Lewis Campbell Philoctetes 6

ed. Lewis Campbell

Philoctetes. Lewis Campbell. ed. Lewis Campbell. Oxford. 1879.

Current edition Experimental

Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879) (OCR draft) (English) (Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879))

Provisional text from uncorrected OCR; expect errors.

Editions (2)
Greek (Lewis Campbell, 1879) (OCR draft) Experimental (Greek (Lewis Campbell, 1879)) — 782 focus
ἀλλὰ ἄλλα ἀλλὰ ἀλλ᾽ οὐ δέδοικ, ὦ a from a ὦ παῖ, μή μ' ἀτελὴς εὔχῃ εὐχή·
ἀλγῶ πάλαι δὴ τἀπὶ σοὶ στένων κακά.
ἀλλ᾽ ὅδε μὲν κλύει οὐδέν, ἐγὼ δ᾽ ὁρῶ οἵνεκα θήραν
τήνδ᾽ ἁλίως ἔχομεν τόξων, δίχα τοῦδε πλέοντες.
840
τοῦδε γὰρ ὁ στέφανος, τοῦτον θεὸς εἶπε κομίζειν.
κομπεῖν δ᾽ ἔστ᾽ ἀτελῆ σὺν σὺμ σὺν ψεύδεσιν αἰσχρὸν ὄνειδος.
σιγᾶν κελεύω, μηδ' ἀφεστάναι φρενῶν.
865
κινεῖ γὰρ ἁνὴρ ἀνὴρ ὄμμα κἀνάγει κάρα.
ἔσται τάδ'· ἀλλ᾽ ἵστω τε καὐτὸς ἀντέχου.
Greek (F. Storr, 1912) (OCR draft) Experimental (Greek (F. Storr, 1912)) — 827-864 focus
Translations (5)
English (Lewis Campbell, 1906) (OCR draft) Experimental (English (Lewis Campbell, 1906)) — 782 focus
Ah! but I fear, my son, thy prayer is vain:
For welling yet again from depths within,
This gory ooze is dripping. It will come!
I know it will. O, foot, torn helpless thing,
785
What wilt thou do to me? Ah! ah! It comes,
It is at hand. ’Tis here! Woe’s me, undone!
I have shown you all. Stay near me. Go not far:
Ah! ah!
O island king, I would this agony
790
Might cleave thy bosom through and through! Woe, woe!
Woe! Ah! ye two commanders of the host,
Agamemnon, Menelaüs, O that ye,
Another ten years’ durance in my room
795
Might nurse this malady! O Death, Death, Death!
I call thee daily—wilt thou never come?
Will it not be?—My son, thou noble boy,
If thou art noble, take and burn me there
Aloft in yon all-worshipped Lemnian fire!
800
Yea, when the bow thou keep’st was my reward,
I did like service for the child of Heaven.
How now, my son?
What say’st? Art silent? Where—where art thou, boy?
My heart is full, and groaning o’er thy woes.
Lord of the happiest life,
Sleep, thou that know’st not strife,
That know’st not grief,
Still wafting sure relief,
Come, saviour now!
830
Thy healing balm is spread
Over this pain worn head,
Quench not the beam that gives calm to his brow.
Look, O my lord, to thy path,
Either to go or to stay
How is my thought to proceed?
835
What is our cause for delay?
835
Look! Opportunity’s power,
Fitting the task to the hour,
Giveth the race to the swift.
He hears not. But I see that to have ta’en
His bow without him were a bootless gain
He must sail with us. So the god hath said
840
Heaven hath decreed this garland for his head:
And to have failed with falsehood were a meed
Of shameful soilure for a shameless deed.
God shall determine the end—
But for thine answer, friend,
Waft soft words low!
All sick men’s sleep, we know,
845
Hath open eye;
Their quickly ruffling mind
Quivers in lightest wind,
Sleepless in slumber new danger to spy.
Think, O my lord, of thy path,
Secretly look forth afar,
850
What wilt thou do for thy need?
How with the wise wilt thou care?
If toward the nameless thy heart
Chooseth this merciful part,
Huge are the dangers that drift.
855
The wind is fair, my son, the wind is fair,
The man is dark and helpless, stretched in night.
(O kind, warm sleep that calmest human care!)
Powerless of hand and foot and ear and sight,
Blind, as one lying in the house of death.
(Think well if here thou utterest timely breath.)
860
This, O my son, is all my thought can find,
Best are the toils that without frightening bind.
Hush! One word more were madness. He revives.
865
His eye hath motion. He uplifts his head.
I will; stand up, endure!
German (J. J. C. Donner, 1875; OCR review) (OCR draft) Experimental (German (J. J. C. Donner, 1875; OCR review)) — 782 focus
Ich fürchte, Jüngling, dein Gebet wird eitel sein:
Denn wieder quillt aus tiefer Wunde mir das Blut
In dunkeln Tropfen, und mir ahnt ein neuer Sturm.
755
weh! Ach!
Weh, wehe, Fuß! Ha, welche Marter schaffst du mir!
Es schleicht her,
Es dringt heran stets näher; weh mir Armen, weh!
Da seht ihr Alles; aber, ach, flieht nicht von mir!
760
Ah, ah, ah!
Kephallener, möchte doch an deiner Brust
Durchbohrend hasten dieser Schmerz! Ach wehe, weh!
Ja, wehe nochmals! Und des Heers Anführer ihr,
Agamemnon und Menelaos, daß an meiner Statt
765
Ihr diese Krankheit nährtet, und gleich lange Zeit!
Weh, weh mir!
O Tod, o Tod! Du, den ich also jeden Tag
Ohn' Unterlaß anrufe, was erscheinst du nie?
Mein Trauter du, mein Edler, komm und fasse mich,
770
Verbrenne mich in Lemnos' Flammengluten dort,
Den oft von mir geruf'nen! Hab' ich selber doch
Dem Sohn Kronions ehemals für diese Wehr,
Die jezo du bewahrest, gleichen Dienst erzeigt.
sprich, Sohn! sprich!
775
Du schweigst? Wo waren deine Sinne, Kind?
Schon lange leid' ich und bejammre dein Geschick.
Schlummer, des Grams und der Sorge vergessender
Gott, sanft anhauchend erschein' uns,
Du Labsal unserem Dasein, komm!
800
Halte vom Aug' ihm fern
Dies Licht, das über der Erde wallt!
Erschein' uns, Heilbringer!
(zu Neoptolemos)
Du Jüngling, sich zu, wo du
Stehst, wohin du gehst, und was uns weiter
805
Zu thun sei! Schon weißt du's:
Was säumst du noch länger?
Die gelegene Zeit, Rath schaffend in Allem,
Gewinnt, rasch ergriffen, glorreichen Sieg.
Wohl, er vernimmt nichts mehr. Doch glaube mir, daß wir des Bogens
810
Beute vergeblich errungen, entschiffen wir ohne den Mann hier.
Denn sein wartet der Kranz, ihn hieß uns bringen die Gottheit.
Unvollendeter That mit Lug sich zu rühmen, wie schmachvoll!
Gegenstrophe.
Solches, o Jüngling, ordnen die Ewigen:
Doch, gibst du mir Antwort wieder,
815
Ganz leise nur, leise nur (hörst du, Kind?)
Sende zu mir dein Wort.
Denn schlaflos ist ja der Kranken Schlaf,
Und lauscht, und sieht Alles.
Doch suche, wähl' aufs Beste,
820
Spähe still und heimlich, sorgsam spähe
Mir, was du thun willst, aus.
Von wem ich hier rede,
Das weißt du ja: stimmt dein Wille zu seinem,
Entwirrt selbst ein Kluger solch Wirrsal kaum.
825
Schlußgesang.
Fahrwind athmet ja, Fahrwind,
Sohn! Hülflos liegt er und augenlos,
Der Mann hier, nächtlich im Schlafe gestreckt,
(Willkommener Schlaf uns!)
Weder der Hand noch dem Fuße gebeut er,
830
Nein, als läg' er im Schooße des Aïdes,
So blickt er. Sprich, was an der Zeit ist!
Dies eine nur, o Sohn, wurde mir klar:
Wagst du furchtlos, glückt die That wohl.
Nun schweiget, sag' ich, seid gefaßt und unverzagt!
835
Der Mann bewegt die Augen und erhebt das Haupt.
(erwachend)
So sei es: doch nun stehe selbst und halte dich.
(sich aufrichtend)
English (Thomas Francklin, 1758–1759) (OCR draft) Experimental (English (Thomas Francklin, 1758–1759)) — 782 focus
Receive them, son ; and let it be thy prayer
They bring not woes on thee, as they have done
To me and to Alcides.
May the gods
Forbid it ever ! May they guide our course
And speed our prosperous sails !
Sleep hath o'ertaken him. See, his head is lain
On the cold earth ; the balmy sweat thick drops
From every limb, and from the broken vein
Flows the warm blood ; let us indulge his slumbers.
INVOCATION TO SLEEP.
Sleep, thou patron of mankind,
Great physician of the mind,
Who dost nor pain nor sorrow know,
840
Sweetest balm of every woe,
840
Mildest sovereign, hear us now ;
840
Hear thy wretched suppliant's vow ;
840
His eyes in gentle slumbers close.
840
And continue his repose ;
840
Hear thy wretched suppliant's tow,
840
Great physician, hear us now.
And now, my son, what best may suit thy purpose
Consider well, and how we are to act.
What more can we expect? The time is come ;
For better far is opportunity
Seized at the lucky hour than all the counsels
Which wisdom dictates or which craft inspires.
Ned. He hears us not. But easy as it is
To gain the prize, it would avail us nothing
Were he not with us ? Phoebus hath reserved
For him alone the crown of victory ;
But thus to boast of what we could not do.
And break our word, were most disgraceful to us.
The gods will guide us, fear it not, my son ;
But what thou sayst speak soft, for well thou knowst
The sick man's sleep is short. He may awake
And hear us ; therefore let us hide our purpose.
If then thou thinkst as he does — thou knowst whom—
This is the hour. At such a time, my son.
The wisest err. But mark me, the wind's fair.
And Philoctctes sleeps, void of all help —
Lame, impotent, unable to resist,
He is as one among the dead. E'en now
We'll take him with us. 'Twere an easy task.
Leave it to me, my son. There is no danger.
Ned. No more ! His eyes are open. See, he moves.
[aioaking]. O fair returning light ! beyond
my hope ;
You too, my kind preservers ! O my son !
I could not think thou wouldst have stayed so long
In kind compassion to thy friend. Alas !
The Atridse never would have acted thus.
But noble is thy nature, and thy birth,
And therefore little did my wretchedness,
Nor from my wounds the noisome stench deter
Thy generous heart. I have a little respite ;
Help me, my son ! I'll try to rise ; this weakness
Will leave me soon, and then we'll go together.
Well, be it so ; but rise.
English (Robert Potter, 1788) (OCR draft) Experimental (English (Robert Potter, 1788)) — 782 focus
Take it, my son; and be thy vows address'di,ז
To Envy, that to thee it cause not toils,
Such as to me, and to its former lord.
Grant this, ye gods! And may a favouring gale
Arise, and safely bear us to the land
Sought by our sails, and by the gods assign'd
O sleep, that know'st not care, that know'st not pain,
Come gently-breathing, sorrow-charming king:
Veil from his eyes this light, whose glaring beams
Unshaded now are spread: come, healing pow'r! -
The hour, my son, requires deliberate thought,
Thy purpose fix'd or changed: this is the hour
To charge us with thy mandates. What avails
835
Longer delay? Occasion hath a pow'r
Surpassing all the counsels of the wise.
True, he hears nothing: but these arms in vain
We make our prize, without him if we sail;
For his the crown; he must be borne to Troy;
840
So will'd the god. How base to boast of deeds,
Which e'en with falsehood could not be achieved!
These things, my son, the god will make his care.
But when to me thy mandates thou shalt give,
Low be thy voice; for sleep in the diseased
845
Is ever on the watch, nor seals the eyes.
What now is in thy pow'r with caution act,
And silence: if with his thy thoughts accord,
Thou know'st of whom I speak, thou seest his state,
850
Let prudence judge, unable to resist.
The gale, my son, the fav'ring gale now breathes;
He sees not, helpless as in night's dark hour
He lies, and sleep, which all his senses locks,
Aids the design; nor hand nor foot discharge
Their functions; but like one, for whom the tomb
Is open'd, see him stretched: this hath a voice
That calls us to the deed; to seize him now
Were easy; be the task to me assign'd:
860
Best is that toil on which no danger waits.
Be silent, I command thee; of such thoughts
865
No more: he moves his eyes, and lifts his head.
Of that no more; but raise thee, grasp my hand.
English (Sir Richard Jebb, 1904) (OCR draft) Experimental (English (Sir Richard Jebb, 1904)) — 827-860 focus

