mvp-comment-114-1
Hitherto the Chorus have offered consolation or counsel. At v. 213 they return to that strain. But here, moved by Electra's misery, they join with her in bewailing its cause.
mvp-comment-114-2
οἰκτρὰ μὲν … πλαγά
1
κοίταις
2
οἰκτρὰ … αὐδὰ
3
mvp-comment-114-3
Sophocles, who follows the Homeric story as to the banquet, could not but remember the
οἰκτροτάτην ὄπα
of the dying Cassandra. And this might naturally suggest to him that other
οἰκτρὰ αὐδή
which she had uttered at an earlier moment, immediately after Agamemnon's return,—her presage of his fate, and her own:
Aesch.
Ag. 1072
—1314.
mvp-comment-114-4
The sense then is:—‘There was a voice of lamentation at the return from Troy’; alluding especially to Cassandra's laments, but also, perhaps, to forebodings in the mouth of the people at Mycenae. ‘And there was a voice of lamentation
ἐν κοίταις πατρῴαις
, when thy father lay on the couch at the fatal banquet.’ The ‘voice’ at the banquet is, first, that of the dying Agamemnon; but Sophocles may have thought also of Cassandra's death-cry, which was sounding in the king's ears as he fell.—For other interpretations, see Appendix.
mvp-comment-114-5
νόστοις
4
ἐν
5
mvp-comment-114-6
κοίταις
6
mvp-comment-114-7
ὅτε οἱ
7
σοι
8
ἀνταία
9
mvp-comment-114-8
γενύων
10
mvp-comment-115-1
δόλος … ἔρος
11
mvp-comment-116-1
δεινὰν δεινῶς
12
δεινὰν … μορφάν
13
mvp-comment-116-2
εἴτ’ οὖν … εἴτε
14
βροτῶν
15
mvp-comment-117-1
πλέον … ἐχθίστα
16
mvp-comment-117-2
δὴ
17
mvp-comment-118-1
νὺξ
18
mvp-comment-118-2
δείπνων
19
mvp-comment-119-1
ἄχθη
20
τοῖς
21
θανάτους
22
mvp-comment-119-2
διδύμαιν χειροῖν
23
διδύμοιν
24
mvp-comment-120-1
εἷλον … πρόδοτον
25
mvp-comment-121-1
οἷς
26
mvp-comment-121-2
Ὀλύμπιος
27
mvp-comment-122-1
ποίνιμα
28
mvp-comment-123-1
ἀγλαΐας
29
mvp-comment-123-2
ἀποναίατο
30
mvp-comment-124-1
πόρσω
31
mvp-comment-125-1
γνώμαν ἴσχεις
32
mvp-comment-125-2
ἐξ οἵων
33
mvp-comment-125-3
τὰ παρόντ’
34
mvp-comment-125-4
οἰκείας
35
mvp-comment-126-1
πολύ … τι κακῶν
36
mvp-comment-126-2
ὑπερεκτήσω
37
mvp-comment-127-1
τὰ δὲ
38
οὐκ ἐριστὰ τοῖς δυνατοῖς
39
πλάθειν
40
mvp-comment-127-2
ἐριστά
41
mvp-comment-127-3
πλάθειν
42
mvp-comment-128-1
δεινοῖς ἠναγκάσθην
43
mvp-comment-129-1
ὀργά
44
ἔξοιδ’
45
mvp-comment-130-1
ἀλλὰ … γὰρ
46
mvp-comment-130-2
ἐν … δεινοῖς
47
mvp-comment-130-3
σχήσω
48
mvp-comment-130-4
ταύτας ἄτας
49
mvp-comment-131-1
ὄφρα
50
mvp-comment-131-2
βίος ἔχῃ με
51
σχήσω
52
mvp-comment-132-1
τίνι γάρ … τίνι φρονοῦντι καίρια
53
ἀκούσαιμ’ ἂν πρόσφορον ἔπος
54
τίνι
55
πρόσφορον
56
mvp-comment-132-2
Other explanations are:—(1) Taking the dative with
πρόσφορον
:—‘To what person who feels aright would that word be suitable which I should hear (=which would be said of me)?’ That is: Should I not deserve to incur a censure from which every right-minded person would shrink? Should I not deserve to be called
δυσσεβής
? This seems forced; and it does not well suit
ἔπος
. (2) Taking the dative with
ἀκούσαιμι
:—‘At whose mouth (=
from whom), that thinks aright, could I hear a suitable word of comfort?’ But such a dative seems impossible. In
Il. 16. 515
δύνασαι δὲ σὺ πάντοσ’ ἀκούειν
|
ἀνέρι κηδομένῳ
, the dat. is one of interest, denoting the person whose prayer is heard (‘
for him’); cp.
Il. 5. 115
κλῦθί μοι
: 24. 335
ἔκλυες ᾧ κ’ ἐθέλῃσθα
.
mvp-comment-133-1
ἄνετε
57
mvp-comment-133-2
ἄλυτα
58
mvp-comment-133-3
κεκλήσεται
59
mvp-comment-133-4
231 f. For
ἐκ
60
mvp-comment-133-5
ἀνάριθμος
61
θρήνων
62
mvp-comment-134-1
ἀλλ’ οὖν
63
γε
64
εὐνοίᾳ
65
mvp-comment-135-1
μάτηρ ὡσεί τις
66
mvp-comment-136-1
μὴ τίκτειν
67
mvp-comment-136-2
ἄταν ἄταις
68
mvp-comment-137-1
καὶ τί μέτρον
69
κακότατος
70
mvp-comment-137-2
φέρε
71
mvp-comment-137-3
ἐπὶ τοῖς φθ.
