νηΐ. Or, in other words, the phrase, On ship-board,' which should depend on ἄγοντα, is attracted into a new construction with δεῖξαι. See Essay on L. § 35. p. 60, and cp. О. Т. 808, ὄχου . . τηρήσας. κ.τ.λ. : Εl. 900. Herm. and Schndw. take νεὼς ἄγοντα to mean, 'Bringing ashore.' Cp. supr. 355-7. But ἄγειν is continually used elsewhere in the play for conveyance by sea; and the instrumental dative λόγοισι μαλθακοῖς connects more naturally with ἄγοντα than with δεῖξαι. Moreover, the meaning obtained by so joining νεὼς ἄγοντ' is wanting in simplicity.
631. mvp-comment-447-1 οὔ] Those who have suspected this reading have not observed the frequency of asyndeton in the language of Philoctetes (Essay on L. § 34. p. 58). The proposed readings, οὗ θᾶσσον (Welcker), ἢ θᾶσσον (Schndw.), are less forcible than the MS. text. Schndw. imagined οὔ to be a marginal gloss on ἢ. For the double superlative in πλεῖστον ἐχθίστης, see Essay on L. § 40. p. 76.
632. mvp-comment-448-1 ἄπουν = οὐκ ἔχοντα βάσιν, infr. 692.
633. mvp-comment-449-1 ἐκείνῳ.. λεκτά] 'He is capable of saying anything.' Cp. O. С. 495, ἐμοὶ μὲν οὐχ ὁδωτά : ibid. 1000, 1, εἶ γὰρ οὐ δίκαιος, ἀλλ᾽ ἅπαν καλὸν | λέγειν νομίζων, ῥητὸν ἄρρητόν τ᾽ ἔπος.
635-636. mvp-comment-450-1 ὡς.. ὁρίζῃ] • That wide seas may part us.'
637. mvp-comment-451-1 ἥ τοι.. ἤγαγεν] Cp. Aj. 674,5, ἐκοίμισε . . πόντον, and note.
639. mvp-comment-452-1 ἐπειδὰν πνεῦμα τοὐκ πρώρας ἀνῇ] When this head wind (1) ceases' (ἀνῇ absolute), or (2) 'lets us go' (ἀνῇ ἡμᾶς, sc.). The same doubt occurs in Hdt. 2. 113, οὐ γὰρ ἀνίει τὰ πνεύματα (sc. μιν?) Cp. Od. 19. 199, ἔνθα δυώδεκα μὲν μένον ἤματα δίοι ᾿Αχαιοί, | εἴλει γὰρ βορέης ἄνεμος μέγας, κ.τ.λ. | τῇ τρισκαιδεκάτῃ δ' ἄνεμος πέσε, τοὶ δ᾽ ἀνάγοντο. The correction of Pierson here is all but certain.
641. mvp-comment-453-1 Cp. Il. 14. 80, οὐ γάρ τις νέμεσις φυγέειν κακόν, οὐδ᾽ ἀνὰ νύκτα,
642. mvp-comment-454-1 οὔκ· ἀλλά] 'Nay, but -.' οὐ denies the general drift of the preceding line; i. e. The evil is not so imminent that you need fly from it with such haste. Cp. Plat. Rep. 6. 491 Ε, οὔκ, ἀλλά, ἢ δ᾽ ὅς, οὕτως, where there is a nearly similar inexactness of response. There is no sufficient ground for transposing 643, 4, 2, 1, with Prof. Paley. The order is far more natural as it stands.
643-644. mvp-comment-455-1 'Robbers feel not any contrary wind when it is a time to steal and take by force.'
645. mvp-comment-456-1 χωρῶμεν, ἔνδοθεν λαβών] 'Let us depart, when you have taken from within.' The participle agrees with part of the subject, and the second person has been implied in εἰ δοκεῖ, SC. σοι. For the limitation of subject, see Essay on L. § 33. p. 56, and cp. Trach. 205, ὀλολύξατε δόμοις, | ὁ μελλόνυμφος, ἐν δὲ κοινὸς ἀρσένων | ἴτω κλάγγα, κ.τ.λ. : ib. 333: Aesch. Eum. 141.
