901–1050
Philoctetes. Lewis Campbell. ed. Lewis Campbell. Oxford. 1879.
Philoctetes. Lewis Campbell. ed. Lewis Campbell. Oxford. 1879.
Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879) (OCR draft) (English) (Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879))
Provisional text from uncorrected OCR; expect errors.
mvp-comment-493-1 ἅπαντα δυσχέρεια 1
mvp-comment-493-2 τὴν αὑτοῦ φύσιν 2 λιπών 3 τὰ μὴ προσεικότα 4
mvp-comment-494-1 οὐδὲν ἔξω τοῦ φυτεύσαντος 5 φυτεύσαντος 6 προσεικότος 7 τοὐμφυτευθέντος 8
mvp-comment-494-2 ἐσθλὸν 9
mvp-comment-495-1 πάλαι 10
mvp-comment-496-1 οὔκουν 11 ἐν οἷς γε δρᾷς 12 ἐν οἷς δὲ αὐδᾷς 13
mvp-comment-496-2 ὀκνῶ 14 δρᾷς 15
mvp-comment-497-1 δράσω 16 λέγων αἴσχιστ’ ἐπῶν 17 κρύπτων ἃ μὴ δεῖ 18
mvp-comment-498-1 ἁνὴρ ὅδ’ 19
mvp-comment-498-2 εἰ μὴ )γὼ 20 γνώμην 21 γνώμων 22
mvp-comment-498-3 τὸν πλοῦν στελεῖν 23
mvp-comment-499-1 λιπὼν 24
mvp-comment-499-2 πέμπω 25 πέμπων 26 τοῦτ’ 27 τοῦτ’ ἀνιῶμαι πάλαι 28
mvp-comment-500-1 οὐδέν σε κρύψω 29
mvp-comment-500-2 γὰρ 30
mvp-comment-501-1 τί <δ)> εἶπας 31 δ’ 32 τί εἶπας 33 τί μ’ εἶπας 34 τί γ’ εἶπας 35
mvp-comment-501-2 πρὶν μάθῃς 36
mvp-comment-501-3 ποῖον μάθημα 37
mvp-comment-501-4 δρᾶσαι 38
mvp-comment-502-1 σῶσαι κακοῦ 39
mvp-comment-502-2 ξὺν σοὶ 40
mvp-comment-503-1 καὶ ταῦτ’ 41
mvp-comment-503-2 ἀληθῆ 42
mvp-comment-503-3 κρατεῖ τούτων 43
mvp-comment-504-1 ὦ ξένε 44
mvp-comment-505-1 ἀλλ’ οὐχ οἷόν τε 45
mvp-comment-505-2 τῶν ἐν τέλει 46
mvp-comment-505-3 927 ff. While Philoctetes makes this appeal, Neoptolemus stands with averted face (935), still holding the bow. Despairing anguish could not be more pathetically expressed than by the transitions from imprecation to entreaty, and from entreaty to the half-soliloquy in which he imagines the future (952).
mvp-comment-506-1 πῦρ 47 πῦρ 48 δεῖμα 49
mvp-comment-506-2 πᾶν δεῖμα 50 δεῖμα 51
mvp-comment-506-3 πανουργίας … τέχνημα 52 τέχνημα 53
mvp-comment-507-1 εἰργάσω 54
mvp-comment-508-1 τὸν προστρόπαιον 55
mvp-comment-509-1 τὸν βίον 56
mvp-comment-509-2 932 A dactyl is here followed by a tribrach, as in 1029 we have two tribrachs. In both verses the rhythm marks agitation.
mvp-comment-510-1 θεῶν πατρῴων 57
mvp-comment-510-2 με μὴ ἀφέλῃ 58
mvp-comment-511-1 προσφωνεῖ 59
mvp-comment-511-2 ὡς μεθήσων μήποθ’ 60 ὁρᾷ πάλιν 61
mvp-comment-512-1 λιμένες 62 προβλῆτες 63
mvp-comment-512-2 ξυνουσίαι θηρῶν 64
mvp-comment-512-3 καταρρῶγες 65
mvp-comment-513-1 λέγω 66
mvp-comment-513-2 ἀνακλαίομαι 67
mvp-comment-513-3 παροῦσι 68 τοῖς εἰωθόσιν 69 παροῦσι 70
mvp-comment-514-1 ὀμόσας 71
mvp-comment-514-2 προσθείς 72 προθείς 73
mvp-comment-515-1 ἱερὰ 74 τοῦ Ζηνὸς Ἡρακλέους 75 ἱερὰ 76 τοῦ Ζ. Ἡρ 77 τοῦ Ζ. Ἡρακλ. 78
mvp-comment-516-1 φήνασθαι 79 φήνασθαι 80 φήνασθαι 81
mvp-comment-516-2 Seyffert, placing only a comma after θέλει 82 κοὐχ ὡς 83 κοὐκ οἶδ’ 84 ὡς 85 κοὐχ ὡς 86 ὡς 87 θέλει 88 ὡς ἑλὼν 89
mvp-comment-517-1 κοὐκ οἶδ’ 90