72
mvp-comment-138-1
ἔβλαστ’
73
mvp-comment-139-1
τούτοις
74
mvp-comment-140-1
εἴ τῳ πρόσκειμαι χρηστῷ
75
mvp-comment-141-1
ξυνναίοιμ’
76
mvp-comment-141-2
εὔκηλος
77
mvp-comment-141-3
γονέων
78
ἐκτίμους
79
mvp-comment-141-4
ἐκτίμους ἵσχουσα
80
mvp-comment-141-5
πτέρυγας … γόων
81
mvp-comment-141-6
ὀξυτόνων
82
mvp-comment-142-1
εἰ γὰρ
83
mvp-comment-142-2
γᾶ
84
mvp-comment-142-3
οὐδὲν
85
ὢν
86
εἰ
87
mvp-comment-142-4
Electra is contrasting her father, whose earthly life has been cut short, with his murderers, who survive. But she believes that his spirit lives in the world below, and will be active in aiding the vengeance (453 ff.).
mvp-comment-142-5
πάλιν
88
mvp-comment-142-6
ἀντιφόνους δίκας
89
mvp-comment-143-1
ἔρροι τ’
90
mvp-comment-143-2
αἰδὼς
91
εὐσέβεια
92
mvp-comment-144-1
ἐγὼ μὲν
93
mvp-comment-144-2
καὶ
94
τὸ σὸν … καὶ τοὐμὸν
95
mvp-comment-145-1
νίκα
96
mvp-comment-145-2
ἅμα
97
mvp-comment-146-1
πολλοῖσι θρήνοις
98
mvp-comment-147-1
ἀλλὰ … γὰρ
99
mvp-comment-148-1
ἥτις εὐγενὴς γυνή
100
mvp-comment-149-1
πατρῷα … πήματα
101
mvp-comment-150-1
κατ’ εὐφρόνην
102
mvp-comment-150-2
θάλλοντα
103
mvp-comment-151-1
ᾗ
104
mvp-comment-151-2
πρῶτα μὲν … εἶτα … ἔπειτα
105
ᾗ
106
mvp-comment-151-3
τὰ μητρὸς
107
mvp-comment-151-4
ἔχθιστα συμβέβηκεν
108
mvp-comment-152-1
κἀκ τῶνδ’ ἄρχομαι
109
mvp-comment-153-1
λαβεῖν … τὸ τητᾶσθαι
110
mvp-comment-154-1
ποίας
111
δοκεῖς
112
mvp-comment-155-1
ἴδω
113
εἰσίδω δ’
114
ἴδω δὲ
115
mvp-comment-155-2
μὲν
116
mvp-comment-156-1
ἐσθήματα
117
mvp-comment-156-2
ἐκείνῳ
118
mvp-comment-156-3
παρεστίους … λοιβάς
119
ἔνθ’ ἐκεῖνον ὤλεσεν
120
mvp-comment-156-4
Acc. to
Homer. Hymn. 29. 4 ff., feasts began and ended with libations to Hestia:
οὐ γὰρ ἄτερ σοῦ
|
εἰλαπίναι θνητοῖσιν, ἵν’ οὐ πρώτῃ πυμάτῃ τε
|
Ἱστίῃ ἀρχόμενος σπένδει μελιηδέα οἶνον
. Soph. fr. 658
<*> πρῷρα λοιβῆς Ἑστία
. Other divinities, including Zeus
σωτήρ
, were similarly honoured; then the paean was sung, and the
πότος
began ( Plat.
Symp.p. 176 A).
mvp-comment-157-1
τούτων
121
mvp-comment-158-1
αὐτοέντην
122
mvp-comment-158-2
Brunck first adopted
αὐτοέντην
123
αὐτοφόντην
124
mvp-comment-158-3
ἡμὶν
125
mvp-comment-159-1
ταλαίνῃ
126
mvp-comment-160-1
ταύτην … τῷδε
127
mvp-comment-161-1
μιάστορι
128
Ἐρινὺν
129
mvp-comment-162-1
ἐγγελῶσα τοῖς ποιουμένοις
130
mvp-comment-163-1
εὑροῦς’
131
τότε
132
mvp-comment-163-2
The conjecture
φρουροῦς’
133
τηροῦς’
134
mvp-comment-164-1
χοροὺς ἵστησι
135
mvp-comment-164-2
μηλοσφαγεῖ … ἱερὰ
136
mvp-comment-164-3
ἔμμην’ ἱερά
137
mvp-comment-164-4
τοῖς σωτηρίοις
138
mvp-comment-164-5
Argive tradition placed Agamemnon's death on the 13th of Gamelion (about the end of January). So said ‘the Argive historians’ (
οἱ Ἀργολικοὶ συγγραφεῖς
),— according to an Argive writer named Deinias, who lived about 225 B.C. (Schol. here: Müller,
Frag. Hist. vol. III. p. 25.) Possibly, then, the idea of Clytaemnestra's hideous festival may have been suggested to the poet by some actual commemoration of the event in Argolis. There was a cult of Agamemnon in various places,—notably in Laconia. (Cp. Roscher's
Lexicon, p. 96.)
mvp-comment-165-1
ἡ δύσμορος
139
κατὰ στέγας
140
mvp-comment-166-1
τέτηκα
141
mvp-comment-166-2
πατρὸς
142
mvp-comment-166-3
The
δαίς
is the feast which, in Homeric fashion (
Il. 1. 467
), would follow the sacrifice (281). Acc. to Eustathius p. 1507. 61 (on
Hom.
Od. 4. 524
ff.),
Ἀγαμεμνόνειος δαὶς
(or
τράπεζα
) was a proverb
ἐπὶ τῶν ἐπ’ ὀλέθρῳ εὐωχουμένων
. The poet may mean that Clytaemnestra called the festival
Ἀγαμεμνόνειος δαίς
, in direct allusion to
δεῖπνα ἄρρητα
(203): and this would give a special point to
ἐγγελῶσα
(277). Cp.
Eur.
Or. 1008
τά τ’ ἐπώνυμα δεῖπνα Θυέστου
. But the words do not necessarily imply more than that she called it
Ἀγαμεμνόνεια
.