648. mvp-comment-457-1 What, that is not somewhere on board my ship?' νεώς, partitive genitive. Essay on L. § 10. p. 15. Ср. Αj. 659, γαίας ὀρύξας ἔνθα, κ.τ.λ.: Ο. C. 694, γᾶς ᾿Ασίας οὐκ ἐπακούω. τοῦθ᾽ ὅ is singular, though ὧν in 647 is plural. Essay on L. § 20, B. p. 31.
649. mvp-comment-458-1 φύλλον . . πάρεστιν] 'There is a leaf which I have.' Cp. infr. 704, ὅθεν εὐμάρει᾽ ὑπάρχοι: supr. 44: Ο.Τ. 766.
650. mvp-comment-459-1 πραΰνειν] 'To assuage its violence.' There is no example of πραΰνειν being used intransitively. πρᾷος is opposed to ἄγριος, cp. supr. 265. Philoctetes is eager to assure Neoptolemus that the evil is not intractable. Cp. infr. 733 foll.
651. mvp-comment-460-1 τί γὰρ ἔτ᾽ ἄλλ᾽ ἐρᾷς λαβεῖν] Philoctetes shows by his manner that the herb is not the only thing that he requires. To this look of longing hesitation γάρ refers.
652. mvp-comment-461-1 εἰ.. παρερρύηκεν] This is said to explain his unsatisfied look (' I would make search,' implied in ἐρᾷς λαβεῖν), * in case some of these my arrows may have slipped from my side.' Cp. Il. 13. 256, ἔρχομαι, εἴ τί τοι ἔγχος ἐνὶ κλισίῃσι λέλειπται, | οἰσόμενος.
653. mvp-comment-462-1 ὡς λίπω μή] For the order, see Essay on L. § 41, γ. p. 78.
655. mvp-comment-463-1 οὐ γὰρ ἄλλα γ᾽ ἔσθ'] 'For indeed there is no other.' These words have been commonly taken as equivalent to ἐκεῖνα καὶ οὐκ ἄλλα: whence Blaydes conjectures ταῦτ᾽ οὐ γὰρ οὖν ἔστ᾿ ἄλλ'. But the meaning given above is more in point. Cp. Morris' Story of Sigurd, That hath not the like in the heavens, nor hath earth of its fellow told.'
656. mvp-comment-464-1 ἆρ᾿ ἔστιν ὥστε] 'Is it possible that one might?' ὥστε as after verbs of permission asked or obtained. The periphrasis is expressive of modesty. κἀγγύθεν] From close at hand, as well as from a distance. For με added in the second clause, cp. supr. 257.
657. mvp-comment-465-1 For the sacredness of the bow, cp. infr. 943.
658. mvp-comment-466-1 τῶν ἐμῶν] Of things within my power.'
659. mvp-comment-467-1 ὁποῖον. ξυμφέρῃ] 'That is of a nature to accord with your desires.' Cp. supr. 627, and note. γενήσεται] 'Shall be granted.'
661. mvp-comment-468-1 πάρες] 'Let it go by;' i.e. Take no more notice of my wish.
662. mvp-comment-469-1 ὅσια .. φωνεῖς] 'Your words are blameless.' 'You speak innocently.'
663. mvp-comment-470-1 For the suppressed antecedent in the expression of strong feeling, see Essay on L. § 39. p. 72, 2. And for the emphatic repetition of ὅς, cp. O. C. 610, φθίνει μὲν ἰσχὺς γῆς, φθίνει δὲ σώματος, and see E. on L. § 44. p. 83.
664. mvp-comment-471-1 μόνος] Supr. 500.