mvp-comment-517-2 ἐναίρων νεκρὸν 91
mvp-comment-517-3 καπνοῦ σκιάν 92
mvp-comment-517-4 εἴδωλον ἄλλως 93 ἄλλως 94
mvp-comment-518-1 ἐπεὶ οὐδ’ 95
mvp-comment-519-1 ἀλλ’ 96
mvp-comment-519-2 ἀλλὰ νῦν 97
mvp-comment-519-3 ἐν σαυτῷ γενοῦ 98 ἔτι 99 ἐν σαυτοῦ 100
mvp-comment-520-1 σιωπᾷς 101 οὐδέν εἰμ’ 102
mvp-comment-521-1 ὦ σχῆμα πέτρας δίπυλον 103 σχῆμα 104
mvp-comment-521-2 αὖθις αὖ πάλιν 105
mvp-comment-521-3 953 The MSS. and edd. give πρὸς σὲ 106 πρός σε 107
mvp-comment-521-4 ψιλός 108
mvp-comment-522-1 αὐανοῦμαι 109
mvp-comment-523-1 πτηνὸν 110 ὀρειβάτην 111
mvp-comment-523-2 τοισίδ’ 112 τοισίδ’ 113 τοῖσδ’ ἔτ’ 114
mvp-comment-524-1 παρέξω δαῖτα 115 ὑφ’ ὧν ἐφερβ 116
mvp-comment-524-2
Wunder proposes
mvp-comment-525-1 καί μ’ 119 κἄμ’ 120 ἐθήρων 121 θηράσουσι 122
mvp-comment-526-1 ῥύσιον 123 φόνον φόνου … ῥύσιον τείσω 124 φόνου 125
mvp-comment-526-2 τοῦ δοκοῦντος 126
mvp-comment-526-3 οὐδὲν εἰδέναι κακόν 127
mvp-comment-527-1 ὄλοιο 128
mvp-comment-527-2 μήπω 129 μήπω 130
mvp-comment-527-3 πρὶν μάθοιμ’ 131
mvp-comment-527-4 εἰ καὶ πάλιν 132 καὶ 133 εἰ 134 καὶ 135 εἰ καὶ πάλιν 136
mvp-comment-527-5 καὶ 137 πάλιν 138 μετοίσεις 139 πάλιν μετοίσεις 140
mvp-comment-528-1 δρῶμεν 141
mvp-comment-528-2 ἐν σοὶ 142
mvp-comment-528-3 προσχωρεῖν 143
mvp-comment-529-1 ἐμοὶ μὲν 144
mvp-comment-529-2 ἐμπέπτωκε 145 οὐ νῦν πρῶτον 146
mvp-comment-530-1 ἐλἐησον 147
mvp-comment-530-2 παρῇς σαυτοῦ βρ. ὄνειδος 148
mvp-comment-530-3 ἐκκλέψας 149
mvp-comment-531-1 μήποτ’ 150 λιπεῖν 151 ὤφελον 152
mvp-comment-531-2 Σκῦρον 153
mvp-comment-532-1 νῦν δ’ ἄλλοισι δοὺς 154 οἷς εἰκός 155 οὐκ εἶ κακὸς σύ 156 ἄλλοισι 157
mvp-comment-532-2 Other interpretations are: (1) δοὺς 158 ἄλλοις σε δοὺς 159 οἷα 160 ἄλλοισι 161
mvp-comment-532-3
974 We are to suppose that Odysseus,—disquieted when he found that the
mvp-comment-532-4 975 Join εἶ … πάλιν 162
mvp-comment-533-1 πέπραμαι 163
mvp-comment-534-1 ἅμ’ αὐτοῖς 164 στελοῦσί σε 165 αὐτοῖς 166
mvp-comment-535-1 τολμήστατε 167
mvp-comment-536-1 οἵδ’ 168
mvp-comment-536-2 μὴ ἕρπῃς 169 η 170 ε 171 α 172 γ’ 173 ἕρπῃς 174
mvp-comment-536-3 986 f. For the voc. combined with nom., cp. 867 n.
mvp-comment-536-4 τὸ παγκρατὲς σέλας Ἡφαιστότευκτον 175
mvp-comment-536-5
The Lemnians had an early repute as workers in iron: Tzetzes on Lycophr. 460
mvp-comment-537-1 εἰ … ἀπάξεται 176
mvp-comment-537-2 τῶν σῶν 177
mvp-comment-538-1 Ζεύς 178 ἵν’ εἰδῇς 179
mvp-comment-539-1 μῖσος 180
mvp-comment-539-2 καὶ ἐξανευρίσκεις 181 λέγειν 182 λέγων 183
mvp-comment-540-1 προτείνων 184 ψευδεῖς τίθης 185
mvp-comment-541-1 ἀληθεῖς 186
mvp-comment-541-2 ἡ δ’ ὁδὸς 187
mvp-comment-542-1 οὐ φήμ’ 188
mvp-comment-542-2 ἐγὼ δὲ φημί 189
mvp-comment-542-3 πειστέον τάδε 190
mvp-comment-543-1 ἡμᾶς μὲν 191
mvp-comment-544-1 τοῖς ἀρίστοισιν 192
mvp-comment-544-2 κατασκάψαι 193
mvp-comment-545-1 οὐδέποτέ γ’ 194
mvp-comment-545-2 πᾶν … κακόν 195