Commentary

Commentary (R. C. Jebb) (OCR draft) (Commentary (R. C. Jebb))

mvp-comment-407-1 νεοχμὸν ἐξαίφνης 1 σαυτοῦ 2 ἰυγήν 3 ποεῖ 4

mvp-comment-408-1 τί σοί 5 ἔστιν 6

mvp-comment-409-1 τοὐπίσαγμα 7 τοὐπείσαγμα 8 τοὐπίσιγμα 9

mvp-comment-410-1 γὰρ 10

mvp-comment-410-2 δράσω 11

mvp-comment-411-1 ἥκει … ἐξεπλήσθη 12 αὕτη 13 διὰ χρόνου 14 ἥκει 15 διὰ χρόνου 16 πλάνοις 17 ἥκει 18 πλάνοις 19

mvp-comment-411-2 ἐξεπλήσθη. — ἰώ 20 φεῦ 21 ἰώ 22 ἐξέπλης 23 πλάνους 24

mvp-comment-411-3 760 There is an error in the traditional numbering here, as the fourth verse after this is called 765. The origin of this error is explained in the Appendix. To avoid changing the usual numeration throughout the rest of the play, I designate the next verse as 762.

mvp-comment-411-4 δῆτα 25

mvp-comment-411-5 δύστηνε … φανείς 26

mvp-comment-411-6 διὰ πόνων πάντων 27

mvp-comment-412-1 βούλει λάβωμαι 28 δῆτα 29

mvp-comment-413-1 μοι 30

mvp-comment-414-1 ἕως 31

mvp-comment-414-2 ἀνῇ 32

mvp-comment-415-1 τὸ πῆμα … τῆς νόσου 33

mvp-comment-416-1 γὰρ οὖν 34

mvp-comment-416-2 ἐξίῃ 35

mvp-comment-417-1 λῆξαι 36

mvp-comment-418-1 ἕκηλον εὕδειν 37 τῷδε τῷ χρόνῳ 38

mvp-comment-418-2 ἐκεῖνοι 39

mvp-comment-419-1 ἑκόντα μήτ’ ἄκοντα 40 μήτ’ 41 μηδ’ 42

mvp-comment-419-2 μήτε τῳ τέχνῃ 43 μηδέ 44 μήτε 45 τέχνῃ 46

mvp-comment-420-1 πρόστροπον 47

mvp-comment-420-2 κτείνας γένῃ 48

mvp-comment-421-1 προνοίας οὕνεκ’ 49 γ’ 50 οὕνεκα 51 γε 52

mvp-comment-421-2 πλὴν σοί τε κἀμοί 53

mvp-comment-421-3 ξὺν τύχῃ 54

mvp-comment-422-1 τὸν φθόνον δὲ πρόσκυσον 55

mvp-comment-423-1 μή … γενέσθαι 56

mvp-comment-423-2 πολύπονα 57

mvp-comment-423-3 μηδ’ ὅπως 58

mvp-comment-424-1 θεοί 59

mvp-comment-424-2 γένοιτο … γένοιτο δὲ 60 ταῦτα νῷν 61

mvp-comment-424-3 κεὐσταλής 62

mvp-comment-424-4 ὅποι ποτὲ 63

mvp-comment-425-1 ἀλλ’ Ὄκνος 64 ἀλλὰ δέδοικ’, ὦ παῖ, μή μ’ ἀτελὴς εὐχή 65 ὦ παῖ 66 ἀλλὰ 67 δέδοικ’ 68 μ’ 69 με 70 εὔχῃ, μή μ’ ἀτελὴς 71 ἀτελῶς 72 εὔχῃ 73 ἔχει 74 ἀτέλεστ’ 75

mvp-comment-425-2 For μὴ 76 α 77

mvp-comment-426-1 κηκῖον 78 νέον 79

mvp-comment-427-1 ἐργάσει 80 προσέρπει 81

mvp-comment-428-1 τάλας 82

mvp-comment-428-2 ἔχετε 83

mvp-comment-428-3 μηδαμῇ 84

mvp-comment-429-1 Κεφαλλήν 85

mvp-comment-429-2 σοῦ 86 ἔχοιτο 87 διαμπερὲς στέρνων 88 σου 89

mvp-comment-430-1 μάλ’ αὖθις 90

mvp-comment-430-2 ὦ διπλοῖ στρ. 91

mvp-comment-430-3 Ἀγάμεμνον, ὦ Μενέλαε 92 Μενέλαέ τ’ Ἀγάμεμνόν τε 93 πῶς ἄν 94 τρέφοιτε 95