665. mvp-comment-472-1 πέρα] 'Above their reach.' 'Where they cannot come.' ἀνιστάναι here is not merely 'To raise upright,' but To set up on high.' Cр. O. С. 661-3, κείνοις δ᾽ ἴσως κεὶ δείν᾽ ἐπερρώσθη λέγειν | τῆς σῆς ἀγωγῆς, οἶδ᾽ ἐγώ, φανή- | σεται | μακρὸν τὸ δεῦρο πέλαγος, οὐδὲ πλώσιμον: Aesch. Cho. 789.
666. mvp-comment-473-1 θιγγάνειν] ‘To handle for a while.’ This word, expressing a lingering process, is rightly in the continuous tense, although δόντι . . ἐξεπεύξασθαι are aorists. Cp. Il. 6. 322, τόξ᾽ ἁφόωντα.
667. mvp-comment-474-1 καὶ δόντι δοῦναι] This illogical addition is singularly expressive of the nervous anxiety of Philoctetes at the thought of giving the bow out of his hands: 'You shall have it in your grasp; I will give it you, and you will give it me again; and then you shall freely boast, etc.' While saying this, Philoctetes does not at once give the bow to Neoptolemus. Cp. infr. 762 foll.
669. mvp-comment-475-1 Cp. infr. 801-3.
670-672. mvp-comment-476-1 These three lines seem out of place. Either there is a lacuna after 670, or they have crept into the text out of the margin, where some hand had inserted them as an apposite quotation from some other play. They have not the appearance of a deliberate interpolation, nor is the difficulty obviated by assigning them to Neoptolemus. If they are retained, they can only mean, 'I do not feel this generous action burdensome, now that I have seen and found a friend in you. For no possession can be equal to a friend who knows (as I am sure you do) how to return kindness for kindness done to him.' In other words, to secure so true a friend as Neoptolemus, even the effort of relinquishing the bow for a moment is not too much. But ἄχθομαι has no object; and the promised kindness of Neoptolemus was not conditional on his being allowed to handle the bow.
675-714. mvp-comment-477-1 The preceding scene was calculated to deepen the feeling of compassion for Philoctetes, which had already been awakened both in Neoptolemus and in the Chorus. His generous willingness to trust them with his all, contrasted with their felt dissimulation, has intensified the sympathy which Neoptolemus afterwards avows, 905, 965, 6. Yet the Chorus do not imagine for a moment that their master will relinquish his purpose. Hence, while sincerely pouring forth their lament over Philoctetes' innocent sufferings (which they can only compare with the torment of the guilty Ixion), and really rejoicing in the prospect of his deliverance, they maintain, as in duty bound (since they are within hearing of the cave), the deceptive notion of the voyage to Trachis, and make no mention of Troy. But it must be borne in mind that from the prophecy of Helenus, of which they knew, they had every reason to suppose that the return to Troy, though Philoctetes was averse to it, would be for his good. While this stasimon is being sung (whether by half-choruses or by the whole together), Neoptolemus is with Philoctetes in the cave, and is finding still more cogent evidence of his misery. This stasimon consists of two strophes and antistrophes, of which the first are chiefly logaoedic, the second chiefly choriambic.
675-714.
mvp-comment-477-2
α'.
1 _uu_u_u_
_uu__uu_u_
_uu_uu_
_uu_u_u_u_
5 _u_u_u_
10 __u_u_u__
_u_u_
_uu_u_ _
_uu_u_ _
_uu_u_uu__
_uu_uu__
5 __u_ _
_uu_u_uu_u_uu_u_
_u_uu___u_uu_u_
_uu__
675. mvp-comment-478-1 ὄπωπα δ᾽ οὐ μάλα] ‘Though I never actually saw.' μάλα emphasizes οὐκ ὄπωπα, because seeing is more than hearing. The sorrow of Philoctetes is patent to the eye.