mvp-comment-545-3 γῆς τόδ’ αἰπεινὸν βάθρον 196
mvp-comment-546-1 ἐργασείεις 197
mvp-comment-547-1 πέτρᾳ 198 αἱμάξω 199
mvp-comment-547-2 πέτρας 200 πεσών 201 ἄνωθεν 202
mvp-comment-548-1 ξυλλάβετον αὐτόν 203 ξυλλάβετ’ αὐτόν 204 γε 205 ξυλλάβετε 206
mvp-comment-548-2 μὴ )πὶ τῷδ’ 207
mvp-comment-549-1 ὦ χεῖρες 208
mvp-comment-549-2 ἐν χρείᾳ 209
mvp-comment-549-3 συνθηρώμεναι 210
mvp-comment-550-1 ὦ μηδὲν ὑγιὲς … φρονῶν 211
mvp-comment-550-2 μηδὲν ὑγιές 212
mvp-comment-550-3 ἐλεύθερον 213
mvp-comment-551-1 οἷ’ αὖ μ’ ὑπῆλθες 214
mvp-comment-551-2 ὑπῆλθες 215
mvp-comment-552-1 πρόβλημα 216
mvp-comment-553-1 ἀνάξιον μὲν σοῦ 217 σοῦ 218
mvp-comment-553-2 οὐδὲν ᾔδει πλὴν 219
mvp-comment-554-1 καὶ νῦν 220
mvp-comment-554-2 οἷς 221
mvp-comment-555-1 διὰ μυχῶν βλέπους’ 222
mvp-comment-555-2 ἀφυᾶ 223 ‐εα 224 ε 225 ‐εᾶ 226 ι 227 υ 228 ‐ιᾶ 229 ‐λῆ; ‐υᾶ 230 ‐υῆ 231 ᾶ 232 ῆ 233
mvp-comment-555-3 προὐδίδαξεν 234
mvp-comment-556-1 συνδήσας 235 ἄγειν 236
mvp-comment-556-2 προὐβάλου 237
mvp-comment-556-3 ἄπολιν 238
mvp-comment-557-1 θεοὶ 239
mvp-comment-557-2 1022 ff. Seyffert puts a comma after ζῶ 240 σὺν κακοῖς πολλοῖς 241 γελώμενος 242 σὺν κακοῖς πολλοῖς 243 ζῶ 244 σὺν κακοῖς πολλοῖς 245 ζῶ 246
mvp-comment-557-3 τῶν Ἀτρέως … στρατηγῶν 247
mvp-comment-558-1 κλοπῇ τε κἀνάγκῃ ζυγεὶς 248 ζυγεὶς 249
mvp-comment-559-1 ἑπτὰ ναυσὶ 250
mvp-comment-560-1 ἔβαλον 251 ὡς σὺ φής 252
mvp-comment-561-1 ἄγετε 253 ἀπάγεσθε 254
mvp-comment-561-2 οὐδέν εἰμι 255 τέθνηχ’ ὑμῖν 256
mvp-comment-562-1 σοι 257
mvp-comment-562-2 δυσώδης 258
mvp-comment-562-3 πῶς … ἔξεσθ’, ὁμοῦ 259 πῶς … εὔξεσθ’, ἐμοῦ 260 εὔξεσθ’ 261 εὔξεσθ’ 262 ἔξεσθ’ 263 ὁμοῦ 264 ἐμοῦ 265 εὔξεσθ’ ἐμοῦ 266 ἔξεστ’ ἐμοῦ 267 ἔξεσθ’ ὁμοῦ 268 θ’ 269 θεοῖς 270
mvp-comment-562-4 Against ἔξεσθ’ 271
mvp-comment-563-1 ὄλοισθ)· ὀλεῖσθε δ’ 272
mvp-comment-564-1 μέλει γ’ 273
mvp-comment-564-2 ἐπεὶ οὔποτ’ 274 ἀνδρὸς ἀθλίου 275
mvp-comment-564-3 1039 For the place of τι 276
mvp-comment-564-4 κέντρον … ἐμοῦ 277
mvp-comment-565-1 θεοί τ’ ἐπόψιοι 278
mvp-comment-565-2 Thus the invocation of πατρῴα γῆ 279 ἐπόψιοι 280
mvp-comment-566-1 τείσασθε 281
mvp-comment-566-2 ἀλλὰ τῷ χρόνῳ 282
mvp-comment-567-1 κἄμ’ 283
mvp-comment-568-1 τῆς vόσου 284
mvp-comment-569-1 βαρύς 285
mvp-comment-569-2 κοὐχ ὑπείκ. 286
mvp-comment-570-1 παρείκοι 287
mvp-comment-570-2 ἑνὸς κρατῶ λόγου 288
mvp-comment-571-1 γὰρ 289
mvp-comment-571-2 τοιούτων 290 τοιούτων 291 πανούργων 292
mvp-comment-571-3 κρίσις 293
mvp-comment-571-4 μου 294
901. mvp-comment-634-1 ναύτην] 'On board your ship.' ναύτης here = πλωτήρ. The word is used predicatively. For both, cp. Aesch. Pers. 719, πεζὸς ἡ ναύτης δὲ πεῖραν τήνδ' ἐμώρανεν τάλας;
902. mvp-comment-635-1 ἅπαντα δυσχέρεια] ‘There is nothing but unpleasantness.' For this use of the abstract noun, cp. O. C. 883, ἆρ᾽ οὐχ ὕβρις τάδ';
903. mvp-comment-636-1 ὅταν is postponed to give greater emphasis to τὴν αὐτοῦ φύσιν. λιπών] Cp. supr. 865, ἀφεστάναι.