mvp-comment-430-4 τὸν ἴσον χρόνον 96

mvp-comment-431-1 ὦ Θάνατε 97

mvp-comment-431-2 ἀεὶ … κατ’ ἦμαρ 98

mvp-comment-431-3 δύνᾳ 99

mvp-comment-432-1 ὦ τέκνον, ὦ γενναῖον 100

mvp-comment-432-2 ἀλλὰ 101

mvp-comment-433-1 τῷ Λ. τῷδ’ ἀνακ. πυρὶ 102

mvp-comment-433-2 The volcanic mountain called

Μόσυχλος
appears to have been on the east coast of Lemnos, south of the rocky promontory (
Ἑρμαῖον ὄρος
, v. 1459) to which the cave of Philoctetes was adjacent. No volcanic crater can now be traced in Lemnos; and it is probable that the ancient Mosychlus has been submerged. See Appendix.
Λήμνιον πῦρ
was proverbial for ‘a fierce fire’ ( Ar. Lys. 299 ). Lycophron (227) has
τεφρώσας γυῖα Λημναίῳ πυρί
in this sense, and calls Ajax
ὁ Λήμνιος
|
πρηστὴρ Ἐνυοῦς
(462), ‘Lemnian thunderbolt of war.’ Cp. Hesych.
Λήμνιον βλέπειν· ἐπειδὴ τὸ πῦρ Λήμνιον
. The legendary association of Lemnos with fierce crime (
Λήμνια κακά
) may have helped to suggest such phrases.

mvp-comment-434-1 ἔμπρησον 103 πυρί μ’ 104 συλλαβὼν 105

mvp-comment-435-1 τὸν τοῦ Διὸς παῖδ’ 106

mvp-comment-435-2 σῴζεις 107

mvp-comment-435-3 τοῦτ’ 108

mvp-comment-435-4 ἐπηξίωσα 109

mvp-comment-435-5 δρᾶν 110

mvp-comment-436-1 τί φής, παῖ 111

mvp-comment-436-2 ποῦ ποτ’ ὤν 112

mvp-comment-437-1 πάλαι δὴ 113

mvp-comment-437-2 τἀπὶ σοὶ … κακά 114

mvp-comment-438-1 καὶ θάρσος ἴσχε 115 καὶ 116 μοι. 117

mvp-comment-438-2 φοιτᾷ 118

mvp-comment-438-3 ὀξεῖα, ταχεῖα 119

mvp-comment-439-1 οὐ μήν 120

mvp-comment-439-2 ἔνορκον … θέσθαι 121

mvp-comment-440-1 ὡς 122 θέμις 123 γε 124 θέμις 125

mvp-comment-440-2 ἐμοὔστι 126

mvp-comment-441-1 ἔμβαλλε 127

mvp-comment-442-1 ἐκεῖσε νῦν μ’ 128 ἐκεῖσε 129 ἐκεῖσε 130 ἄνω 131 παραφρονεῖς αὖ 132 τὸν ἄνω λεύσσεις κύκλον 133 εἴ τι δὴ πλέον φρονεῖς 134

mvp-comment-443-1 αὖ 135

mvp-comment-443-2 τὸν ἄνω κύκλον 136

mvp-comment-444-1 ποτέ 137

mvp-comment-444-2 ἀπό μ’ ὀλεῖς 138

mvp-comment-445-1 καὶ δὴ μεθίημ’ 139

mvp-comment-445-2 εἴ τι δὴ 140

mvp-comment-445-3 πλέον φρονεῖς 141 εἰ 142

mvp-comment-446-1 θανάσιμον 143

mvp-comment-446-2 ὅπως ἔχω 144

mvp-comment-446-3 ὀρθοῦσθαι 145

mvp-comment-447-1 οὐ μακροῦ χρόνου 146

mvp-comment-448-1 γέ τοι 147

mvp-comment-449-1 ἄκρον … ποδὸς 148 φλέψ 149

mvp-comment-450-1 ὄμμασι δ’ ἀντίσχοις 150 τάνδ’ αἴγλαν ἃ τέταται τανῦν 151 τάνδε 152 αἴγλαν 153 τέταται 154

mvp-comment-450-2 The words could not mean, ‘keep off this sunlight from his eyes.’ ὄμμασι 155 ἀντίσχοις 156 αἴγλαν 157 ἀντίσχοις 158 τάνδ’ αἴγλαν 159

mvp-comment-451-1 ἴθι ἴθι 160

mvp-comment-452-1 ποῦ στάσει 161

mvp-comment-453-1 The MSS. give here ποῖ δὲ βάσει πῶς δέ μοι τἀντεῦθεν 162 κεῖνό μοι, κεῖνο λάθρᾳ 163 ποῖ δέ μοι τἀνθένδε βάσει 164 ποῖ 165 φροντίδος 166

mvp-comment-453-2 τἀνθένδε 167

mvp-comment-454-1 ὁρᾷς ἤδη 168 ὁρᾷς, εὕδει 169

mvp-comment-455-1 πρὸς τί μενοῦμεν 170 πράσσειν 171

mvp-comment-456-1 καιρός 172 πάντων γνώμαν ἴσχων 173

mvp-comment-456-2 < πολύ τι > πολὺ 174

mvp-comment-456-3 παρὰ πόδα 175

mvp-comment-457-1 ἀλλ’ ὅδε μὲν 176

mvp-comment-457-2 θήραν … ἔχομεν 177

mvp-comment-458-1 τοῦδε … τοῦτον 178

mvp-comment-458-2 ὁ στέφανος 179

mvp-comment-459-1 κομπεῖν δ’ 180 ἀτελῆ σὺν ψεύδεσιν 181

mvp-comment-460-1 ἀλλά, τέκνον 182

mvp-comment-460-2 ὀψεται 183

mvp-comment-461-1 ὧν 184 λόγων 185 ἀμείβῃ 186

mvp-comment-462-1 πάντων 187 λεύσσειν 188 εὐδρακὴς 189

mvp-comment-463-1 ἀλλ’ ὅτι δύνᾳ 190 λάθρᾳ 191

mvp-comment-463-2 δύνᾳ 192

mvp-comment-463-3 κεῖνο … κεῖνο 193 δή 194

mvp-comment-463-4 μοι 195

mvp-comment-463-5 ὅτι δ. μάκιστον 196 ἐξιδοῦ 197

mvp-comment-463-6 ὅπᾳ 198 ὅπως 199

mvp-comment-464-1 οἶσθα γὰρ ἃν … πάθη 200 ἃν 201 ὧν 202 ὃν 203 γνώμαν 204 οἶσθα γὰρ ἃν αὐδῶμαι 205 ταύταν 206 κεῖνο 207 τούτῳ 208 πυκινοῖς 209 ἐνιδεῖν 210 ἄπορα πάθη 211

mvp-comment-465-1 οὖρος 212

mvp-comment-466-1 οὐδ’ ἔχων ἀρωγὰν 213 νύχιος 214

mvp-comment-467-1 ἀλεὴς ὕπνος ἐσθλός 215 ἀλεής 216 ἀλέας 217 ἀδεὴς 218 δ’ 219 ἀλεὴς 220

mvp-comment-467-2 Some reject ἀλεὴς ὕπνος ἐσθλός 221 ἀδεὴς 222 ἀδεὴς πόνος ἐσθλός 223 πόνος ὁ μὴ φοβῶν κράτιστος 224 ἀδεὴς πόνος ἐσθλός 225

mvp-comment-468-1 οὔ τινος 226

mvp-comment-469-1 Ἀΐδᾳ πάρα κείμενος 227 παρακείμενος 228

mvp-comment-470-1 ὅρα, βλέπ’ 229 ὅρα 230 ὁρᾷ 231

mvp-comment-470-2 εἰ καίρια φθέγγει 232

mvp-comment-471-1 τὸ δ’ ἁλώσιμον ἐμᾷ φρ. 233

mvp-comment-471-2 πόνος ὁ μὴ φοβῶν κράτιστος 234 ὁ μὴ φοβῶν 235 πόνος 236

mvp-comment-472-1 μηδ’ ἀφεστάναι φρενῶν 237

mvp-comment-473-1 ὦ φέγγος 238 τό τ’ 239

mvp-comment-473-2 ἐλπίδων ἄπιστον 240 οἰκούρημα 241

mvp-comment-474-1 τοῦτ’ 242 ἐξηύχης’ 243 τλῆναι 244 ἂν 245 τλῆναι 246 ἐξηύχης’ 247