676. mvp-comment-479-1 ποτέ belongs to the verbal notion in πελάταν. Cp. supr. 147.
677. mvp-comment-480-1 Ιξίονα (see v. rr.) is omitted in the text as possibly arising from a gloss. Cp. Trach. 840.
678. mvp-comment-481-1 ἄμπυξ is (a) a frontlet; hence (b) may be here understood to mean the convex external surface of a wheel. ἄμπυκα δρομάδα = 'A rolling rim.' A conjectural reading, ἄντυγα, was proposed by Musgrave. But ἄντυξ, in the literal sense, is no more 'a wheel' than ἄμπυξ.
679. mvp-comment-482-1 ἔβαλεν] Although ἔλαβε, the MS. reading, is not impossible, if we suppose δέσμιον proleptic ('seized bound' for 'seized and bound'), ἔβαλεν gives a better sense. Cp. O. C. 475. Mr. Paley reads, κατ᾿ ἄμπυκα δὴ δρομάδ᾽ ὡς βάλε δέσμιον ὁ π. Κ. π. For the metre of this, cp. infr. 863, 4, 1114, 5; О. С. 253, 4.
680. mvp-comment-483-1 For ἐσίδον, which is the reading of the first hand of L. and of Par. A, cp. El. 205.
681. mvp-comment-484-1 τοῦδ᾽ ἐχθίονι] See Essay on L. § 10. p. 15, 2 a.
682. mvp-comment-485-1 'Who having neither harmed nor defrauded any.' Cp. Od. 4. 690, οὔτε τινὰ ῥέξας ἐξαίσιον, οὔτε τι εἰπών. The use of ἔρδειν absolutely for ἔρδειν τι κακόν is singular, but is assisted by νοσφίσας following. Cp. the frequent use of παθεῖν τι for παθεῖν τι κακόν. Mr. Paley strangely interprets, 'Having imprisoned any' (as if from ἔργω).
683. mvp-comment-486-1 ἔν *γ᾽ ἴσοις] This, Hermann's, emendation of ἐν ἴσοις is adopted as the most probable. 'Just, at least amongst the just; i.e. One sure to have been esteemed righteous, if he had lived amongst righteous men. Cp. (for the form of expression, not for the meaning οἱ ἴσος) O. T. 677, ἐν δὲ τοῖσδ᾽ ἴσος. The force of ye is to throw blame by implication on the Argives at Troy, who treated Philoctetes as if he had been a malefactor.
684. mvp-comment-487-1 The metre requires some change. Dindorf reads ὠλέκεθ᾽ ὧδ᾽. But τῇδε has more point than ὧδε, and connects better with what follows.
685. mvp-comment-488-1 τόδε. . ἔχει] 'At this I marvel.' τόδε is accusative after θαῦμ᾽ ἔχει με = θαυμάζω. Cp. Od. 20. 217, αὐτὰρ ἐμοὶ τόδε θυμὸς .. πόλλ᾽ ἐπιδινεῖται.
686. mvp-comment-489-1 'How then he retained his hold of a life so steeped in tears.' Cp. supr. 535, διέζων and note, infr. 1158-60.
687. mvp-comment-490-1 ἵν᾿ αὐτὸς ἦν πρόσουρος] Sc. ἑαυτῷ. Schndw. cp. Lucian. Timon. θεοῖς θυέτω καὶ εὐωχείσθω μόνος ἑαυτῷ γείτων καὶ ὅμορος. The phrase is an oxymoron. Cp. Aesch. Cho. 866, μόνος ὢν ἔφεδρος, (‘Having none to second him'). οὐκ ἔχων βάσιν] 'Without power of movement.' Cp. supr. 632, ἄπουν, and, for the meaning of the verbal noun, supr. 18, ἐνθάκησις, and note. Bothe's ingenious correction, ἵν᾽ αὐτὸς ἦν, πρόσουρον οὐκ ἔχων βάσιν ( cp. supr. 171, μηδὲ σύντροφον ὄμμ᾽ ἔχων), is inadmissible, (1) as too diffuse, and (2) because αὐτός εἶμι, “I am by myself,' is not a poetical expression for the misery of solitude. This and the following lines are an echo and expansion of Philoctetes' complaint, supr. 280 foll. ἄνδρα δ᾽ οὐδέν᾽ ἔντοπον, | οὐχ ὅστις ἀρκέσειεν, οὐδ᾽ ὅστις νόσου | κάμνοντι συλλάβοιτο. Lambinus gives an odd explanation of πρόσ-ουρος, 'expositus ventis.'