904. mvp-comment-637-1 ἔξω τοῦ φυτεύσαντος] 'From (i. e. 'alien to') your father's strain.' ἔξω is suggested by λιπών and φυτεύσαντος by φύσιν. Mollweide very ingeniously conjectured τοῦ προσεικότος (which, as Nauck observes, might be corrupted to τοῦ πατρὸς εἰκότος), but his conjecture is less forcible than the text.
907. mvp-comment-638-1 'There is certainly no baseness in what you are doing. But for what your speech may imply, I feel afraid.' For ὀκνῶ, describing a state of vague, but painful apprehension, cp. O. T. 746, 749. For the ellipse, ὀκνῶ (μὴ αἰσχρὸς φανῇς), see Essay on L. § 39, 6. p. 74. Nauck unnecessarily conjectured ἐφ᾽ οἷς.
908. mvp-comment-639-1 δεύτερον] 'A second time.' He is already convicted of baseness in his own mind for having concealed his intention, and he foresees the reproach which the avowal of this same intention will draw down upon him.
910. mvp-comment-640-1 The idea of the homeward voyage is so vividly present to Philoctetes' mind, that the only evil intention he can imagine in Neoptolemus is that of leaving him behind.
912. mvp-comment-641-1 λιπών.. ἔγωγε] Sc. στελῶ τὸν πλοῦν.
912-913. mvp-comment-642-1 μὴ | πέμπω] The position of the words has the effect of throwing a strong emphasis on πέμπω.
914. mvp-comment-643-1 τί ποτε] The trisyllablic foot marks increasing agitation. Cp. infr. 923, 4.
915-916. mvp-comment-644-1 'Ex his tantum abest ut posterior versus ejiciendus sit, ut ejus adjectione eximie ostenderit Sophocles, quam penitus perspectam haberet animi humani naturam. Nam ubi quis semel ab se impetravit ut proferat quod celare jussus erat, jam, quasi expiaturus non recte factum, non aliquid, sed omnia cupit effundere.' (Hermann.) It may be observed here that the στιχομυθίαι in the Philoctetes are, like the style generally, less severely regular than in any of the other plays.
917. mvp-comment-645-1 πρὶν μάθης] 'Till you understand the case.' Neoptolemus indulges the hope, which he only abandons at the last moment ( infr. 1391), that Philoctetes may see that it is for his advantage to go to Troy.
919-920. mvp-comment-646-1 He here states briefly that which at a more favourable moment ( infr. 1326-47) he explains at full.
920. mvp-comment-647-1 τὰ .. πεδία] A periphrasis for Τροίαν. Cp. infr. 1332. The extent of the Trojan plain struck the imagination of the Greeks who lived in a broken, uneven country.
921. mvp-comment-648-1 ἀληθῆ] 'In very deed.' For the adverbial predicate, see Essay on L. § 23. p. 38.
922. mvp-comment-649-1 πολλή.. ἀνάγκη] ‘This is ruled by strong necessity.' κρατεῖ τούτων, sc. ὥστε οὕτω γενέσθαι. καί] 'And therefore.' καί with imperatives has often a slightly illative force. Cp. Plat. Gorg. 449 C, τούτου μὴν δεῖ, ὦ Γοργία· καί μοι ἐπίδειξιν αὐτοῦ τούτου ποίησαι.
923. mvp-comment-650-1 ὦ ξένε] This change in the manner of address, from ὦ τέκνον, supr. 914, marks the transition from confidence to estrangement on the part of Philoctetes.
926. mvp-comment-651-1 τό τ᾽ ἔνδικόν.. ποιεῖ] 'Duty and interest alike compel me.' Cp. supr. 50 foll., 111 foll.
927-962. mvp-comment-652-1 In this passionate outburst Philoctetes first reproaches Neoptolemus, then appeals to his feelings of honour and compassion, then meekly supplicates him. Then (934), when Neoptolemus turns away to hide the impression thus made on him, Philoctetes, thinking him obdurate, complains to the unconscious companions of his solitude. His speech insensibly returns to Neoptolemus, with whom he again pleads, first indirectly, then with one brief direct appeal (l.950). When this is answered by silence, he yields to despair, and turns his face and his complaint towards the lonesome cave. Once more (961) his mind reverts to him who has been so cruel, but had seemed so guileless, and before cursing him, he waits to know whether Neoptolemus will even yet repent.
927. mvp-comment-653-1 πῦρ] Cp. O. T. 190, 1, and note. πᾶν δεῖμα] In this and similar expressions ( supr. 622) it is doubted whether πᾶς is distributive or intensive, attributive or predicative. (1) πᾶν distributive: i. e. 'terror of every kind' (not only πῦρ). (2) πᾶν intensive, 'entire' or 'utter terror.' The latter is more probable. 'Thou that art fire and terror unrelieved.' πανουργίας . . ἔχθιστον] · 'Most hateful piece of knavish villany.' For the abstract neuter substantive applied to persons in expressing dislike, cp. λάλημα, μίσος, λῆμα, etc. So φθέγμα in expressing affection.
929-930. mvp-comment-654-1 οὐδ᾽ ἐπαισχύνει.. σχέτλιε] This is more forcible when taken interrogatively as a separate sentence. It is otherwise with the brief clause οὐδ' ἐπαισχύνει λέγων in Αj. 1307.
930-932. mvp-comment-655-1 The iteration and the broken rhythm (l.932 has three trisyllabic feet) are expressive of distracted feeling.