mvp-comment-474-2 μεῖναι 248 τἀμὰ πήματα 249

mvp-comment-474-3 ξυνωφελοῦντά μοι 250

mvp-comment-475-1 οὔκουν 251

mvp-comment-475-2 εὐφόρως 252 εὐπόρως 253

mvp-comment-476-1 κἀξ εὐγενῶν 254 ἐν εὐχερεῖ ἔθου 255

mvp-comment-476-2 γέμων 256

mvp-comment-477-1 λήθη 257

mvp-comment-477-2 δή 258

mvp-comment-478-1 σύ μ’ αὐτὸς … ποτέ 259 κόπος 260 ού μ’ αὐτὸς ἆρον, σύ με κατάστησον 261

mvp-comment-478-2 νῦν δ’ αἶρε σαυτόν 262 ἵν’, ἡνίκ’ ἂν κόπος μ’ ἀπαλλάξῃ ποτέ 263

mvp-comment-478-3 ZippmannA. , whom Nauck and Cavallin follow in their texts, deletes both v. 880 and v. 889 as spurious, and transposes 879 to a place between 888 and 890. His two main objections to the traditional text are:—Why should Ph. , formerly so eager to start, now wish to wait till his

κόπος
has passed off? (880). And why should he desire to rise before that moment, instead of resting on the ground? The view of the whole situation which I have given above will show why I believe the traditional text to be sound.

mvp-comment-479-1 ἐπίσχωμεν 264 τὸ πλεῖν 265

mvp-comment-480-1 ἀλλ’ ἥδομαι μέν 266 μέν 267

mvp-comment-480-2 ἀνώδυνον 268

mvp-comment-480-3 βλέποντα 269

mvp-comment-480-4 κἀμπνέοντ’ 270

mvp-comment-481-1 ὡς οὐκέτ’ ὄντος 271 συμβόλαια 272 τὰς παρούσας ξυμφορὰς 273 πρὸς 274 τὰς παρ. ξυμφοράς 275 πρὸς τὰς παρ. ξυμφορὰς 276

mvp-comment-481-2 συμβόλαια 277

mvp-comment-482-1 νῦν δ’ αἶρε σαυτόν 278

mvp-comment-482-2 εἰ δέ σοι μᾶλλον φίλον 279

mvp-comment-482-3 τοῦ πόνου γὰρ 280

mvp-comment-483-1 αἰνῶ τάδ’, ὦ παῖ 281 αἰνῶ τάδε 282

mvp-comment-484-1 ἔασον 283

mvp-comment-484-2 ὀσμῇ 284

mvp-comment-484-3 συνναίειν 285

mvp-comment-485-1 ἔσται τάδ’ 286

mvp-comment-485-2 ἵστω 287

mvp-comment-485-3 καὐτὸς ἀντέχου 288

mvp-comment-486-1 σύνηθες … ἔθος 289

mvp-comment-487-1 τί δῆτ’ ἂν δρῷμ’ 290

mvp-comment-487-2 δρῷμ’ 291

mvp-comment-487-3 τοὐνθένδε γε 292 γε 293

mvp-comment-488-1 ἐξέβης 294

mvp-comment-488-2 λόγῳ 295 λόγων 296

mvp-comment-489-1 οὐκ οἶδ’ ὅποι χρὴ 297 στρέφειν 298 τρέπειν 299

mvp-comment-490-1 ἀπορεῖς δὲ τοῦ σύ 300

mvp-comment-491-1 ἐνθάδε … τοῦδε τοῦ πάθους 301

mvp-comment-492-1 οὐ δή 302 ὥστε 303 ἔπεισεν 304

mvp-comment-492-2 ναύτην 305

Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879) (OCR draft) (Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879)) focus

737. mvp-comment-529-1 ἐξαίφνης is joined with veοχμόν as = νεωστί γενόμενον. ὅτου] «Wherefore.' Genitive of cause. Essay on L. § 10. p. 14.

738. mvp-comment-530-1 σαυτοῦ] 'Over thyself,' is genitive of the object after στόνον.

743. mvp-comment-531-1 Hermann in 1841 defended the MS. distribution of the persons (see v. rr.), supposing Philoctetes to evade inquiry first by saying οἶσθα, ‘You know as well as I do,' and then οὐκ οἶδα, ‘I do not know,' with the inconsistency of one distracted by pain and avoiding question. And there is nothing unnatural in this. But the words πῶς οὐκ οἶσθα are very clumsy in the mouth of Neoptolemus, whereas, if uttered by Philoctetes, they convey a touching expostulation against the cruelty of pressing him with questions when the case is so obvious. According to Bothe's arrangement, which is here retained, Neoptolemus at first affects ignorance, but is presently overcome with pity. For τί σοί, · What is the matter with you?' Hermann conjectured τί τοι;

745. mvp-comment-532-1 ἀλλ᾽ οἴκτειρέ με] The mental anxiety of the sufferer is greater than his pain.

747. mvp-comment-533-1 ταρβήσας] According to the story of the supposed Έμπορος, Neoptolemus was in twofold danger in Lemnos, both from Phoenix and the Theseidae, who were pursuing himself ( supr. 561,2), and still more from Odysseus and Diomed, who were on their way to fetch Philoctetes, and if they fled together would pursue them both.

748-749. mvp-comment-534-1 ἥκει.. ἐξεπλήσθη] (1) ‘For this plague in its wanderings is come after an interval in no less strength than when it sated itself.' A recurrent malady is imagined as going out of a man, making a circuit, and returning. Cp. infr. 808: Tennyson, Aylmer's field, p. 80. For ἥκειν in a somewhat similar connection, cp. Plat. Gorg 518 D, ὅταν δὴ αὐτοῖς ἥκῃ ἡ τότε πλησμονὴ νόσον φέρουσα συχνῷ ὕστερον χρόνῳ. For the dative πλάνοις (almost = πλανωμένη, Aesch. Prom. 275), see Essay on L. § 14. p. 20, 2 . ἴσως = οὐχ ἧττον ἰσχυρῶς. See Essay on L. § 24, α. p. 40 . ὡς ἐξεπλήσθη, i. e. ὡς τὸ πρὶν ἥκουσα ἐξεπλήσθη. It might be thought to have exhausted itself, or to have satisfied its hunger; but no, it returns with all its former violence. (2) The Scholiast explains, π. ἴ. ὡ. ἐ., 'I suppose when it has had enough of wandering. For other interpretations, see Ellendt's Lexicon, and Blaydes and Paley in loco. Arndt's emendation, ὡς ἐξεπλήσθη φλέψ. ΝΕ. ἰὼ δ. σ., is worth recording for its prosaic oddity.

751. mvp-comment-535-1 διὰ πόνων πάντων] ‘In passing through all (i. e. extreme) woe.' πάντων is virtually intensive. Others would render, 'Beyond all sufferings' that have been.

754. mvp-comment-536-1 ἕως ἀνῇ] For the omission of av, see Essay on L. § 27, 1. p. 45.

755. mvp-comment-537-1 τὸ πῆμα .. παρόν] ‘This present fit of pain.’ Cp. O. C. 78, 9, for the epexegesis.

756-757. mvp-comment-538-1 λαμβάνει γὰρ οὖν | ὕπνος μ᾽] 'For, you must know, sleep is wont to seize me.' For the present tense, cp. supr. 308, ἐλεοῦσι μέν.

757. mvp-comment-539-1 ἐξίῃ] · Is passing off.'

758. mvp-comment-540-1 λῆξαι] Sc. τὸ κακόν.

758-759. mvp-comment-541-1 ἀλλ᾽ . . εὕδειν] με is easily supplied: see v. rr. Cp. infr. 801: О. Т. 461, κἂν λάβῃς ἐψευσμένον.

759. mvp-comment-542-1 τῷδε τῷ χρόνῳ] 'While I am asleep.' Essay on L. § 11. pp. 17, 18.

761. mvp-comment-543-1 Several editors prefer μηδ' ἄκοντα. μηδέ τῳ τέχνη] Hdt. 1. 112, έχρῇζε μηδεμιῇ τέχνῃ ἐκθεῖναί μιν.

763. mvp-comment-544-1 πρόστροπον] This word has an especially sacred and compelling force. Cp. O. Τ. 41, ἱκετεύομέν σε πάντες οἵδε πρόστροποι. κτείνας γένῃ] Cp. especially Aj. 588, μὴ προδοὺς ἡμᾶς γένῃ.

