Polybius Histories 3

Evelyn S. Shuckburgh (Translator)

Histories. Polybius. Evelyn S. Shuckburgh (Translator). London. 1889.

Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.

Funding provided by Robert B. Strassler.

Current edition Perseus

The Histories (English) (Polybius. Vols. 1-2. Shuckburgh, Evelyn S., translator. London, New York, NY: Macmillan and Co., 1889.)

Editions (1)
Ἱστορίαι Perseus (Polybius. Vols. 1-4. Büttner-Wobst, Theodor, editor. Leipzig: Teubner, 1893.) — 3.1 focus

Notes on the current edition

Histories

1. A summary of the work from B. C. 220 to B. C. 168.
2. B. C. 220- 216.
3. 1. The cause and course of the Hannibalian war.
4. 2. Macedonian treaty with Carthage , B. C. 216.
5. 3. Syrian war, B. C. 218.
6. 4. Byzantine war. B. C. 220.
7. First digression on the Roman Constitution.
8. Second on Hiero of Syracuse .
9. 5. The attempted partition of the dominions of Ptolemy Epiphanes, B. C. 204.
10. 6. War with Philip, B. C. 201-197.
11. 7. Asiatic war, B. C. 192-191.
12. 8. Gallic wars of Eumenes and Prusias.
13. 9. Union of the Peloponnese . Antiochus Epiphanes in Egypt . Fall of the Macedonian monarchy, B. C. 188- 168.
14. The plan extended to embrace the period from B. C. 168-146.
15. A new departure the breaking-up of the arrangement made after the fall of Macedonia . Wars of Carthage against Massinissa; and of Rome against the Celtiberians, B. C. 155-150; and against Carthage (3d Punic war, B. C. 149-146).
16. The origin of the 2d Punic war;
17. B. C. 334.
18. B. C. 192,
19. B. C. 401-400,
20. B. C. 396-394
21. and of the war with Antiochus.
22. The Hannibalian or Second Punic war. First cause.
23. B.C. 238. Bk. i. ch. 88 . Second cause.
24. Third cause.
25. B. C. 195
26. B. C. 238.
27. Death of Hamilcar, B. C. 229.
28. Death of Hasdrubal, B. C. 221.
29. B. C. 220 Hannibal attacks the Vaccaei.
30. Saguntum appeals to Rome . Winter of B. C. 220- 219.
31. Hannibal’s defiance.
32. Illyrian war, B. C. 219.
33. B. C. 219. Coss. M. Livius Salinator L. Aemilius Paullus.
34. Hannibal besieges Saguntum .
35. Fall of Saguntum .
36. Illyrian war, B. C. 219.
37. Capture of Pharos.
38. Indignation at Rome at the fall of Saguntum .
39. Of Chaereas nothing seems known; a few fragments of an historian of his name are given in Müller, vol. iii. Of Sosilus, Diodorus (26, fr. 6) says that he was of Ilium and wrote a history of Hannibal in seven books. Nepos ( Hann. 13 ) calls him a Lacedaemonian, and says that he lived in Hannibal’s camp and taught him Greek.
40. Envoys sent to Carthage to demand surrender of Hannibal.
41. The first treaty, B. C. 509-508.
42. i.e. in Latium .
43. Second treaty. B. C. 306 (?).
44. ἐπιλάβηται injecerit manum, the legal form of claiming a slave.
45. Third treaty, B.C. 279.
46. Misstatement of Philinus.
47. Fourth treaty, B. C. 241.
48. Fifth treaty, B. C. 238.
49. Sixth treaty, B. C. 228.
50. No excuse for the Roman claim on Sardinia .
51. 1, 83.
52. The Roman case.
53. Mutual provocation.
54. Saguntum of course is south of the Iber, but the attack on it by Hannibal was a breach of the former of the two treaties. Livy ( 21, 2 ) seems to assert that it was specially exempted from attack in the treaty with Hasdrubal.
55. Answer of Fabius. See Livy, 21, 18 .
56. From ch. 21 .
57. βασιλεύς. The two Suffetes represented the original Kings of Carthage (6, 51). The title apparently remained for sacrificial purposes, like the ἄρχων βασιλεύς, and the rex sacrificulus. Polybius, like other Greek writers, calls them βασιλεῖς. Infra, 42. Herod. 7, 165 . Aristot. Pol. 2, 8 .
58. Winter of 219- 218 B. C. Hannibal’s arrangements for the coming campaign.
59. The inscription recording these facts.
60. A promontory in Bruttium , Capo delle Colonne.
61. B.C. 218. Hannibal breaks up his winter quarters and starts for Italy .
62. General view of the geography of the world.
63. This division of the world into three parts was an advance upon the ancient geographers, who divided it into two, combining Egypt with Asia , and Africa with Europe . See Sall. Jug. 17 ; Lucan, Phars. 9, 411 ; Varro de L. L. 5, § 31 . And note on 12, 25 .
64. The extreme north and south unknown.
65. The length of the march from Carthagena to the Po, 1125 Roman miles.