935. mvp-comment-656-1 ὧδ'] 'Even so.' For the emphatic resumption of the antecedent, see E. on L. § 40. p. 75. πάλιν] 'The opposite way.' 'Avertit vultum.' Brunck. Cp. Eur. Med. 411, καὶ δίκα καὶ πάντα πάλιν στρέφεται.
936. mvp-comment-657-1 προβλῆτες] The substantive is more easily omitted with πέτραι following in the next line.
936-937. mvp-comment-658-1 ξυνουσίαι θηρῶν ὀρείων] 'Wild comrades of the hills.' Cp. supr. 184, 5, στικτῶν ἢ λασίων μετὰ θηρῶν, and for the abstract word, Eur. Alc. 606, ἀνδρῶν Φεραίων εὐμενὴς παρουσία.
939. mvp-comment-659-1 ἀνακλαίομαι] 'I complain in my own behalf.' Such is the force of the middle voice. Cp. Antiphon, 119, 24, ἀποστερούμενος δὲ ὑπ᾿ αὐτῶν μηδὲ τὰς παρούσας ἀτυχίας ἀνακλαύσασθαι πρὸς ὑμᾶς, ἀπορῶ εἰς ἥντινα ἄλλην σωτηρίαν χρή με καταφυγεῖν, Trach. 153. εἰωθόσιν] Sc. παρεῖναι.
940. mvp-comment-660-1 Cp. supr. 260, and note.
942. mvp-comment-661-1 χεῖρα δεξιάν] Cp. supr. 813, and note. And for προστίθημι in a similar connection, cp. El. 47, ὅρκῳ προστιθείς: Fr. 428, ὅρκου δὲ προστεθέντος ἐπιμελεστέρα | ψυχὴ κατέστη.
943. mvp-comment-662-1 For the slight transposition of the order of the words = ἱερὰ τοῦ .. Ἡρακλέους, λαβὼν ἔχει, see Essay on L. § 41. p. 77. Ιn τοῦ Ζηνὸς Ἡρακλέους the second genitive has become a sort of epithet. Cp. Ant. 154, ὁ Θήβας . Βάκχιος.
944. mvp-comment-663-1 φήνασθαι] 'To show them as his own.'
945. mvp-comment-664-1 ἐκ βίας μ' ἄγει] ‘He seeks to carry me away by force.' In taking the bow, Neoptolemus tries to force Philoctetes to depart. Philoctetes feels this, though he prefers to die.
946-947. mvp-comment-665-1 Ср. О. C. 109, 10, οἰκτείρατ᾿ ἀνδρὸς Οἰδίπου τόδ᾽ ἄθλιον | εἴδωλον, οὐ γὰρ δὴ τὸ γ' ἀρχαῖον δέμας.
947-948. mvp-comment-666-1 οὐ γὰρ.. δόλῳ] These words are especially calculated to wound the pride of Neoptolemus.
949. mvp-comment-667-1 τί . . δρᾶν] He returns upon himself for a moment, but, finding no resource, makes one more effort to reach the heart of Neoptolemus. He is met with silence.
950. mvp-comment-668-1 Cp. Ant. 552, τί δῆτ᾽ ἂν ἀλλὰ νῦν σ᾽ ἔτ᾿ ὠφελοῖμ᾽ ἐγώ; For ἐν σαυτῷ γενοῦ, 'Return to thy true self,' cp. Xen. An. 1. 5. 17, ἀκούσας ταῦτα ὁ Κλέαρχος ἐν ἑαυτῷ ἐγένετο : Aj. 639,40, οὐκέτι συντρόφοις ὀργαῖς ἔμπεδος. The other idiom, ἐν σαυτοῦ, read in Par. A. ('esto apud te,' Lamb.), is a humorous expression unsuited for tragedy.
952. mvp-comment-669-1 σχῆμα πέτρας δίπυλον] 'Rock formed with twofold doorway,' i.e. πέτρα δίπυλος ἐσχηματισμένη. For a similar periphrasis, cp. Eur. Alc. 911, ὦ σχῆμα δύμων, πῶς εἰσέλθω ; ‘A common periphrasis for any object that presents itself to the eye in a familiar form.' Paley. αὖθις αὖ πάλιν] Supr. 930, 932.
953. mvp-comment-670-1 ψιλός .. τροφήν] 'Without means of defence or sustenance.' Cp. Αj. 1123, κἂν ψιλὸς ἀρκέσαιμι σοί γ' ὡπλισμένῳ : infr. 1125, 6, χερὶ πάλλων | τὰν ἐμὰν μελέου τροφάν.
954. mvp-comment-671-1 αὐανοῦμαι] There can be no doubt about this reading, though the notion of a 'second death' (see v. rr. and cp. νεκρόν, supr. 946) has infected the MSS. τῷδ᾽ ἐν αὐλίῳ] Cp. supr. 19, infr. 1087.
957. mvp-comment-672-1 For the suppressed antecedent (τοῖς οἱ ἐκείνοις), cp. Εl. 1060, τροφᾶς κηδομένους ἀφ᾽ ὧν . . βλάστωσιν.
959. mvp-comment-673-1 ῥύσιον] 'In requital.' ῥύσιον is (a) that which is rescued from plunder, (b) what is taken in reprisal, (c) an act of reprisal or requital.
960. mvp-comment-674-1 For πρός, κ.τ.λ. after a verb in the active voice, see Essay on L. § 36. p. 64.