765. mvp-comment-545-1 οὐ δοθήσεται .. κάμοί] 'They shall be given to no one (and no one shall have them) besides us two.' Neoptolemus has in mind the real ground for this. Supr. 115.

766. mvp-comment-546-1 Philoctetes, even amidst his pain, feels the gravity of the moment when he gives the bow out of his hands. The common feeling about the Divine envy appears also in El. 1466.

767. mvp-comment-547-1 μηδ' ὅπως] For the disjunctive form of expression, cp. supr. 80, τοιαῦτα φωνεῖν, μηδὲ τεχνᾶσθαι κακά.

768. mvp-comment-548-1 Heracles and Philoctetes, both owners of the bow, had both had more than the usual share of trouble. The troubles of Heracles might even be traced to the weapon with which he had slain Nessus and provoked the sons of Eurytus to strife.

769-771. mvp-comment-549-1 Neoptolemus also feels the gravity of the moment, but dissembles his gladness under the cover of a heart-felt though ambiguous prayer.

770. mvp-comment-550-1 εὐσταλής] 'Happily conducted' = εὐτυχῶς ἐσταλμένος : said with reference to other dangers than those of winds and waves; e. g. a mutiny arising from Philoctetes' malady. Cp. supr. 520, 1, infr. 890 foll.

771. mvp-comment-551-1 ὅποι ποτέ, κ.τ.λ.] The formality of the prayer renders its ambiguous vagueness less suspicious. Neoptolemus trusts that, in spite of apparent difficulties, the will of the gods, as expressed in prophecy, is on the side of his ambition.

772. mvp-comment-552-1 The appearance of a single dochmiac line amongst the senarii is not of itself a sufficient reason for suspicion in a passage which is naturally interrupted by physical as well as by mental suffering. Cp. Trach. 1185, 6. Indeed the regularity of the dochmiac structure is rather in favour of the verse. But, in the vulgate reading (see v. rr.), the ellipse of the subjunctive mood and the accusative με-μ' cannot = μοι-are difficult to explain. The former objection may be removed by conjecturing μή μ' ἀτελὴς (οι ἀτελῶς) εὔχῃ, and the accusative may then be defended. See Essay on L. § 16. p. 23.

783. mvp-comment-553-1 ἐκ βυθοῦ] 'From hidden depths.' Men in pain naturally exaggerate the dimensions of the part affected.

784. mvp-comment-554-1 τι.. νέον] 'Some violent change.' Ср. O. С. 1447, and note.

786. mvp-comment-555-1 παπαῖ μάλ] Cp. O. C. 1462, ἴδε μάλα, and note. ἐργάσει] 'A great evil perpetually recurrent is most in apprehension.' But Philoctetes is also thinking of the danger to his new-found hopes.

789. mvp-comment-556-1 ἔχετε τὸ πρᾶγμα] 'You know all now.' He has made known to them what he had sought to hide, l. 742 foll. and they are aware both of his need and his danger, 776 foll. He implores them therefore to stand by him. μηδαμή = μηδεμιᾷ τέχνῃ. Cp. supr. 771.

790. mvp-comment-557-1 ἀτταταῖ] Perhaps *ἰατταταῖ should be read so as to keep up the iambic rhythm.

791-792. mvp-comment-558-1 εἴθε.. ἥδε] 'Would that this pang might pierce thy breast and cling there!' For ξένε, cp. Aj.817. Philoctetes and Odysseus had been bound by a common oath,

793-795. mvp-comment-559-1 For the repeated interjection, cp. Eur. Alc. 235, βόασον ὦ, στέναξον ὦ Φεραία χθών: ib. 460, ὦ μόνα, ὦ φίλα γυναικῶν : Cycl. 266.

794. mvp-comment-560-1 ὦ Μενέλαε: 795, τὸν ἴσον: 797, ὦ θάνατε, θάνατε. The freeer handling of the senarius, which marks the Philoctetes, and which belongs to the later manner of Greek tragedy, is most observable in this speech, where it expresses agitation ( cp. O. T. 967). For other instances, see ll. 651, 665, 879, 923, 4, 950, 1029, 1315, 1327, mostly in speeches of Philoctetes.

797-798. mvp-comment-561-1 Cp. Aj. 854, ὦ θάνατε, θάνατε, νῦν μ᾿ ἐπίσκεψαι μολών: Aesch. Phil. fr. 250, ὦ θάνατε Παιάν, μή μ' ἀτιμάσῃς μολεῖν.

798. mvp-comment-562-1 οὐ δύνᾳ μολεῖν] 'Why can you not come?' i. e. 'Why is it impossible to bring you?” πῶς οὐ δυνατόν ἐστί σε μολεῖν;

800. mvp-comment-563-1 ἀνακαλουμένῳ] (1) ‘Generally invoked,' or (2) 'Celebrated by this name.' Cp. Ar. Lys. 299. The volcano on Mount Mosychlos would be a god-prepared pyre for Philoctetes, whose end would then resemble that of his master Heracles.

803. mvp-comment-564-1 After l. 803 there is a pause, during which Neoptolemus is lost in thought. Philoctetes, who is already losing consciousness, is visited with a sudden fear lest his friend may have left him. Every word which he utters gives him a fresh hold on Neoptolemus' compassion.

806. mvp-comment-565-1 τἀπὶ σοί] 'That afflict thee.' Cp. Trach. 981, ἀλλ᾽ ἐπί μοι μελέῳ βάρος ἄπλετον ἐμμέμονε φρήν.

807. mvp-comment-566-1 The tripartite division of this line is very unusual. But it is modified by the elision in ἴσχ' for ἴσχε, and the rhythm of this whole passage is broken.

808. mvp-comment-567-1 'As it comes impetuously, so it leaves me speedily.' For the paratactic structure, cp. Ant. 1112, αὐτός τ᾽ ἔδησα καὶ παρὼν ἐκλύσομαι.

809. mvp-comment-568-1 θάρσει, μενούμεν] Neoptolemus says this with mingled feelings, and the eagerness of Philoctetes is made pathetic by his unconsciousness of the situation.

810. mvp-comment-569-1 σαφῶς φρόνει] Sc. με ὡς μενοῦντα.

811. mvp-comment-570-1 Ср. О. C. 650, 1, and note. Philoctetes desires the confirmation for which he will not ask. Neoptolemus makes a solemn asseveration (ὡς .. γε = 'At any rate be assured that'), in which the hidden intention of fate ( cp. ξυμφορᾶς ξύνθημα, Ο. C. 46) is again ambiguously conveyed. Philoctetes still requires the assurance of the right hand. Cр. О. С. 1632, δός μοι χερὸς σῆς πίστιν ἀρχαίαν, and note: Trach. 1181. Neoptolemus gives it with the safe promise of remaining, which to Philoctetes at the moment is quite sufficient. (He afterwards, infr. 1398, interprets the promise differently, as a confirmation of the original engagement, supr. 527). On receiving this satisfaction, he relapses into a semi-conscious state, and dreaming apparently of Oeta, Olympus, and the Lemnian fire in one, begs to be carried 'yonder,' 'upwards.' But immediately afterwards, when Neoptolemus comes near to hold him, he cries out to be let alone. (Prof. Paley interprets 813, 4, ἐκεῖσε.. ἄνω, as referring to the cave. But the vagueness of 815 is against this.)

815. mvp-comment-571-1 τὸν ἄνω κύκλον] 'The circle of the heavens.' Cp. Aj. 672, νυκτὸς αἰανῆς κύκλος.

817. mvp-comment-572-1 The tmesis of ἀπό occurs again infr. 1158, 1177.

818. mvp-comment-573-1 *εἴ τι δὴ πλέον φρονεῖς] 'Supposing that you must know best.' πλέον, sc. ἐμοῦ. Cp. Plat. Hipp. Min. 371 A, τοῦ Ὀδυσσέως φαίνεται φρονεῖν πλέον πρὸς τὸ ῥᾳδίως λανθάνειν: Thuc. 5. 29. § 2, νομίσαντες πλέον τέ τι εἰδότας μεταστῆναι αὐτούς, κ.τ.λ. Neoptolemus feels like an inexperienced nurse, and perceives that the sickness is beyond his treatment. He begins to think that the sick man must know what is best for his own state. Cp. Trach. 1017-22.

820. mvp-comment-574-1 Philoctetes throws himself on the ground.

822. mvp-comment-575-1 τόδε] See Essay on L. § 22, 1. P.34.