mvp-comment-167-1
αὐτὴ πρὸς αὑτήν
143
αὑτήν
144
mvp-comment-167-2
κλαῦσαι
145
mvp-comment-167-3
ἡδονὴν φέρει
146
mvp-comment-168-1
ἡ λόγοισι γενναία
147
mvp-comment-169-1
φωνοῦσα
148
mvp-comment-170-1
δύσθεον
149
mvp-comment-170-2
μίσημα
150
mvp-comment-170-3
σοὶ μόνῃ
151
mvp-comment-170-4
τέθνηκεν
152
mvp-comment-170-5
ἐν πένθει
153
mvp-comment-171-1
ἐκ γόων
154
mvp-comment-171-2
οἱ κάτω θεοί
155
mvp-comment-172-1
τάδ’
156
mvp-comment-172-2
ἥξοντ’ Ὀρέστην
157
mvp-comment-173-1
παραστᾶς’
158
mvp-comment-174-1
ἥτις
159
mvp-comment-174-2
ὑπεξέθου
160
mvp-comment-175-1
ἀλλ’ ἴσθι τοι τείσουσά γ’
161
mvp-comment-176-1
ὑλακτεῖ
162
mvp-comment-176-2
σὺν
163
mvp-comment-176-3
πέλας
164
παρών
165
mvp-comment-176-4
301 The adv.
πάντα
166
mvp-comment-176-5
ἄναλκις
167
mvp-comment-176-6
ἡ πᾶσα βλάβη
168
mvp-comment-177-1
σὺν γυναιξὶ
169
mvp-comment-177-2
τὰς μάχας
170
mvp-comment-178-1
ἐφήξειν
171
mvp-comment-179-1
μέλλων … δρᾶν τι
172
mvp-comment-179-2
τὰς οὔσας τε … καὶ τὰς ἀπούσας
173
mvp-comment-179-3
μου
174
μοι
175
mvp-comment-179-4
διέφθορεν
176
mvp-comment-180-1
σωφρονεῖν
177
εὐσεβεῖν
178
mvp-comment-180-2
ἔν τοι κακοῖς
179
mvp-comment-180-3
πολλή )στ’ ἀνάγκη
180
κἀπιτηδεύειν κακά
181
mvp-comment-180-4
I place only a comma, not a colon, after
πάρεστιν
182
mvp-comment-181-1
ὄντος … βεβῶτος
183
mvp-comment-182-1
ἦ κάρτα
184
mvp-comment-182-2
θυραῖον
185
mvp-comment-182-3
οἰχνεῖν
186
mvp-comment-182-4
ἀγροῖσι
187
mvp-comment-182-5
τυγχάνει
188
mvp-comment-183-1
ἦ κἂν … ἱκοίμην
189
ἦ τ<*>ν
190
ἦ δἂν
191
mvp-comment-183-2
ἐς λόγους τοὺς σοὺς ἱκοίμην
192
mvp-comment-184-1
ὡς νῦν
193
ὥς νυν
194
mvp-comment-184-2
ἱστόρει· τί σοι φίλον
195
τό
196
τά
197
mvp-comment-184-3
With the other punctuation,
ἱστόρει τί σοι φίλον
198
mvp-comment-185-1
καὶ δὴ
199
mvp-comment-185-2
τοῦ κασιγνήτου τί φής
200
mvp-comment-185-3
ἥξοντος
201
ἢ μέλλοντος
202
mvp-comment-186-1
φησίν γε
203
mvp-comment-186-2
ποεῖ
204
mvp-comment-187-1
καὶ μὴν ἔγωγ’
205
γε
206
mvp-comment-187-2
οὐκ ὄκνῳ
207
mvp-comment-188-1
ἀρκεῖν
208
mvp-comment-189-1
ἐπεί
209
mvp-comment-189-2
μακρὰν
210
mvp-comment-189-3
324 Here, as in 316,
νῦν
211
νυν
212
mvp-comment-189-4
δόμων
213
φέρουσαν
214
mvp-comment-190-1
ὅμαιμον
215
mvp-comment-190-2
φύσιν
216
mvp-comment-191-1
Χρυσόθεμιν
217
mvp-comment-192-1
οἷα
218
νομίζεται
219
mvp-comment-193-1
πρὸς θυρῶνος ἐξόδοις
220
φωνεῖς
221
ἐλθοῦσα
222
αὖ
223
mvp-comment-193-2
330 For the absence of caesura, cp.
Ph. 101
n.
mvp-comment-194-1
θυμῷ … χαρίζεσθαι
224
mvp-comment-195-1
καίτοι τοσοῦτόν γ’ οἶδα
225
mvp-comment-195-2
κἀμαυτήν, ὅτι
226
mvp-comment-195-3
333 f. For the repeated
ἄν
227
mvp-comment-195-4
οἶ) αὐτοῖς φρονῶ
228
mvp-comment-196-1
ὑφειμένῃ
229
πλεῖν
230
mvp-comment-196-2
For the image, cp.
Eur.
Med. 524
ἄκροισι λαίφους κρασπέδοις
(with close-reefed sails)
ὑπεκφυγεῖν
|
τὴν σὴν στόμαργον, ὦ γύναι, γλωσσαλγίαν
:
Ar.
Ran. 997
ἀλλ’ ὅπως, ὦ γεννάδα
, |
μὴ πρὸς ὀργὴν ἀντιλέξεις
, |
ἀλλὰ συστείλας, ἄκροισι
|
χρώμενος τοῖς ἱστίοις κ.τ.λ.
: and conversely
Soph.
Ant. 715
ναὸς ὅστις ἐγκρατῆ πόδα
|
τείνας ὑπείκει μηδέν
.
Ovid
Epist. 1. 8. 71
moderatius opta, | Et voti, quaeso, contrahe vela tui.
Shakesp.
Henry VI., pt. iii, act 3 sc. 3. 5
‘Now Margaret | Must strike her sail, and learn awhile to serve | Where kings command.’
mvp-comment-197-1
καὶ μὴ δοκεῖν
231
mvp-comment-198-1
τοιαῦτα δ’ ἄλλα
232
ἀλλὰ
233
ἄλλα
234
mvp-comment-199-1
καίτοι τὸ μὲν δίκαιον
235
mvp-comment-199-2
κρίνεις
236
mvp-comment-199-3
εἰ … με δεῖ
237
mvp-comment-199-4
ἐλευθέραν
238
mvp-comment-199-5
ζῆν
239
mvp-comment-199-6
πάντ’
240
mvp-comment-199-7
ἀκουστέα
241
mvp-comment-200-1
δεινόν γε
242
mvp-comment-201-1
τῆς … τικτούσης
243
mvp-comment-201-2
μέλειν
244
mvp-comment-202-1
τἀμὰ νουθετήματα
245
mvp-comment-202-2
κείνης διδακτά
246
mvp-comment-202-3
ἐκ σαυτῆς
247
mvp-comment-203-1
The text, which has been suspected (cr. n.), is sound; but the train of thought is somewhat obscured by compression.