961. mvp-comment-675-1 ὄλοιο μή πω] 'Perish-not yet!' The curse already on his lips ( ὅλοιο) is suspended by the addition of the negative and changed to ὄλοιο μή πω, κ.τ.λ. then finally resumed in θάνοις. πρὶν μάθοιμ᾽] Cp. supr. 325, and note.
962. mvp-comment-676-1 καί] Cp. infr. 1270, οὔκουν ένεστι καὶ μεταγῶναι πάλιν;
963. mvp-comment-677-1 δρῶμεν] Conjunctive mood.
964. mvp-comment-678-1 ἤδη is to be joined with πλεῖν, 'To sail at once.' Cp. supr. 466, ἤδη · στέλλεσθε;
968. mvp-comment-679-1 σαυτοῦ] Some editors prefer σαυτῷ, the reading of I, i.e. 'Do not let thy name become a reproach amongst men.' But the reading of L is sound. 'Suffer not this reproach against thee to go forth amongst men.' ἐκκλέψας ἐμέ] 'Through your deceiving me.' Cp supr. 55.
969. mvp-comment-680-1 δράσω] Aor. conjunctive.
972. mvp-comment-681-1 ἔοικας ἥκειν] For this conversational periphrasis, see Essay on L. § 41. p. 77, a , and cp. Ant. 1279 foll. For δούς used like ἐνδούς, ‘yielding' ( cp. the intransitive use of 'give' in English), see Essay on L. § 55. p. 101, 4. Cp. also the turn of expression in Aj. 483, 4, παῦσαί γε μέντοι καὶ δὸς ἀνδράσιν φίλοις | γνώμης κρατῆσαι, τάσδε φροντίδας μεθείς : Eur. Phoen. 21, ἡδονῇ δούς.
979. mvp-comment-682-1 ξυλλαβών] Cp. supr. 945, and note.
981. mvp-comment-683-1 παῖ] Cp. supr. 967. The hateful sight of Odysseus drives Philoctetes once again to throw himself on the mercy of Neoptolemus. Cp. Lear, 2. 4, 'Those wicked creatures yet do look well-favoured, When others are more wicked; not being the worst | Stands in some rank of praise. I'll go with thee.'
982. mvp-comment-684-1 For the situation, cp. О. С. 858 foll.
983. mvp-comment-685-1 στείχειν ἅμ᾿ αὐτοῖς] ‘Το march along with them.' The pronoun αὐτοῖς refers to Neoptolemus and his attendants. Here, as infr. 1003, the language is assisted by the scene. Others refer αὐτοῖς to the bow, but in this case some other verb than στείχειν would be required.
986-988. mvp-comment-686-1 Cp. supr. 800, infr. 1464.
987. mvp-comment-687-1 Cp. supr. 376, and note.
988. mvp-comment-688-1 τῶν σῶν] Sc. χωρίων. The pron. refers to Λημνία χθών, the words καὶ.. Ἡφαιστότευκτον being διὰ μέσου.
989. mvp-comment-689-1 ἵν᾽ εἰδῇς] 'I tell you!' Cp. Aesch. Cho. 439, ἐμασχαλίσθη δ᾽ ἔθ᾽ ὡς τόδ' εἰδῇς. In such expressions there is an ellipse of λέγω. τῆσδε γῆς] Lemnos.
992. mvp-comment-690-1 Ср. О. С. 277. Zeus is false to Heracles if he favours the design against his friend.
993. mvp-comment-691-1 The removal of Philoctetes fulfils the prophecy of Helenus, and thus establishes the truthfulness of the gods.
994. mvp-comment-692-1 'I say, No! for my part.' 'But I say, Yes! you must be ruled.' Gernhard conjectured, ΦΙ. οὔ φημ'. ΟΔ. ἐγὼ δέ φημι
997. mvp-comment-693-1 ἄρα is postponed because of the energy with which the first words of the sentence are spoken. See Essay on L. § 26. p. 44.
998. mvp-comment-694-1 τοῖς ἀρίστοισιν] Neoptolemus.
1000. mvp-comment-695-1 γῆς .. βάθρον] 'This Lemnian steep.' Cp. Aj. 859, ὦ γῆς ἱερὸν οἰκείας πέδον | Σαλαμίνος. For the descriptive pleonasm of γῆς, cp. Aesch. Prom. 433, * Αϊδος.. μυχὸς γᾶς.
1002. mvp-comment-696-1 πέτρᾳ] 'On the rock;' i.e. ἐν πέτρα = εἰς πέτραν (rather than instrum. dat.), to be joined with αἱμάξω. πέτρας is ablative genitive with πεσών.
1003. mvp-comment-697-1 ξυλλάβετέ γ' αὐτόν] ‘Ay, apprehend him.' ye may be explained by supposing the attendants to have advanced of their own accord on seeing the intention of Philoctetes. Recent editors have adopted G. Bernhardy's conjecture, ξυλλάβετον αὐτόν, supposing Odysseus to address his two attendants, the usual δύ' ἀμφίπολοι of Epic poetry. But if this were right the same dual form of command would have been found elsewhere, e.g. in O. С. 840, 847.
1005. mvp-comment-698-1 ἀνδρὸς τοῦδε] 'Odysseus,' said with bitter emphasis. Cp. supr. 376, εἰ τἀμὰ κεῖνος ὅπλ᾽ ἀφαιρήσοιτό με. συνθηρώμεναι is at once 'caught' and 'bound.'