823. mvp-comment-576-1 'Sweat certainly is bathing him over all his frame.' γέ τοι calls attention to the sign which helps to confirm supr. 821, 2.

824. mvp-comment-577-1 ἄκρου.. ποδός] Cp. supr. 748, and note. παρέρρωγεν] 'Has burst from the side of (i. e. from the place of the wound)'. For the repetition of the same root in the compound, see Essay on L. § 40. p. 75, § 55. p. 101.

827-862. mvp-comment-578-1 Odysseus ( supr. 77, 115), whose words appear in some way to have reached the Chorus ( supr. 136 foll.), spoke only of the necessity of obtaining the bow. For this the Chorus now see the opportunity, and cannot understand the inaction of Neoptolemus, who is better informed (839-42, cp. infr. 1329-43), and is moreover chained to the spot by remorseful sympathy with Philoctetes. This passage, which does the work of a stasimon in separating two episodia, is in so far of the nature of a commos that it contains a lyrical interchange between the Chorus and one of the persons on the stage. The text is imperfect in several places, and Bergk conjectures that four lines of Neoptolemus', answering to 839-42, have dropped out between 854, 5. It seems most probable that ll. 827-32 were sung by one half-chorus, and ll. 843-48 by the other, in subdued tones; that 833-8, 849-54 were recited severally by two of the chief choreutae, and that 855-64 were recited by the coryphaeus, or, possibly, sung by the whole Chorus. The metres of this irregular strain are dactylic, anapaestic, trochaic, iambic, and choriambic. The following is an approximate scheme of them :- στρ. and ἀντ.
Logaoedic 1 _UU_UU_UU_U_
(?)
Anapaestic { __ | __
Choriambic _UU_ __
Logaoedic 5 __UU_U_
Iambic U_U_ __
Iambic U_U_U_
Trochaic
Iambic U_ U_U_ __
Iambic 10 U_ U_U_ __
Iambic U_U_U_U_
Paracelèusmatic, { _ UU _ UU _
with logaoedic close (?)

The strophe is followed by four dactylic hexameters, the antistrophe by an epode, of which this is the scheme:-
Logaoedic {: __
Dactylic {: _UU_UU__ | _UU_UU_ _ (?)
Iambo-trochaic 5 _U_U_U_ _ (?)
Dactylic _UU_UU_UU_UU_
Iambic U_U_U_
For νύχιος, l. 858, cp. Eur. Hel. 1479, Suppl. 280.

827-829. mvp-comment-579-1 It is seldom that we can at all realise the euphonic effects of Greek lyric verse. But the effect of the vowelly assonance of εὐαὴς .. εὐαίων, accompanied by low breathings of the flute, may be partly imagined.

827. mvp-comment-580-1 ῞Υπν'.. Ὑπνε] Cp. supr. 663 foll. ὃς .. ὅς, κ.τ.λ., and note. ὀδύνας] ‘Pain.' ἀλγέων] 'Grief.' Herm. (1841) preferred ἄλγεος for the metre. Cp. Il.14.164, ὕπνον ἀπήμονά τε λιαρόν τε: Od. 13. 92, δὴ τότε γ᾽ ἀτρέμας εὔδε, λελασμένος, ὅσσ᾽ ἐπεπόνθει.

828-829. mvp-comment-581-1 The metre of these lines is different from that of 844, 5, which should correspond to them in the antistrophe. But the effect of the two spondaic (anapaestic) lines ( cp. 837, 853) resembles El. 88, 9, 105, 6, 153, 173, 213-6, 233-6, and the antistrophe is possibly corrupt. See note on infr. 844. Others read εὐǎές, in which the vocative would resemble ἁλίπλαγκτε in Aj. 695. But the a is probably long. εὐαής] The first strain of the Chorus, ll. 827-32, is intended at once to lull Philoctetes to sleep, and darkly to express their own wishes. Thus εὐαής is at once 'With kindly breath' ( cp. supr. 18, 19, ἐν θέρει δ᾽ ὕπνον | δι᾽ ἀμφιτρῆτος αὐλίου πέμπει πνοή), and 'As with favouring gale' (to further our design).

829. mvp-comment-582-1 εὐαίων] 'Bringing happiness.' For the repetition, which depends on the Triclinian MSS., cp. Eur. Or. 174, πότνια, πότνια νύξ. Sleep is invoked, as the Lord of happiest life. Cp. Fr. 372, ὡς τοῖς κακῶς πράσσουσιν ἡδὺ καὶ βραχὺν | χρόνον λαθέσθαι τῶν παρεστώτων κακῶν: Plat. Apol. 39 D. Others explain εὐαίων, 'Lasting,' 'Not soon over.'

830. mvp-comment-583-1 ὄμμασι δ᾽ ἀντίσχοις τάνδ᾽ αἴγλαν .. τανῦν] 'And hold before his eyes this brightness that is now spread over them.' There is difficulty in the interpretation of αἴγλαν. Hermann was at one time satisfied with explaining it by a simple oxymoron, 'This light' = the light the eyes now have, i.e. darkness. Lobeck, Hermann in 1841, and, I believe, Prof. E. L. Lushington, would take αἴγλαν literally of the light of day, and explain ὄμμασι as a dativus commodi. ἀντέχειν then means 'To hold away, Fend off.' 'And defend his eyes from this brightness that is now spread forth.' But the explanatory clause ( ἃ τέταται τανῦν), according to this interpretation, appears weak and motiveless. Welcker's suggestion that αἴγλη here means a head-band ( αἴγλη, χλιδών, Fr. 524), satisfies some interpreters. A modification of Hermann's first interpretation seems to afford a possible meaning. The Chorus, gazing on Philoctetes' closed eyelids, see an expression of peaceful repose in his countenance that was previously absent. They pray that this boon of sleep may be continued. 'Light' is a familiar image of relief and safety. But in speaking of repose as light, the Chorus think again of their design, and add, 'This light which his eyes now have on them,' and not the light of waking. Or τάνδ' αἴγλαν may mean more simply, 'This soothing light:' the relief which slumber brings to Philoctetes being associated with the cheerful sunshine. (Burges conj. ἀμπίσχοις; Auratus conj. ἀχλύν.) τέταται, sc. τοῖς ὄμμασι. For a somewhat similar expression, cp. Aj. 706, ἔλυσεν αἰνὸν ἄχος ἀπ᾿ ὀμμάτων ῎Αρης.

832. mvp-comment-584-1 ἴθι, ἴθι] The hiatus here is one of those irregularities which suggest the doubt spoken of in the Introduction, p. 364. It may be accounted for by the ictus, U_U_ __, Cp. 859. Cp. with this invocation to Sleep (in its second intention), Shak. Cymb. 2, 2, 'O Sleep, thou ape of death, lie dull upon her! And be her sense but as a monument, | Thus in a chapel lying.'

833. mvp-comment-585-1 For the frequent form of expression, cp. especially Eur. Alc. 864, ποῖ βῶ; πᾶ στῶ; τί λέγω; τί δὲ μή;

834. mvp-comment-586-1 πῶς δέ μοι. . φροντίδος] Sc. ἔσται. ' And how are matters from this point to proceed with me in respect of thought?' i.e. What course is my design to take? Cp. infr. 895.

835. mvp-comment-587-1 ὁρᾷς ἤδη] 'You see (how things are) now;' viz. that Philoctetes is fast asleep. For the short abrupt sentences, ср. О. С. 117-22, ib. 162-5.

836. mvp-comment-588-1 πρὸς τί . . πράσσειν] ‘For what are we waiting, to do it?' i.e. What practical advantage is to be gained by our delay? πράσσειν is epexegetic of πρὸς τί. μενοῦμεν is the MS. reading, but the short vowel gives a more probable rhythm.

837. mvp-comment-589-1 καιρός, κ.τ.λ.] 'Opportunity, which holds the clue of everything, by following closely, wins much advantage.' The Chorus hint the unwisdom of adhering to one fixed plan, when a good opportunity occurs of suddenly executing another. A conjectural reading is ῥώμαν. But γνώμαν is confirmed by the echo of the phrase in the antistrophe. Cavallin, comparing πολλά in 305 supr., explains πολύ as = πολλάκις. γνώμαν ἴσχων nearly = γνῶμα παρέχων. Cp. Εl. 75, καιρὸς γάρ, ὅσπερ ἄνδρασιν | μέγιστος ἔργου παντός ἐστ᾽ ἐπιστάτης: Pind. Pyth. 9. 78, ὁ δὲ καιρὸς ὁμοίως | παντὸς ἔχει κορυφάν. Others join πάντων κράτος = 'Opportunity, combined with judgment, carries a decided superiority in all cases.' A word is lost of the quantity of αἴσιον (C.) or ἄνδρασιν (Hermann).