66. The arae Philaenorum were apparently set up as boundary stones to mark the territory of the Pentapolis or Cyrene from Egypt : and the place retained the name long after the disappearance of the altars ( Strabo, 3.5.5-6 ).
67. For Polybius’s calculation as to the length of the stade, see note on 34, 12.
68. Coss. P. Cornelius Scipio and Tib. Sempronius Longus. B. C. 218. The Consuls are sent, one to Spain , and the other to Africa .
69. Placentia and Cremona .
70. Outrage by Boii and Insubres.
71. Livy, 21, 25 , calls it Tannetum, and describes it only as vicus Pado propinquus. It was a few miles from Parma .
72. Tiberius Sempronius prepares to attack Carthage .
73. Publius Scipio lands near Marseilles .
74.
Pluribus enim divisus amnis in mare decurrit
(Livy, 21, 26)
.
75. Hannibal reaches the Rhone .
76. See on ch. 33 , note 2.
77. A detachment crosses higher up the river.
78. The crossing begun.
79. The crossing completed.
80. Message from friendly Gauls.
81. The passage of the elephants.
82. This statement has done much to ruin Polybius’s credit as a geographer. It indicates indeed a strangely defective conception of distance; as his idea, of the Rhone flowing always west, does of the general lie of the country.
83. Scipio finds that Hannibal has escaped him.
84. Hannibal’s march to the foot of the Alps .
85. The ascent.
86. I have no intention of rediscussing the famous question of the pass by which Hannibal crossed the Alps . The reader will find an admirably clear statement of the various views entertained, and the latest arguments advanced in favour of each, in the notes to Mr. W. T. Arnold’s edition of Dr. Arnold’s History of the Second Punic War, pp. 362-373.
87. The Gauls harass the army.
88. Severe losses.
89. περί τι λευκόπετρον, which, however, perhaps only means bare rock, cf. 10, 30 . But see Law’s Alps of Hannibal, vol. i. p. 201 sq.
90. Arrives at the summit.
91. 9th November.
92. The descent.
93. A break in the road.
94. Digression on the limits of history.
95. Rest and recovery.
96. Taking of Turin .
97. Tiberius Sempronius recalled.
98. Excitement at Rome
99. Hannibal’s speech.
100. Skirmish of cavalry near the Ticinus , Nov. B. C. 219.
101. Scipio retires to Placentia on the right bank of the Po.
102. His life, according to one story, was saved by his son, the famous Scipio Africanus ( 10, 3 ); according to another, by a Ligurian slave ( Livy, 21, 46 ).
103. Hannibal crosses the Po higher up and follows Scipio to Placentia .
104. Livy says to Mago, Hannibal’s younger brother ( 21, 47 ). This Hasdrubal is called in ch. 93 captain of pioneers.
105. Treachery of the Gauls serving in the army of Scipio.
106. Scipio changes his position at Placentia to one on the Trebia.
107. Hannibal follows him.
108. Scipio’s position on the slopes of Apennines , near the source of the Trebia.
109. Tiberius Sempronius joins Scipio.
110. Fall of Clastidium . Hannibal’s policy towards the Italians.
111. A skirmish favourable to the Romans.
112. Sempronius resolves to give battle.
113. Hannibal prepares an ambuscade.
114. Battle of the Trebia, December B.C. 218.
115. Hannibal’s forces.
116. The Roman forces.
117. That is, four legions and their regular contingent of socii. See 6, 19 sqq.
118. The Roman cavalry retreat.
119. Both Roman wings defeated.
120. fights its way to Placentia .
121. Winter of B.C. 218- 217. Great exertions at Rome to meet the danger.
122. B. C. 217.
123. Hannibal conciliates the Italians.
124. He crossed the Apennines , not by the ordinary road to Lucca , descending the valley of the Macra, but, as it appears, by a straighter line down the valley of the Auser or Serchio .—ARNOLD.
125. Hannibal starts for Etruria. Spring of B. C. 217.
126. The marshes between the Arno and the Apennines south of Florence .
127. ἀπεκοιμῶντο Schw. translates simply dormiebant. But the compound means more than that; it conveys the idea of an interval of sleep snatched from other employments. See Herod. 8, 76 ; Aristoph. Vesp. 211 .
128. Hannibal in the valley of the Arno .
129. Hannibal correctly judges the character of Flaminius.
130. Flaminius is drawn out of camp.
131. The ambuscade at Lake Thrasymene.