1007. mvp-comment-699-1 οἷ᾽ αὖ] This seems a more probable correction of οἷα than οἷον, which, though found in some MSS., may have arisen from a gloss. *αὖ] 'Again,' as you did ten years ago, when you took advantage of me sleeping; supr. 271 foll.
1008. mvp-comment-700-1 πρόβλημα σαυτοῦ] ‘As your stalking-horse.' πρόβλημα is in apposition to παῖδα. For προβάλλεσθαι, as a word of blame, cp. Thuc. 1. 37, τὸ εὐπρεπὲς ἄσπονδον . . προβέβληνται.
1009. mvp-comment-701-1 ἀνάξιον.. ἐμοῦ] 'Who does not deserve to be thy minister, but well deserves to be my friend.'
1012. mvp-comment-702-1 For the dative after ἀλγεινῶς φέρων = ἀχθόμενος, see Essay on L. § 14. p. 21, and § 36. p. 64.
1013. mvp-comment-703-1 διὰ μυχῶν βλέπουσ᾽] This is differently explained, (1) 'Spying into hidden places' (so Musgrave, who compares Philo J. 2. p. 78, τὸν ἀεὶ βλέποντα καὶ τὰ ἐν μυχοῖς τῆς διανοίας). For this cp. Αj. 11, καί σ᾽ οὐδὲν εἴσω τῆσδε παπταίνειν πύλης | ἔτ᾽ ἔργον ἐστίν. Or (2) 'Spying out of hiding holes' ('per latebras prospiciens,' Schndw.). The latter (2) is preferable. For the point here is, not that Philoctetes was hidden in his cave, but that Odysseus himself keeps out of sight, while he watches the proceedings of Neoptolemus. This also gives a better meaning. ‘By διά is meant looking through the intervening darkness.' (Paley.) Cp. Aj. 381, κακοπινέστατόν τ᾿ ἄλημα στρατοῦ: ib. 390, and note.
1014. mvp-comment-704-1 ἀφυῆ] ‘Unapt,' sc. πρὸς τὸ τοιοῦτὸν τι ποιεῖν: or, as Seyffert puts it, ἐπὶ τὸ σοφὸν εἶναι ἐν κακοῖς. Cp. supr. 79, 80, ἔξοιδα καὶ φύσει σε μὴ πεφυκότα τοιαῦτα φωνεῖν, μηδὲ τεχνᾶσθαι κακά.
1015. mvp-comment-705-1 προὐδίδαξεν] ‘Has instructed him.' Cp. supr. 538, προϋμαθον, and note.
1016. mvp-comment-706-1 δύστηνε] Cp. Aj. 1290, δύστηνε, ποῖ βλέπων ποτ' αὐτὰ καὶ θροεῖς; συνδήσας agrees with the subject of ἄγειν. The intention here mentioned is spoken of in the more passionate phrase, supr. 979, as a finished act; cp. Aj. 1126, δίκαια γὰρ τόνδ᾽ εὐτυχεῖν κτείναντά με;
1017. mvp-comment-707-1 ἀκτῆς] Supr. 1, 272. προὐβάλου] • You contrived to cast me forth.' The (subjective) middle throws on Odysseus the prime responsibility of the act.
1018. mvp-comment-708-1 ἄπολιν] 'Outcast.' Cp. the Homeric ἀφρήτωρ, ἀθέμιστος, ἀνέστιος. ἐν ζῶσιν νεκρόν] 'Among the living, but not alive.'
1019. mvp-comment-709-1 καί] 'And indeed.' For the stress on καί, cp. Εl. 597 ( ὡς τὴν μητέρα | κακοστομοῦμεν.) καί σ᾽ ἔγωγε δεσπότιν | ἢ μητέρ᾽ οὐκ ἔλασσον εἰς ἡμᾶς νέμω. Philoctetes adds this, not correcting himself, but as feeling painfully the impotence of his curse.
1022. mvp-comment-710-1 τοῦτ᾽ αὐτό is cognate accusative, expressing the cause. The pronoun refers both to ζῶν preceding, and to ὅτι following. Cp. supr. 797, Ant. 463, 4, ὅστις γὰρ ἐν πολλοῖσιν ὡς ἐγὼ κακοῖς | ζῇ, πῶς ὅδ᾽ οὐχὶ κατθανὼν κέρδος φέρει;
1025. mvp-comment-711-1 κλοπῇ τε κἀνάγκῃ ζυγείς] 'Through being kidnapped, and bound under compulsion.' Cp. supr. 73, and note. For the metaphor in ζυγείς, cp. Αj. 24, κἀγὼ ᾿θελοντὴς τῷδ᾽ ὑπεζύγην πόνῳ.
1027. mvp-comment-712-1 ἑπτὰ ναυσί] ΙΙ. 2. 718, τῶν δὲ Φιλοκτήτης ἦρχεν, τόξων εὖ εἰδώς, ἑπτὰ νεῶν.
1028. mvp-comment-713-1 ἄτιμον ἔβαλον] ‘Flung away dishonoured.' For the use of the simple verb = ἐξέβαλον, see E. on L. § 55. p. 101, 4. κεῖνοι δὲ σέ] Sc. ἐκβαλεῖν μέ φασιν. Dindorf wrongly quotes ἔκβαλον as the reading of L.
1029. mvp-comment-714-1 'And now why take me, why force me away?' For the repetition and redundancy, cp. supr. 236. and note. ἀπάγειν is the word for taking a criminal to execution, and the middle voice conveys more of personal feeling. ( Cp. supr. 613.) The agitation of Philoctetes is again marked by two tribrachs following each other. Cp. supr. 932.