mvp-comment-203-2
‘You forget your father, and care only for your mother. All your counsels to me come from her. Then (
ἔπειτα
),—that being so,—give up the attempt at a compromise. Make a
choice (
ἑλοῦ γε
). You can be imprudent (
φρονεῖν κακῶς
),—as you say that I am,—and loyal to your dead father. Or you can be prudent (
φρονοῦσα
), and forgetful of him,—as you actually are; you who (
ἥτις
) say, indeed, that you would show your hatred of the murderers if you could; and yet, when I
do resist them, you try to turn me from my purpose. You merely add the shame of cowardice to our woes.’
mvp-comment-203-3
ἔπειθ’
248
mvp-comment-203-4
ἑλοῦ γε
249
mvp-comment-203-5
φρονεῖν κακῶς
250
mvp-comment-203-6
Other explanations are:—(1) ‘Choose to be thought either
lost to right feeling, or, if you have such feeling, then at least
forgetful of your duty.’ (2) ‘Choose to seem either
unintelligent (if you are merely the blind instrument of our rulers); or, if you act with clear understanding (
φρονοῦσα
),—thinking to benefit me,—at least forgetful of your father.’ Both these views assume that the question is merely between two interpretations which might be placed on the present conduct of Chrysothemis. But Electra is putting the dilemma between imprudent loyalty and prudent disloyalty.
mvp-comment-204-1
τῶν φίλων
251
mvp-comment-205-1
ἥτις
252
φρονοῦσα
253
μῖσος
254
mvp-comment-206-1
πάντα
255
mvp-comment-206-2
τιμωρουμένης
256
mvp-comment-207-1
οὔτε … τε
257
mvp-comment-207-2
τήν τε δρῶσαν
258
mvp-comment-208-1
πρὸς κακοῖσι
259
mvp-comment-208-2
δειλίαν ἔχει
260
mvp-comment-209-1
ἐπεὶ
261
mvp-comment-209-2
ἢ μάθ’ ἐξ ἐμοῦ
262
mvp-comment-210-1
ἐπαρκούντως
263
mvp-comment-211-1
προσάπτειν
264
mvp-comment-211-2
εἴ τις ἔστ’ ἐκεῖ χάρις
265
mvp-comment-212-1
ἡμὶν
266
ξύνει
267
mvp-comment-213-1
τὰ σὰ … δῶῤ
268
mvp-comment-213-2
ἐφ’ οἶσι
269
mvp-comment-213-3
χλιδᾷς
270
mvp-comment-214-1
ὑπεικάθοιμι
271
mvp-comment-214-2
πλουσία
272
mvp-comment-214-3
περιρρείτω
273
mvp-comment-215-1
τοὐμὲ μὴ λυπεῖν
274
mvp-comment-215-2
Remark the resemblance to the passage where Antigone—summing up her position—compares the
moral pain of neglecting her duty with those penalties which she contemns:—
κείνοις ἂν ἤλγουν· τοῖσδε δ’ οὐκ ἀλγύνομαι
(
Ant. 468
). There, too, we have a Sophoclean triad of clauses, the third echoing the first,—as
τῆς σῆς δ’ οὐκ ἐρῶ τιμῆς τυχεῖν
here reiterates the sense of
σοὶ δὲ πλουσία... βίος
(n. on
Ant. 465
ff.).
mvp-comment-215-3
One of the scholia recognises the traditional reading, and explains it correctly: —
τοῦτο μόνον ἐμὲ βοσκέτω, τὸ μὴ λυπεῖν ἐμὲ αὐτήν, εἰ
(‘as I should do, if’)
τοῖς φονεῦσι τοῦ πατρὸς πείθεσθαι ἀναγκασθήσομαι
.—The conjectures have been numerous: see Appendix.
mvp-comment-216-1
οὐδ’ ἂν σὺ
275
mvp-comment-217-1
παῖδα
276
mvp-comment-217-2
κεκλῆσθαι
277
mvp-comment-218-1
πλείστοις
278
mvp-comment-219-1
μηδὲν
279
πρὸς ὀργὴν
280
mvp-comment-220-1
ἀμφοῖν
281
τοῖς λόγοις
282
mvp-comment-221-1
τῆσδε … αὕτη
283
πάλιν
284
mvp-comment-222-1
ἐγὼ μὲν
285
mvp-comment-222-2
πως
286
mvp-comment-222-3
μύθων
287
mvp-comment-223-1
οὐδ’
288
κοὐδ’
289
ποτέ
290
mvp-comment-224-1
ἰὸν
291
mvp-comment-224-2
σχήσει
292
mvp-comment-225-1
τὸ δεινὸν
293
mvp-comment-225-2
εἰ γὰρ τῶνδέ μοι
294
εἰ
295
mvp-comment-226-1
γὰρ
296
mvp-comment-226-2
γόων
297
λόγων
298
mvp-comment-227-1
ἐνταῦθα
299
mvp-comment-227-2
ἔνθα μή ποτε … προσόψει
300
mvp-comment-227-3
ζῶσα
301
mvp-comment-227-4
κατηρεφεῖ
302
mvp-comment-227-5
χθονὸς τῆσδ’ ἐκτὸς
303
mvp-comment-227-6
ὑμνήσεις
304
mvp-comment-228-1
πρὸς ταῦτα
305
mvp-comment-228-2
Nauck reads
κοὔ
306
καί
307
mvp-comment-228-3
ἐν καλῷ, εὔκαιρον
schol.:
H. 4. 3. 5
νομίσαντες οὐκ ἐν καλῷ εἶναι πρὸς τοὺς ὁπλίτας ἱππομαχεῖν
: so, too,
Eur.
Heracl. 971
, etc. Cp.
καλόν
(
ἐστι
)=
καίριον
in
Soph.