839-842. mvp-comment-590-1 Hexameters occur similarly in the commos of Trachiniae, ll. 1017-23, where solemn reflections are intermingled with the more excited lyric strains. Cp. also ib. 1009-13, 1031-1040.

839. mvp-comment-591-1 θήραν | τήνδ'] 'This capture,' accomplished supr. 779.

841. mvp-comment-592-1 τοῦδε γὰρ ὁ στέφανος] Cp. infr. 1344-7, Ἑλλήνων ἕνα | κριθέντ᾽ ἄριστον.. κλέος ὑπέρτατον λαβεῖν. ‘The prize was to be his.' Others (Paley) render, 'In him was the prize.' εἶπε] Sc. δεῖν.

842. mvp-comment-593-1 'To have an unaccomplished work to boast of, and that with the help of falsehood, is a reproach that carries deep disgrace.' To bring away the bow, as if performing a great feat, would only expose them to the reproach of not having brought Philoctetes. And this, when Neoptolemus had lied for the purpose.

843. mvp-comment-594-1 τάδε.. θεὸς ὄψεται] The completion of the work achieved so far may be left to Divine providence, notwithstanding what is mysterious in the oracle. Cp. Aj. 1165, κοίλην κάπετόν τιν᾿ ἰδεῖν, and note: O. C. 1454, ὁρᾷ, ὁρᾷ ταῦτ᾽ ἀεὶ χρόνος : Thuc. 5. 27, ὁρᾶν τοὺς ᾿Αργείους ὅπως σωθήσεται ἡ Πελοπόννησος.

844. mvp-comment-595-1 ὧν .. αὖθις] The metre of the MS. reading ὧν δ᾽ ἂν ἀμείβῃ μ᾽ αὖθις (U_U_U_U) does not correspond to the strophe, and is not very probable. Possibly ἀμείβῃ was a gloss explaining προσφωνῇ.. αὖθις, and we might read, ὧν δ᾽ ἂν προσφωνῇ μ᾽ αὖθις. Cp. ll. 1. 223, Πηλείδης δ᾽ ἐξαῦτις ἀταρτηροῖς ἐπέεσσιν | ᾿Ατρείδην προσέειπε, κ.τ.λ. Hermann's conjecture is provisionally adopted in the text.

847. mvp-comment-596-1 ὡς .. λεύσσειν] 'Since ever in disease Sleep, which slumbers not, is quick to perceive.' πάντων ἐν νόσῳ, sc. ὄντων. ' Of all men, when they are sick.' (Others join πάντων εὐδρακής, ‘Having quick sight of all things.") λεύσσειν is epexegetic of εὐδρακής. Sleep is personified, and 'sight' used for perception in general. Cp. Trach. 1019.

850. mvp-comment-597-1 The text is defective, as the metre shows. κεῖνο is opposed to τάδε in 843, and means, therefore, not the abduction of Philoctetes, but the carrying away of the bow and arrows. The Chorus urge Neoptolemus not to be absorbed in gazing on Philoctetes, but to take a wider survey of the situation, that he may secure the object set before him by Odysseus. For λάθρα, σκοπῶν λαθραίως might be substituted to complete the line, which answers to supr. 834.

852. mvp-comment-598-1 The reading ὧν, which would answer to μενοῦμεν in 836, gives no satisfactory meaning. For the comparison of supr. 240, 1, αὐδῶμαι.. παῖς Ἀχιλλέως ('I call Achilles father') does not justify ὧν αὐδῶμαι = ' Whom I call master,' even if this were clearly in point. And if ὃν is read, the metre is the same as that of ll. 6 and 9. In this case αὐδῶμαι is active, as in Ο. Τ. 846. The question remains whether Philoctetes or Odysseus is the antecedent to ὃν. It seems necessary that τούτῳ in 853 should be the antecedent, and τούτῳ is Philoctetes. The Chorus may be supposed to speak vaguely of him, in order to avoid the possibility of awakening his suspicions, should he overhear them. 'If this be your mind towards him you wot of;' i. e. 'If you allow yourself to be so affected with pity, as you manifestly are, towards Philoctetes.' The Chorus thus gently warn their master of what follows in the ensuing scene. Prof. Jebb conjectures ὃν αἰδοῦμαι, 'Whose fear is before my eyes,' viz. Odysseus'. Others read ταὐτὸν . . γνώμας.

854. mvp-comment-599-1 ἐνιδεῖν = SC. ἐστὶν or ἔνεστιν, (1) 'The prudent may see therein inextricable harm.' Or, possibly, (2) 'One may see therein perplexing trouble for the wise' (i. e. for Odysseus).

855-862. mvp-comment-600-1 It is probable that Neoptolemus answered here; and to this the words βλέπ᾽ εἰ καίρια φθέγγει may be referred :- 'Whether you speak seasonably,' viz. in hinting that we must take him away. Else they must allude to supr. 826, 6, which is far off. οὖρος, κ.τ.λ.] This is to be taken literally, not figuratively with the Scholiast. Cp. supr. 639, 40, and note. Schndw. quotes Theocr. 13. 52, κουφότερ', ὦ παῖδες, ποιεῖσθ᾽ ὅπλα· πλευστικὸς οὖρος.

856. mvp-comment-601-1 οὐκ ἔχων ἀρωγάν] ‘Helpless, in sleep, disease and solitude, and in the loss of his arms.' For ἀνόμματος, 'Without use of eyes,' cp. supr. 632, ἄπουν, 'Lame.'

859. mvp-comment-602-1 νύχιος resumes ἀνόμματος with greater intensity. 'Sightless, as if steeped in night.' ἐκτέταται, ' Lies prostrate,' is stronger than κεῖται. ἀλεὴς ὕπνος ἐσθλός] ‘How kind is sleep, warm sleep!' A parenthesis like supr. 400, 1. To suppose a commonplace γνώμη, 'A man sleeps soundly in the sun,' is hardly adequate in feeling. It is rather an exclamation of joy that their invocation ( supr. 827 foll.) has been heard by the God of Sleep. For ἐσθλός, meaning propitious, cp. Od. 24. 311, ἢ τέ οἱ ἐσθλοὶ ἔσαν ὄρνιθες ἰόντι: ib. 19. 547, οὐκ ὄναρ, ἀλλ᾽ ὕπαρ ἐσθλόν: Ελ. 1093, μοίρᾳ μὲν οὐκ ἐν ἐσθλᾷ βεβῶσαν. If ἀλεής is suspected, ἀδαής rather than ἀδεής should be read, although the latter might be connected with l. 864. But it is rash to reject ἀλεής, when λιαρός is an Homeric epithet of ὕπνος: ΙΙ. 14. 164, ὕπνον ἀπήμονά τε λιαρόν τε. The notion of 'Sleep in the sun' agrees with αἴγλαν, supr. 831.

860. mvp-comment-603-1 οὔ τινος] An enumeration of this kind often ends with a general expression. Cp. O. Τ. 1284, 5. They are perhaps thinking of the bow, which they dare not name.

861. mvp-comment-604-1 'But sees no more than the dead.' Cp. O. Τ. 972, κεῖται παρ' "Αιδῃ Πόλυβος, and see Essay on L. § 54. P 99. Dindorf reads ἀλλ' ὡς τίς τ', 'formula epica.' But cp. l. 859.

862. mvp-comment-605-1 βλέπ᾽ εἰ] This is the easiest correction of a faulty text, and affords a possible meaning. Cp. supr. note on 855 foll. But it is doubtful whether βλέπε can mean 'See to it,' in classical Greek; and βλέπει may be a gloss on ὁρᾷ. φθέγγει is also open to suspicion.

862. mvp-comment-605-2 Blaydes conjectures βλέπει· καίρια φώνει. But Neoptolemus is the first to perceive the signs of waking in Philoctetes. Others, βλέπ᾽ εἰ καίρια φωνῶ.