132. Livy, 22, 4-6 . For a discussion of the modern views as to the scene of the battle, see W. T. Arnold’s edition of Dr. Arnold’s History of the Second Punic War, pp. 384-393. The radical difference between the account of Livy and that of Polybius seems to be that the former conceives the fighting to have been on the north shore of the lake between Tucro and Passignano ; Polybius conceives the rear to have been caught in the defile of Passignano , the main fighting to have been more to the east, where the road turns up at right angles to the lake by La Torricella. Mr. Capes, however, in his note on the passage of Livy, seems to think that both accounts agree in representing the fighting on the vanguard as being opposite Tucro.
133. The battle, 22d June.
134. Hannibal’s treatment of prisoners.
135. Dismay at Rome .
136. Servilius’s advanced guard cut to pieces.
137. Hannibal’s advance after the battle.
138. This treatment of non-combatants was contrary to the usages of civilised warfare even in those days, and seems to have been the true ground for the charge of crudelitas always attributed to Hannibal by Roman writers, as opposed to the behaviour of such an enemy as Pyrrhus ( Cic. de Am. 28 ). It may be compared to the order of the Convention to give no quarter to English soldiers, which the French officers nobly refused to execute.
139. Polybius expresses the fact accurately, for, in the absence of a Consul to nominate a Dictator, Fabius was created by a plebiscitum; but the scruples of the lawyers were quieted by his having the title of prodictator only ( Livy, 22, 8 ).
140. Q. Fabius Maximus Dictator.
141. Ramsay ( Roman Antiquities, p. 148) denies this exception, quoting Livy, 6, 16 . But Polybius could hardly have been mistaken on such a point; and there are indications ( Plutarch, Anton. 9 ) that the Tribunes did not occupy the same position as the other magistrates towards the Dictator.
142. The ager Praetutianus was the southern district of Picenum ( Livy, 22, 9 ; 27, 43 ). The chief town was Interamna .
143. Fabius takes the command.
144. On the Appian Way between Equus Tuticus and Herdonia , mod. Troja.
145. Cunctator.
146. Minucius discontented.
147. Hannibal in Samnium and Apulia .
148. Holsten for the Δαύνιοι of the old text; others suggest Calatia.
149. Added by conjecture of Schw. One MS. has δευτέρα ἡ ἀπὸ τοῦ Ἐριβανοῦ.
150. Hannibal descends into the Falernian plain.
151. Near Cales .
152. Fabius lies in wait.
153. Hannibal eludes him.
154. Hannibal gets through the pass. Autumn, B. C. 217.
155. Homer, Odyss. 10, 230 .
156. Fabius goes to Rome , leaving the command to M. Minucius.
157. Spain , B. C. 217.
158. Roman success at sea.
159. Publius Scipio, whose imperium is prolonged after his Consulship of the previous year, with Spain assigned as his province, is sent to join his brother there with 20 ships: early in B.C. 217.
160. Treason of Abilyx.
161. Hannibal takes Geronium.
162. Minucius obtains a slight success. Autumn B. C. 217.
163. Carthaginian foragers cut off.
164. Minucius invested with co-equal powers with Fabius.
165. Hannibal draws on Minucius.
166. Fabius comes to the rescue.
167. B.C. 216. Coss. C. Terentius Varro and L. Aemilius Paulus.
168. Autumn, B. C. 216.
169. The Senate order a battle.
170. See 1. 16 .
171. The Consuls Aemilius Paulus, and Terentius Varro go to the seat of war.
172. Speech of Aemilius.
173. The Roman army approaches Cannae.
174. Terentius Varro orders an advance.
175. The Romans are successful.
176. Hannibal harangues his troops.
177. Hannibal irritates the enemy.
178. Anxiety at Rome .
179. Dispositions for the battle of Cannae .
180. The battle, 2d August, B. C. 216.
181. The Romans outflanked by the cavalry.
182. ἐξ ἀσπίδος ἐπιπαρενέβαλλον. The ordinary word for forming line or taking dressing is παρεμβάλλειν. In the other two passages where ἐπιπαρενβάλλειν is used, ἐπί has a distinct (though different) force. I think here it must mean against, so as to attack. And this seems to be Casaubon’s interpretation.
183. Fall of Aemilius Paulus.
184. There is nothing here absolutely to contradict the picturesque story of the death of Paulus given by Livy ( 22, 49 ), but the words certainly suggest that Polybius had never heard it.
185. Losses of the Romans.
186. The results of the battle. Defection of the allies.
187. Fall of Lucius Postumius in Gaul . See supra, ch. 106 .
188. B.C. 216.