Ph. 1155
; and
εἰς καλόν
=
καιρίως
in
O.T. 78.
mvp-comment-229-1
ἦ ταῦτα δὴ
308
ἦ … δὴ
309
ἦ … γὰρ
310
mvp-comment-229-2
καὶ βεβούλευνται
311
mvp-comment-230-1
ἀλλ’ ἐξίκοιτο
312
mvp-comment-230-2
τοῦδέ γ’ οὕνεκ’
313
mvp-comment-231-1
τίνα … τόνδ’
314
mvp-comment-231-2
τάλαινα
315
mvp-comment-232-1
εἴ τι τῶνδε
316
mvp-comment-233-1
ποῦ ποτ’ εἶ φρενῶν
317
mvp-comment-234-1
ὅπως
318
ὑμῶν
319
mvp-comment-234-2
προσώτατ’
320
προσωτάτω φύγω
321
mvp-comment-235-1
βίου … τοῦ παρόντος
322
mvp-comment-236-1
καλὸς γὰρ
323
mvp-comment-236-2
θαυμάσαι
324
mvp-comment-237-1
τοῖς φίλοις
325
mvp-comment-238-1
εἰκαθεῖν
326
mvp-comment-239-1
ταῦτα
327
οὐκ ἐμοὺς
328
mvp-comment-240-1
γε
329
μέντοι
330
mvp-comment-240-2
μὴ )ξ
331
mvp-comment-240-3
πεσεῖν
332
mvp-comment-240-4
399 A woman, speaking of herself in the plur., uses the masc.:
Ant. 926
παθόντες ἂν ξυγγνοῖμεν ἡμαρτηκότες
.
mvp-comment-241-1
συγγνώμην
333
mvp-comment-242-1
τἄπη
334
mvp-comment-242-2
πρὸς κακῶν
335
mvp-comment-243-1
μή πω
336
mvp-comment-244-1
οἷπερ … ὁδοῦ
337
mvp-comment-245-1
τῷ φέρεις
338
mvp-comment-245-2
ἔμπυρα
339
mvp-comment-246-1
τυμβεῦσαι χοάς
340
mvp-comment-247-1
βροτῶν
341
mvp-comment-248-1
ὃν ἔκταν’ αὐτή
342
ὅν γ’
343
mvp-comment-249-1
τῷ τοῦτ’ ἤρεσεν
344
mvp-comment-250-1
δείματος
345
mvp-comment-250-2
δοκεῖν ἐμοί
346
mvp-comment-251-1
θεοὶ πατρῷοι
347
mvp-comment-251-2
συγγένεσθέ γ’
348
mvp-comment-251-3
ἀλλὰ νῦν
349
mvp-comment-252-1
εἴποιμ’ ἂν τότε
350
mvp-comment-253-1
ἐπὶ σμικρὸν
351
ἐπὶ σμικρῶν
352
mvp-comment-253-2
φράσαι
353
mvp-comment-254-1
σμικροὶ λόγοι
354
mvp-comment-255-1
πατρὸς … δευτέραν ὁμιλίαν
355
mvp-comment-255-2
ἐφέστιον πῆξαι
356
mvp-comment-255-3
This sceptre is described in the
Iliad (2. 101 f.) as the work of Hephaestus, who gave it Zeus; Hermes transmitted it to Pelops, from whom it passed to Atreus and Agamemnon. The Homeric sceptre is often called
χρύσεον
(
Il. 2. 268
, etc.), prob. as being ornamented with gold foil, or studded with gold nails (
Il. 1. 246
χρυσείοις ἥλοισι πεπαρμένον
). Among the objects found at Mycenae are some supposed remains of such sceptres (Schliem.,
Myc. 201, etc.).
mvp-comment-255-4
οὑφόρει ποτέ
357
mvp-comment-256-1
ἔκ τε
358
ἐκ δὲ
359
mvp-comment-256-2
βρύοντα
360
mvp-comment-256-3
ᾧ … γενέσθαι
361
mvp-comment-256-4
The vision resembles that of Astyages, who dreamed that a vine sprang from his daughter Mandanè, the wife of Cambyses,
τὴν δὲ ἄμπελον ἐπισχεῖν τὴν Ἀσίην πᾶσαν
. The
ὀνειροπόλοι
explained this to mean that her son (Cyrus) should reign in his grandfather's stead. (
Her. 1. 108.
) The spreading branches figure also in the dream of Xerxes (7. 19):
ἐδόκεε...ἐστεφανῶσθαι ἐλαίης θαλλῷ, ἀπὸ δὲ τῆς ἐλαίης τοὺς κλάδους γῆν πᾶσαν ἐπισχεῖν
.
mvp-comment-256-5
In choosing the
sceptre of Agamemnon as the stock from which the wondrous growth is put forth, Sophocles may have had in mind the words of Achilles (
Il. 1. 234
ff.);
ναὶ μὰ τόδε σκῆπτρον· τὸ μὲν οὔποτε φύλλα καὶ ὄζους
|
φύσει, ἐπεὶ δὴ πρῶτα τομὴν ἐν ὄρεσσι λέλοιπεν
, |
οὐδ’ ἀναθηλήσει
.
mvp-comment-257-1
του παρόντος
362
τοῦ
363
παρόντος
364
του
365
mvp-comment-257-2
Ἡλίῳ δείκνυσι τοὖναρ
366
mvp-comment-258-1
οὐ κάτοιδα, πλὴν
367
mvp-comment-258-2
πέμπει με κείνη
368
mvp-comment-259-1
These three verses, which the MSS. give to Electra, and which several recent critics reject (cr. n.), clearly belong to Chrysothemis, and are genuine. Electra's exclamation of joy (411) caused Chrysothemis to ask if her sister had any ground for hope (412). Electra replied that, when she had heard the dream, she would say. This showed her sister that Electra relied merely on the fact that Clytaemnestra had seen
some fearful vision. Now, therefore, instead of asking for Electra's interpretation, she merely repeats her counsel (383 f.) before proceeding on her errand. The words
πρός
νυν θεῶν κ.τ.λ.
(428 ff.) show the train of her thought. To Chrysothemis, the alarm of Clytaemnestra (427) is more important than the apparition of Agamemnon. The dream is only a new reason why Electra should be cautious,—not why she should hope.
mvp-comment-259-2
The current ascription of the verses to Electra was doubtless prompted by verse 413. It was supposed that the recital of Chrysothemis must be immediately followed by the comments of Electra. But, as Hermann observed, the phrase
ἀβουλίᾳ πεσεῖν
would alone suffice to show that the verses belong to Chrysothemis (
cp. 398
). Nor could the warning,
σὺν κακῷ μέτει πάλιν
, be fitly uttered by Electra.