688. mvp-comment-491-1 κακογείτονα] ‘To be a neighbour to his misery.’ This, as Lessing saw (Laoc. p. 37), = γείτονα κακῶν οἱ ἐν κακοῖς.
689-691. mvp-comment-492-1 By bringing *τάν from before θερμοτάταν, where it injures the metre, to before βαρυβρῶτ', where a syllable is required, we obtain a possible construction for these lines. In whose ear he might lament, with groaning that had response (ἀντίτυπον), the disease (τάν, sc. νόσον) so cruelly gnawing, so dripping with gore.
689. mvp-comment-493-1 στόνον ἀντίτυπον is thus cognate accusative with ἀποκλαύσειεν, i.e. So as to receive groan for groan.' Cp. Ant. 592, ἀντιπλῆγες ἀκταί.
692. mvp-comment-494-1 ἐνθήρου] ( Cp. supr. 226, ἀπηγριωμένον) 'That has lost the human shape,' no longer recognizable as that of a human being. Cp. Aesch. Ag. 562, τιθέντες ἔνθηρον τρίχα. The etymological analysis of the word is difficult, perhaps = θηρσὶν ἐναριθμούμενος.
693. mvp-comment-495-1 εἴ τις ἐμπέσοι (sc. αἱμάς)] 'If any attacked him;' i.e. If the bleeding at any time came on.
694. mvp-comment-496-1 φορβάδος.. ἑλεῖν] ‘Or to take them' (the herbs) 'from the sustaining earth.' There is a slight change of construction; i. e ἑλεῖν = ὅστις ἕλοι, and the order of language, as elsewhere ( Essay on L. § 41, B. p. 77 ) reverses the order of fact. This passage has given needless trouble. Mr. Paley reads ἕλοι.
695. mvp-comment-497-1 *εἶρπε.. ἄν] Cp. supr. 290 foll. *ἀλλαχά] This is the simplest change (see v.rr.), which restores correspondence of strophe and antistrophe. Others read ἀτίμως for ἀναξίως in supr. 686. So τότε is antecedent to ἁνίκα in 704.
696. mvp-comment-498-1 εἰλυόμενος . . τιθήνας] 'Crawling, like a child without the kindly nurse.' So the Chorus expand the suggestive word εἰλυόμην in 291; i.e. He needed the support of hands as well as feet in the rocky paths.
697. mvp-comment-499-1 ὅθεν εὐμάρει᾽ ὑπάρχοι] 'To the place where a supply for his wants (the herb for his pain, the birds for his hunger) was to be found.' πόρον.. ἐξανείη] 'Left him the power of motion; i. e. Allowed him to move again. As the pain might be said ἐμποδίζειν πόρον, so when it ceases it is said ἐξανιέναι πόρον. Cp. Aj.674-6. This seems the most likely interpretation of a difficult passage. For other suggestions, see Herm., Schndw., Nauck, Dindorf, Paley.