863-864. mvp-comment-606-1 τὸ δ᾽ ἁλώσιμον *ἀμᾷ.. κράτιστος] 'So far as our minds can grasp, young sir, the toil that frightens not is best.' Cp. O. Τ. 1234, 5, ὃ μὲν τάχιστος τῶν λόγων εἰπεῖν τε καὶ μαθεῖν, τέθνηκε θεῖον Ἰοκάστης κάρα : Plat. Rep. 7.517 B, τὰ δ᾽ οὖν ἐμοὶ φαινόμενα οὕτω φαίνεται, ἐν τῷ γνωστῷ τελευταία ἡ τοῦ ἀγαθοῦ ἰδέα καὶ μόγις ὁρᾶσθαι. ἀμᾷ seems to be required by the indications of the metre (dactylic with anacrusis.) πόνος ὁ μὴ φοβῶν] The Chorus are probably using the language of fishermen, meaning that if Philoctetes is once alarmed, the capture of the bow will be more difficult. See above, l. 839, θήραν, and cp. Plato, Lys. 206 B, ποιός τις οὖν ἄν σοι δοκοί θηρευτὴς εἶναι, εἰ ἀνασοβοῖ θηρεύων καὶ δυσαλωτοτέραν τὴν ἄγραν ποιοῖ; Δῆλον ὅτι φαῦλος. For πόνος in this connection, cp. Pind. Pyth. 2. 79, ἅτε γὰρ εἰνάλιον πόνον ἐχοίσας βαθὺ | σκευᾶς ἑτέρας, ἀβάπτιστός εἰμι, φελλὸς ὡς ὑπὲρ ἕρκος, ἅλμας : Theocr. 21. 14, οὗτος τοῖς ἁλιεῦσιν ὁ πᾶς πόνος. The common interpretation, from the Scholiast downwards, has been, 'The labour that causes no fear,' i.e. that is not attended with danger.

865. mvp-comment-607-1 μηδ᾽ ἀφεστάναι φρενών] ‘And not take leave of your senses.' Cp. El. 1326, ὦ πλεῖστα μῶροι καὶ φρενῶν τητώμενοι, κ.τ.λ.

866. mvp-comment-608-1 For ἀνάγει, ‘Uplifts again,' cp. Αj. 131, κλίνει τε κἀνάγει πάλιν,

867-871. mvp-comment-609-1 Just when the plot against his peace is being urged most vehemently, Philoctetes awakes, and pours out touching words of unsuspecting thankfulness for the patient care, of which he little knows the motive. He throws himself afresh on Neoptolemus, and will have no support but his.

867-868. mvp-comment-610-1 ὦ φέγγος.. ξένων] 'Light after sleep, how welcome! And how surpassing fondest hope, the patient tendance of these friends!" For the construction of φέγγος and οἰκούρημα, cp. Trach. 1046, 7, ὦ πολλὰ . . μοχθήσας ἐγώ. διάδοχον] 'Succeeding, taking the place of (in my experience). ἐλπίδων ἄπιστον] 'Beyond the belief of expectation,' i.e. which I could not have believed beforehand. οἰκούρημα] More concrete than οἰκουρία = 'Act of keeping watch.' οἰκουρεῖν is, ‘Το keep watch over a person's property and interests in his absence.' So Neoptolemus has guarded the bow and the person of Philoctetes during his prostration, from the thievish attempt which he most feared.

869. mvp-comment-611-1 οὐκ ἂν ἐξηύχησα] 'I could not once have vaunted.' The aorist implies 'for a single moment,' and is thus more forcible here than the imperfect would have been.

871. mvp-comment-612-1 μεῖναι has been unreasonably suspected. Cavallin conjectures ἰδεῖν.

872. mvp-comment-613-1 οὔκουν ᾿Ατρείδαι] 'It was not the Atreidae, who-.' οὖν marks the reasonableness of Philoctetes' doubt, which was in accordance with the conduct of the Atreidae. *εὐφόρως] This seems the simplest correction of εὐπόρως. See Essay on L. § 55. p. 101. Others prefer εὐπετῶς, comparing Fr. 523, χρεὼν | τὰ θειᾶ θνητοὺς ὄντας εὐπετῶς φέρειν. Οr, εὐλόφως. Paley retains εὐπόρως.

874. mvp-comment-614-1 κἀξ εὐγενῶν] The frequent allusions to his father have a constraining power over the heart of Neoptolemus.

875. mvp-comment-615-1 ἐν εὐχερεῖ ἔθου] ‘Took as a light burden.'

876. mvp-comment-616-1 βοῆς] This reference of Philoctetes to his own cries makes us feel how involuntary they were. He knew them as an inseparable accompaniment of his presence anywhere.

877. mvp-comment-617-1 καὶ νῦν] Cp. O. T. 52, 3, ὄρνιθι γὰρ καὶ τὴν τότ᾽ αἰσίῳ τύχην | παρέσχες ἡμῖν, καὶ τανῦν ἴσος γενοῦ.

879. mvp-comment-618-1 Nauck, following A. Zippmann, transposes this line to before 890 and rejects 880 and 889. The apparent coldness of Neoptolemus, who in 886 ignores this appeal of Philoctetes to him, may, however, be accounted for by supposing that his consciousness of acting a part makes him less forward with the show of sympathy, now that his emotions are really stirred.

880. mvp-comment-619-1 Philoctetes is not yet confident that his powers are fully returned. The habit of lying perdu after each attack makes him less prompt to move. But he feels that he must be ready to start as soon as he can. (But qy. ἡ. ἀ. τὸ πνεῦμ᾽ ἀπ. ποτέ? Cp. supr. 639, 40.)

882. mvp-comment-620-1 μέν prepares for the narrative in νῦν δ᾽ αἷρε σαὐτόν.

883. mvp-comment-621-1 ἀνώδυνον βλέποντα] 'Opening thine eyes without the look of pain.' βλέποντα is sometimes put simply as an equivalent for ζῶντα, e.g. Aesch. Ag. 677, καὶ ζῶντα καὶ βλέποντα. But here the expression is modified by the addition of ἀνώδυνον as an adverbial accusative (i. e. not only seeing the light but free from the look of pain). Others take ἀνώδυνον as a masculine adjective, and make ἀνώδυνον βλέποντα = 'Living in freedom from pain.'

884. mvp-comment-622-1 τὰ συμβόλαιά σοι. . ἐφαίνετο] Either (1) 'Your commerce with the circumstances surrounding you: i.e. Your behaviour in the present juncture:' a figurative use of the ordinary meaning of συμβόλαια: or (2) 'Your symptoms, when regarded in the light of your affliction:' i. e. 'Considering your peculiar case your appearance suggested the inference that you were dead.' The latter meaning (2) receives some confirmation from Hdt. 5. 92, 7, and, more doubtfully, from Eur. Ion 411, quoted by L. and S. But the former is better on the whole, and agrees with σοι, the reading of the chief MS. See v. rr.

887-888. mvp-comment-623-1 Cp. supr. 522, 3. Neoptolemus professes to be encouraged by these words of the Chorus to assume that they will not spare pains in helping Philoctetes, whose wishes are seconded by their prince.

889. mvp-comment-624-1 ὥσπερ νοεῖς] 'As you really mean.' Philoctetes does not take the refusal of Neoptolemus to lift him with his own hands. He is too much impressed with his actual kindness to be at once affected by the coldness and reserve of his language.

892. mvp-comment-625-1 συνναίειν] For the infinitive, see Essay on L. § 33. p. 57 , and cp. especially O. C. 1211, 2, ὅστις τοῦ πλέονος μέρους χρήζει . . ζώειν.

893. mvp-comment-626-1 Neoptolemus gives Philoctetes his hand, but bids him exert himself, and put forth his strength in using the support. He is roused by this and makes the necessary exertion.

894. mvp-comment-627-1 'Fear not. Long habit will enable me to rise.'

895. mvp-comment-628-1 If Neoptolemus had followed the course marked out for him, he would have taken Philoctetes on board, and only when out at sea have let him discover the destination of the voyage. But now that the decisive moment is arrived, he cannot deceive the unfortunate who has trusted him. For the optative (potential) without av, see E. on L. § 27. p. 45. Others read δῆτ᾽ ἄν.

896. mvp-comment-629-1 'What mean such words, my son? Whither tends this sudden diversion?'

897. mvp-comment-630-1 'I know not which way to express what is so full of perplexity.' τάπορον . . ἔπος is the word that can neither be spoken nor kept silent.

898. mvp-comment-631-1 Philoctetes cannot bear that doubts should rise just when his hopes are on the point of being fulfilled.

899. mvp-comment-632-1 (1) 'But I am at such a point of difficulty (that I must speak).' τοῦδε πάθους, sc. τῆς ἀπορίας, from ἀπορεῖς, supr. Or (2) simply, 'I am in a difficulty.' Cp. Aesch. Choeph. 891, ἐνταῦθα γὰρ δὴ τοῦδ᾽ ἀφικόμην κακοῦ.

900. mvp-comment-633-1 οὐ δή] 'Surely it cannot be-;' i.e. 'I trust it is not.' Cp. Trach. 668, and note.