mvp-comment-259-3
τῶν ἐγγενῶν
369
mvp-comment-260-1
ἀβουλίᾳ
370
mvp-comment-260-2
σὺν κακῷ
371
mvp-comment-260-3
μέτει
372
mvp-comment-261-1
ἀλλ’
373
mvp-comment-261-2
ὦ φίλη
374
τούτων μὲν
375
mvp-comment-262-1
οὐ … θέμις
376
οὐδ’ ὅσιον
377
mvp-comment-262-2
ἐχθρᾶς ἀπὸ γυναικὸς
378
mvp-comment-262-3
κτερίσματ’
379
mvp-comment-262-4
λουτρὰ
380
mvp-comment-263-1
ἀλλ’ ἢ πνοαῖσιν
381
ῥοαῖσιν
382
mvp-comment-263-2
κρύψον
383
mvp-comment-263-3
νιν
384
mvp-comment-263-4
ἔνθα μή ποτ’
385
ἔνθεν
386
mvp-comment-263-5
εὐνὴν
387
mvp-comment-264-1
ἀλλ’ ὅταν θάῃν
388
mvp-comment-264-2
The conjecture
ἔστ’ ἂν
389
ὅταν
390
σῳζέσθω
391
mvp-comment-264-3
κειμήλἰ
392
mvp-comment-265-1
ἀρχὴν
393
τλημονεστάτη
394
mvp-comment-266-1
ἔβλαστε
395
mvp-comment-267-1
ὅν γ’ … τῷδ’
396
mvp-comment-267-2
ἐπέστεφε
397
mvp-comment-267-3
442 f. The position of
αὐτῇ
398
mvp-comment-267-4
δέξεσθαι
399
mvp-comment-267-5
It seems, then, a reasonable inference that here, where the reference is to future time, he would have written
δέξεσθαι
400
δέξασθαι
401
mvp-comment-267-6
444 ff. Join
θανὼν ἄτιμος
402
mvp-comment-267-7
ἐμασχαλίσθη
403
mvp-comment-267-8
Two different motives are assigned by the Greek commentators; viz.:—(1) the desire to render the dead incapable of wreaking vengeance (
ὥσπερ τὴν δύναμιν ἐκείνων ἀφαιρούμενοι
): (2) the desire to make an atonement (
ἐξιλάσασθαι τὴν δολοφονίαν—ἀφοσιοῦσθαι τὸν φόνον
). There can be little doubt that the first of these motives was the primitive origin of the custom. If the second was afterwards blended with it, the idea may have been that of offering the severed portions to the gods below,—as a victim was devoted to death by cutting off a lock of hair (
Eur.
Alc. 75
). Apollonius Rhodius seems to present the practice in this light (4. 477): Jason, having slain a foe,
ἐξάργματα τάμνε θανόντος
. Cp.
Etym. Magn.:
ἀπάργματα λέγεται τὰ ὑπὸ τῶν τραγῳδῶν λεγόμενα μασχαλίσματα
.
mvp-comment-267-9
κἀπὶ λουτροῖσιν
404
mvp-comment-267-10
ἐξέμαξ ν
405
mvp-comment-267-11
ἆρα μὴ
406
mvp-comment-268-1
οὐκ ἔστιν
407
mvp-comment-268-2
ταῦτα μὲν μέθες· σὺ δὲ
408
mvp-comment-269-1
βοστρύχων ἄκρας φόβας
409
mvp-comment-269-2
κἀμοῦ ταλαίνης
410
mvp-comment-270-1
†ἀλιπαρῆ
411
λιπαρῆ
412
mvp-comment-270-2
We come, therefore, to a dilemma. (1) The words
τήνδ’ ἀλιπαρῆ τρίχα
may conceal some corruption:
τήνδ’
ought possibly to be
τήνδε τ’
413
ἀλίπαρον
414
mvp-comment-270-3
(2) Or else, if the text be sound,
ἀλιπαρῆ
may mean
οὐ λιπαράν
. There is no doubt that
λιπ
, ‘fat,’ is the root both of
λι^παρός
, ‘shining,’ and of
λι—παρής
, ‘sticking’; cp.
Plat.
Crat. 427 B
τὸ λιπαρὸν καὶ τὸ κολλῶδες
(
Curt.
Etym. § 340
). Similarly
γλίσχρος
, ‘sticky,’ came to mean ‘importunate.’ It is barely possible that, in coining a new negative compound, the poet may have transferred the sense of
λιπαρός
to
λιπαρής
: but it seems improbable.
mvp-comment-271-1
ζῶμα
415
mvp-comment-271-2
χλιδαῖς
416
mvp-comment-272-1
προσπίτνουσα
417
αὐτὸν
418
mvp-comment-273-1
ἐξ ὑπερτέρας χερός
419
mvp-comment-273-2
ζῶντ’
420
mvp-comment-274-1
ἀφνεωτέραις
421
mvp-comment-274-2
στέφωμεν
422
mvp-comment-274-3
δωρούμεθα
423
mvp-comment-275-1
οἶμαι μὲν οὖν
424
mvp-comment-275-2
If
μέλον
425
μέλειν
426
μέλον
427
mvp-comment-276-1
σοί
428
mvp-comment-277-1
βροτῶν
429
mvp-comment-278-1
πρὸς εὐσέβειαν
430
mvp-comment-279-1
δράσω
431
mvp-comment-279-2
τὸ γὰρ δίκαιον
432
mvp-comment-279-3
(1)
τὸ δίκαιον
is an acc. of general reference, and
οὐκ ἔχει λόγον
is impersonal. ‘With regard to what is (clearly) right, it is unreasonable for two persons to dispute; rather both should hasten on the doing (of it).’ With
ἀλλ’ ἐπισπεύδειν
we supply the notion
δεῖ
from the negative
οὐκ ἔχει λόγον
(as from
οὐκ ἔξεστι
in
O. C. 1402
ff.; cp.
O. T. 817
ff.). For the form of the sentence, cp.
H. 7. 3. 7
τοὺς περὶ Ἀρχίαν...οὐ ψῆφον ἀνεμείνατε, ἀλλὰ ὁπότε πρῶτον ἐδυνάσθητε ἐτιμωρήσασθε
. So here the acc.
τὸ δίκαιον
, which represents the object of
δρᾶν
, is separated from it by the parenthesis
οὐκ
ἔχει λόγον δυοῖν ἐρίζειν
. (The first scholium gives substantially this view:
οὐκ ἔχει λόγον φιλονεικεῖν περὶ τοῦ δικαίου, ὥστε περὶ αὐτοῦ δύο ὄντας ἐρίζειν
.)
mvp-comment-279-4
(2) Or
τὸ δίκαιον
might be nom.: ‘that which is clearly right does not
afford any ground (
οὐκ ἔχει λόγον
) for two persons to dispute,’ etc. So the second schol.:
ἢ τὸ οὐκ ἔχει λόγον ἀντὶ τοῦ οὐ παρέχει πρόφασιν
. So far as the verb
ἔχει
is concerned, this sense is quite admissible: cp.