699-700. mvp-comment-500-1 (1) 'Not lifting for his sustenance the sown-produce' ( cp. Hdt. 4.53) 'of the sacred earth, nor sustenance afforded by other things which we, industrious men, enjoy.' If this is right, φορβάν, which in l. 706 is in apposition to σπόρον ( cp. Plat. Legg. 12. 958 E, ὅσα τροφὴν μήτηρ οὖσα ἡ γῆ πέφυκε βούλεσθαι φέρειν), is to be resumed in l. 707 as the immediate object of αἴρων. (2) Another way is to take σπορόν (sic) as an adjective. Cp. τορός, τομός. 'Not taking up the sown sustenance afforded by the sacred earth, nor the sustenance afforded by other things, etc.'
702. mvp-comment-501-1 πτανῶν πτανοῖς] (1) 'From his winged arrows by means of winged birds' (ὀρνέοις, Scholiast). Cp. supr. 288, 9, τὰς ὑποπτέρους | βάλλον πελείας. Or (2) 'With winged shafts (instrum. dat.) he contrived a sustenance consisting of winged birds' (gen. of material). There is no sufficient ground for suspecting the reading. Perhaps, however, πτανάν, agreeing with φορβάν, would be better than πτανῶν. Cp. infr. 1146, πταναὶ θῆραι. For the tautology in φορβάδος, φορβάν, φορβάν, see Essay on L. § 44. pp. 83, 4.
703. mvp-comment-502-1 ψυχά] Cp. supr. 55 and note.
704. mvp-comment-503-1 For the genitive with ἥσθη, see Essay on L. § 10. p. 16, 5 , and, for the dative χρόνῳ, ibid. § 11. p. 18, b.
705. mvp-comment-504-1 λεύσσων . . εἰς] 'Looking to,' in dependence. Cp. El. 925, μηδὲν ἐς κεῖνόν γ᾽ ὅρα. στατόν] The remark of Odysseus, supr. 21, εἴπερ ἐστὶ σῶν, showed that the fountain was not an abundant one, such as would afford a perennial stream of living water.
706. mvp-comment-505-1 αἰεὶ προσενώμα] 'Fetched it for his daily need.' He had the labour of fetching it continually as he required it.
707. mvp-comment-506-1 ἀνδρῶν ἀγαθῶν] ‘Of a brave hero,' i. e. Achilles. Poetical plural. παιδὶ συναντήσας is a good conjecture of Fröhlich.
708. mvp-comment-507-1 'He shall win happiness and glory after being so low.' εὐδαίμων is predicative and proleptic-ἐς τὸ εὐδαίμων εἶναι. Cp. Ο. Τ. 166, ἠνύσατ' ἐκτοπίαν φλόγα πήματος, i. e. ὥστε ἐκτοπίαν γενέσθαι. κείνων refers to 691-718.
709. mvp-comment-508-1 πλήθει πολλῶν μηνῶν] 'In the fulness of many months.' Cр. О. Т. 156, περιτελλομέναις ὥραις : Aesch. Ag. 504, δεκάτῳ σε φέγγει τῷδ᾽ ἀφικόμην ἔτους: Trach. 824, 5, ὁπότε τελεόμηνος ἐκφέροι | δωδέκατος ἄροτος.
710. mvp-comment-509-1 πατρώαν.. αὐλάν] ‘Τo his father's hall.’ The change to πατρίαν, adopted by most editors- cp. supr. τὰ πάτρια τεύχεα seems to be required for the metre, _uu_u_uu_u_uu_u_ (ἀνύσειε γαστρὶ φορβάν, supr. 712). But see l. 1100, λῳονος.
711-712. mvp-comment-510-1 'Beside the banks of the Spercheius, that are haunted by the Melian nymphs' (literally, 'Belonging to the Melian nymphs and (the river-god) Spercheius'). This is a more natural connection for the words Μηλιάδων νυμφᾶν than when they are joined with the preceding line.
712. mvp-comment-511-1 ὁ χάλκασπις ἀνήρ] Heracles. The epithet is picturesque. The orbed shield reflecting the sunlight from the top of Oeta suggests the glory which the hero has amongst the gods, and the fire which consumed his mortality.