1030. mvp-comment-715-1 τέθνηχ᾽ ὑμῖν] Cp. O. C. 1366, ἢ τὰν οὐκ ἂν ἢ τὸ σὸν μέρος. And for the dative, ib. 444, φυγάς σφιν ἔξω πτωχὸς ἠλώμην ἀεί.
1032-1033. mvp-comment-716-1 πῶς θεοῖς εὔξεσθ' . . ἔτι] 'How shall ye declare to Heaven that ye will sacrifice or pour libation to the gods any more?' εὔχεσθαι is properly to say aloud in presence of a god, and so (a) 'To pray,' (b) 'To vow,' (c) 'To glory.' Here the meaning is somewhere between (c) and (b), 'To vaunt' and 'To promise.' Cp. Eur. Alc. 334, where eὔχομαι is, 'I thankfully profess.' θεοῖς is (a) dative after εὔξεσθε, (b) in a secondary construction with the infinitives αἴθειν ἱερά and σπένδειν. 'How shall ye vaunt before the gods that ye will burn sacrifice to them, or make drink-offerings?' There is no ground whatever for suspecting the reading.
1034. mvp-comment-717-1 αὕτη .. ἐμέ] Cp. supr. 8. It may be observed that Philoctetes here knows what he had not suspected at the time described by him, supr. 271. ἐκβαλεῖν] Sc. ὥστε ἐκβαλεῖν. See Essay on L. § 36. p. 62.
1039. mvp-comment-718-1 εἰ μή τι .. ἐμοῦ] 'Were ye not pricked to it by some divine power reminding you of me.' κέντρον is (a) literally, 'The prick of a goad.' (b) metaphorically, 'A sharp thought' ( θεῖον, ‘implanted by a god'); in which sense ἐμοῦ is joined to it as an objective genitive. The religious feeling of these lines is very similar to Oed. Col. 96-105. Philoctetes' hope in the gods, which at supr. 1020 had sunk very low, is revived by the reflection that some Divine Providence must have caused the wish for his return to Troy. But he appeals only in the first instance to the gods of his fatherland, and to the gods of vengeance. The θεοὶ ἐπόψιοι are either (1) the Ερινύες. Cp. Aj. 835, 6, τὰς ἀεί τε παρθένους | ἀεί θ᾽ ὁρώσας πάντα τὰν βροτοῖς πάθη Or (2), as elsewhere, Zeus and Apollo. Cp. Εl. 175, Ζεύς, ὃς ἐφορᾷ πάντα καὶ κρατύνει.
1042. mvp-comment-719-1 κἄμ᾽] καί belongs to the verb. Cp. Ant. 280, παῦσαι, πρὶν ὀργῆς κἀμὲ μεστῶσαι λέγων, and note.
1044. mvp-comment-720-1 τῆς νόσου] Sc. ἐκ. See Essay on L. § 8. p. 11. Cp. Od. 1. 18, πεφυγμένος ἦεν ἀέθλων: Ant. 488, 9, οὐκ ἀλύξετον | μόρου κακίστου. For the relief afforded by vengeance, cp. Εl. 939, τῆς νῦν παρούσης πημονῆς λύσεις βάρος: ib. 1489, 90, ὡς ἐμοὶ τύδ᾽ ἂν κακῶν | μόνον γένοιτο τῶν πάλαι λυτήριον.
1045. mvp-comment-721-1 Cp. Ant. 471, 2, δηλοῖ τὸ γέννημ' ὠμὸν ἐξ ὠμοῦ πατρὸς | τῆς παιδός· εἴκειν δ᾽ οὐκ ἐπίσταται κακοῖς. For the hypallage in φάτιν.. ὑπείκουσαν, cp. O. C. 977, πῶς *δἂν τὸ γ' ἶκον πρᾶγμ᾽ ἂν εἰκότως ψέγοις;
1048. mvp-comment-722-1 εἴ μοι παρείκοι] Sc. τὸ πρᾶγμα ὥστε πολλὰ λέγειν. 'Did but my leisure serve me.' νῦν δ᾽ ἑνὸς κρατῶ λόγου] 'But, as it is, I have only one thing to say.' This refers to infr. 1054 foll. 'All I can now say is that we need not take him, if he will not come. The bow is enough.' Odysseus means that this is not the time for justifying his act. He will do and say only what is necessary for his end. When the plea of justice is required, arguments will not fail him. κρατῶ has been suspected. The nearest parallel to it is O. T. 409, τοῦδε γὰρ κἀγὼ κρατῶ.
1049. mvp-comment-723-1 τοιούτων .. τοιοῦτος have here a general meaning, and τοιούτων may be either (1) neuter, or (2) masculine. (1) 'Where this or that line of conduct is required, I follow that course;' or (2) 'Where this or that character is needed, I am of that character.' Cp. Plato, Rep. 4.429 B, 437 E, Phaedr. 271 D; Eur. Or. 1680 ( ΜΕ. πείθεσθαι χρεών.) ΟΡ. κἀγὼ τοιοῦτος (sc. τῇ γνώμῃ εἰμὶ ὥστε πείθεσθαι). Others suppose a vague reference to the accusation of injustice in Philoctetes' speech.
1050-1051. mvp-comment-724-1 Cp. supr. 83-5.