Thuc. 2. 41
οὔτε τῷ πολεμίῳ ἐπελθόντι ἀγανάκτησιν ἔχει
(
ἡ πόλις
). The objection is that the phrases
ἔχειν λόγον, οὐκ ἔχειν λόγον
, which are very common, regularly mean, ‘to be reasonable,’ ‘to be unreasonable.’ This is so both in the personal and in the impersonal constr.; as Plat.
Phaedop. 62 D
τὸ γὰρ μὴ ἀγανακτεῖν...οὐκ ἔχει λόγον
:
Dem. or. 36 § 54
πῶς ἔχει λόγον σὲ...δίκην ἀξιοῦν λαμβάνειν
; The supposed sense, ‘not to
afford a reason,’ is unexampled.
mvp-comment-279-5
δυοῖν
433
mvp-comment-280-1
παρ’ ὑμῶν
434
mvp-comment-281-1
πικρὰν
435
δοκῶ με … τολμήσειν
436
ἔτι
437
mvp-comment-282-1
εἰ μὴ )γὼ
438
mvp-comment-282-2
γνώμας λειπομένα
439
mvp-comment-283-1
ἁ πρόμαντις Δίκα
440
mvp-comment-283-2
δίκαια φερομένα χεροῖν κράτη
441
mvp-comment-284-1
μέτεισιν
442
mvp-comment-284-2
οὐ μακροῦ χρόνου
443
mvp-comment-285-1
ὕπεστί μοι θράσος
444
κλύουσαν
445
mvp-comment-285-2
ἁδυπνόων … ὀνειράτων
446
mvp-comment-286-1
ἀμναστεῖ γ’ ὁ φύσας ς’
447
mvp-comment-287-1
χαλκόπλακτος
448
mvp-comment-287-2
γένυς
449
mvp-comment-287-3
The very axe (
φόνιος πέλεκυς
, 99) with which the blow was dealt is imagined as nourishing a grudge against the murderers who had set it such a task. Such a personification recalls that practice of Athenian law by which inanimate objects which had caused death were brought to a formal trial in the court called
τὸ ἐπὶ Πρυτανείῳ
, and, after sentence, cast beyond the boundaries, in the presence of the Archon Basileus and the sacrificial officers of the tribes (
φυλο‐
βασιλεῖς
). Aeschin. or. 3 § 244
τὰ μὲν ξύλα καὶ τοὺς λίθους καὶ τὸν σίδηρον, τὰ ἄφωνα καὶ ἀγνώμονα, ἐάν τῳ ἐμπεσόντα ἀποκτείνῃ, ὑπερορίζομεν
. (Cp.
Dem. or. 23 § 76
.) A like conception was implied in the English law (repealed in 1846) of ‘deodands’ (Deo danda),
i.e., personal chattels (whether animals or things) which, having caused the death of a human being, were forfeited to the Crown for pious uses.
mvp-comment-288-1
ἐν αἰκίαις
450
mvp-comment-289-1
καὶ πολύπους καὶ πολύχειρ
451
mvp-comment-290-1
λόχοις
452
mvp-comment-290-2
χαλκόπους
453
mvp-comment-291-1
ἄλεκτρ’ ἄνυμφα
454
mvp-comment-291-2
γάμων ἁμιλλήμαθ’
455
mvp-comment-291-3
ἐπέβα
456
mvp-comment-292-1
πρὸ τῶνδέ τοι … συνδρῶσιν
457
mvp-comment-292-2
Verses 495—497 (
πρὸ τῶνδέ τοι...τέρας
) answer metrically to vv. 479—481
ὕπεστί μοι...ὀνειράτων
, where the text is certain, save for the doubt whether
θράσος
or
θάρσος
should stand in 479. Here we must first decide two points.
mvp-comment-292-3
(1) Are the words
πρὸ τῶνδε
458
mvp-comment-292-4
(2) Could
ἔχει με, μήποτε τέρας πελᾶν
(etc.) mean, ‘
the belief possesses me, that’ etc.? Surely not. No real parallel for so strange a phrase has been produced. It is irrelevant to quote those impersonal verbs which directly express the
occurrence of a thought to the mind; as
Xen.
An. 6. 1. 17
εἰσῄει αὐτοὺς ὅπως ἂν καὶ ἔχοντές τι οἴκαδε ἀφίκοιντο
(‘the thought came to them, how they might,’ etc.):
Thuc. 6. 78.
§ 1
εἰ δέ τῳ ἄρα παρέστηκε, τὸν μὲν Συρακόσιον...πολέμιον εἶναι κ.τ.λ.
Either, then, the subject to
ἔχει
has dropped out, or the words
μ’ ἔχει
conceal a corruption.
mvp-comment-292-5
The following remedies are possible: I incline to the first, as involving least change. (1) Reading in 479
ὕπεστί μοι θράσος
, we may read here
πρὸ τῶνδέ τοί μ’ ἔχει
|
<θάρσος τι>, μήποθ’ ἡμῖν
etc. (It may be remarked that
τι
is in harmony with the tone of
ὕπεστί μοι
in 479.) Another available word is
ξύννοια
(cp.
Ant. 279
). (2) Or, reading in 479
ὕπεστί μοι θάρσος
, we could read here
πρὸ τῶνδέ τοι θάρσος ἴσχει με
. On either view, the
υ
of
ἁδυπνόων
in 480 is long (as several critics have assumed). It should be noted that (1) involves a different constitution of the verses: see p. lxxxii.
mvp-comment-292-6
In those MSS. which have
μή ποτε μή ποθ’ ἡμῖν
459
mvp-comment-293-1
ἀψεγές
460
ἀψεφές
461
mvp-comment-293-2
πελᾶν
462
mvp-comment-294-1
τοῖς δρῶσι
463
τοῖς συνδρῶσιν
464
mvp-comment-295-1
μαντεῖαι βροτῶν
465
mvp-comment-296-1
εὖ κατασχήσει
466
mvp-comment-297-1
ἱππεία
467
mvp-comment-297-2
Oenomaüs, king of Pisa in Elis, had promised the hand of his daughter Hippodameia to the suitor who should defeat him in a chariot-race; the penalty of failure being death. The young Pelops, son of Tantalus, offered himself as a competitor. Myrtilus, the charioteer of Oenomaüs, was persuaded (either by Hippodameia or by Pelops) to betray his master. He did so by leaving out one or both of the linch-pins by which the naves of the chariot-wheels were secured to the axles.