713. mvp-comment-512-1 †πᾶσιν] If this is retained, it is necessary to read εἴ που for ὅπου in the strophe, with Brunck. But Hermann's correction, πάλαι, is not improbable. The passage is to be differently interpreted according as πλάθει is regarded: whether as a literal, or as an historical present. If the latter is correct, then θείῳ πυρί may refer to the golden cloud that descended to take up Heracles from the pyre. If the former, we must suppose a natural confusion between Heracles on Oeta and Heracles in Olympus.
715-716. mvp-comment-513-1 The last antistrophe was intended for the hearing of Philoctetes, and it is probable that, before it ended, he and Neoptolemus had already appeared from the cave. He now suddenly becomes motionless and speechless. εἰ θέλεις] 'Will you?' Neoptolemus professes unconsciousness of the cause of Philoctetes' apparent change of purpose. ἐξ οὐδενὸς λόγου] 'With no apparent cause.' 'Without assigning a reason.' Cp. O. C. 620, ἐκ σμικροῦ λόγου.
716. mvp-comment-514-1 ἀπόπληκτος . . ἔχει] 'Stand stupefied and caught.' Cp. Aj. 1144, 5, ἡνίκ᾽ ἐν κακῷ | χειμῶνος εἴχετο.
717. mvp-comment-515-1 The agony which he has in vain endeavoured to suppress forces a cry from Philoctetes against his will. Presently (ll. 733-5), he again assumes indifference, but is again overpowered, and cries to the gods for help.
719. mvp-comment-516-1 οὐδὲν δεινόν] 'No matter for alarm.' Cp. Trach. 459, τὸ δ᾽ εἰδέναι τί δεινόν; and cp. esp. O. C. 1200.
720. mvp-comment-517-1 τῆς παρεστώσης νόσου] i. e. τῆς νόσου παρεστώσης σοι. Cp. infr. 765.
721. mvp-comment-518-1 κουφίζειν] Sc. τὴν νόσον.
723. mvp-comment-519-1 In some MSS. οὕτως is read after θεούς, and Seidler and others have suggested that ὦ θεοί· τί τοὺς θεοὺς ὧδ᾽ ἀναστένων καλεῖς; should be read. But cp. Aj. 588, 9. It must be admitted however that the want of caesura is a reason for suspecting something wrong.
724. mvp-comment-520-1 'That they should interpose mercifully to save us.' (αὐτούς unemphatic.) Even here the suffering of Philoctetes is not merely physical. This attack of pain is threatening him with the frustration of his hopes.
727. mvp-comment-521-1 This passage, like El. 610, 1, O. T. 746, indicates the use of significant action by the person who is not speaking.
728. mvp-comment-522-1 For the omission of the article before κακόν, cp. supr. 83, and note, and see E. on L. § 21. p. 33, b.
729. mvp-comment-523-1 διέρχεται] 'It pierces.' Cp. infr. 791, 2.
731. mvp-comment-524-1 βρύκομαι] 'I am torn as with teeth.' Cp. Trach. 987, ἡ δ᾽ αὖ μιαρὰ βρύκει.
732. mvp-comment-525-1 παπαῖ] This exclamation of pain expresses the effort to close the lips alternating with the utterance of an involuntary cry.
733. mvp-comment-526-1 πρόχειρον] 'Ready to your hand.' πρόχειρος is one of the words which are used etymologically' in tragedy. ( Essay on L. § 54. pp. 99, 100. ) Cp. Eur. Hel. 1563, 4, φάσγανόν θ᾽ ἅμα | πρόχειρον ὤθει.
734. mvp-comment-527-1 εἰς ἄκρον πόδα] The force of ἄκρος in such phrases is not to be pressed. But cp. infr. 824.
736. mvp-comment-528-1 ἴθ᾽, ὦ παῖ] 'Do so, I pray thee, my son.' (Not, as supr. 733, where ἴθι is, 'Go on.')