Tzetzes on Lycophron 156
ταῖς χοινίκισι
(=
πλήμναις
, the naves)
τῶν τροχῶν οὐκ ἐμβαλὼν τοὺς ἥλους
. According to another story, he substituted a linch-pin of wax for a real one (
schol. Apoll. Rh. 752
ἐμβαλόντα κήρινον ἔμβολον ἐπὶ τοῦ ἀκραξονίου
). So Pelops won the race, and the bride. But Oenomaüs was soon avenged on the traitor; for Myrtilus insulted Hippodameia, and was thrown into the sea by Pelops; upon whose house he invoked a curse, as he sank.
mvp-comment-297-3
Euripides, too, (
Or. 990
ff.,
Helen. 386 f.) refers to this chariot-race as the event with which the troubles of the Pelopidae began. Apollonius Rhodius briefly describes the critical moment of the race as one of the subjects embroidered on the cloak of Jason (1. 752 ff.); there Oenomaüs was seen, ‘falling sideways, as the axle broke at the naves of the wheels,’—
ἄξονος ἐν πλήμνῃσι παρακλιδὸν ἀγνυμένοιο
|
πίπτεν
.
mvp-comment-297-4
The eastern pediment of the temple of Zeus at Olympia (
circ. 450 B.C.) was adorned with sculptures by Paeonius, representing the preparation for this contest (
Paus. 5. 10. 6
). The fragments found on the site have sufficed for a reconstruction of the group. Zeus occupied the centre; to the right of him were Pelops and Hippodameia; to the left, Oenomaüs and his wife Steropè. On each side was a chariot drawn by four horses. Myrtilus was sitting in front of his team, with his face turned away from his master.
mvp-comment-297-5
In the older and nobler form of the myth, Pelops won, not by a fraud, but by the grace of Poseidon, who gave him winged horses (Pindar
O. 1. 87
ἔδωκεν δίφρον τε χούσεον πτεροῖσίν τ’ ἀκάμαντας ἵππους
). On the chest (
λάρναξ
) of Cypselus, seen by Pausanias in the Heraeum at Olympia (
Paus. 5. 17. 5
), Pelops was driving two winged horses.
mvp-comment-298-1
αἰανὴς
468
mvp-comment-298-2
The form
αἰανὴς
has the best authority, and some critics hold that
αἰανὸς
(Hesych.) was a Byzantine invention. But in
Aesch.
Eum. 416
,
ἡμεῖς γάρ ἐσμεν νυκτὸς αἰανῆς τέκνα
(so L, schol., and Tzetzes on Lycophron 406),
αἰανῆ
is far less suitable.
mvp-comment-299-1
εὖτε
469
mvp-comment-299-2
ὁ ποντισθεὶς Μυρτίλος
470
mvp-comment-299-3
A vase found at Capua shows Pelops and Hippodameia in a ship, from which Myrtilus is falling backwards into the water. A winged Erinys hovers in the air above, brandishing a sword over the head of Pelops (Baumeister,
Denkmäler p. 1204, referring to
Mon. Inst. x. 25).
mvp-comment-299-4
ἐκοιμάθη
471
mvp-comment-300-1
παγχρυσέων δίφρων
472
mvp-comment-301-1
πρόρριζος
473
mvp-comment-301-2
ἐκριφθείς
474
mvp-comment-302-1
ἔλειπεν
475
ἔλιπεν
476
οἴκου
477
οἴκους
478
πω
479
mvp-comment-303-1
πολύπονος
480
αἰκία
481
mvp-comment-304-1
ἀνειμένη
482
μέν
483
mvp-comment-304-2
ὡς ἔοικας
484
mvp-comment-304-3
στρέφει
485
mvp-comment-304-4
Clytaemnestra begins in the same strain as Chrysothemis, who likewise emphasised her reproof by the word
αὖ
486
mvp-comment-305-1
μή τοι θυραίαν γ’
487
mvp-comment-305-2
αἰσχύνειν φίλους
488
mvp-comment-306-1
καίτοι
489
mvp-comment-306-2
δὴ
490
πολλούς
491
mvp-comment-306-3
ἐξεῖπάς με … ὡς
492
mvp-comment-306-4
θρασεῖα
493
τραχεῖα
494
mvp-comment-306-5
ἄρχω
495
mvp-comment-307-1
ὕβριν … οὐκ ἔχω
496
κακῶς κλύουσα
497
mvp-comment-308-1
πατὴρ γάρ
498
mvp-comment-308-2
πρόσχημα
499
mvp-comment-309-1
ἡ γὰρ Δίκη
500
mvp-comment-310-1
ᾗ χρῆν σ’ ἀρήγειν
501
mvp-comment-311-1
The order of words in the MSS.,
ἐπεὶ πατὴρ οὗτος σός
, is probably right; the words would then fall from her with a certain deliberate bitterness.
Cp. 542
:
Ant. 44
ἦ γὰρ νοεῖς θάπτειν σθ’
(n.):
Ph. 101
λέγω σ’ ἐγὼ δόλῳ Φιλοκτήτην λαβεῖν
.
mvp-comment-312-1
μοῦνος
502
Ἑλλήνων
503
mvp-comment-312-2
Nauck requires
τὴν αὐτὸς αὑτοῦ
instead of
τὴν σὴν ὅμαιμον
, because Agamemnon's unique crime was the slaughter of his own child: as if the text did not convey this. Clytaemnestra means, ‘while mourning a father, you forget a sister.’
mvp-comment-312-3
532 f. The regular mode of expression would be,
οὐκ ἴσον λύπης καμὼν ἐμοί, ὁ σπείρας τῇ τικτούσῃ
. But, having written
ὅτ’ ἔσπειρε
, the poet explains
ἐμοί
by repeating the comparison in a new form,
ὥσπερ ἡ τίκτουσ’ ἐγώ
. (For
ὡς
or
ὥσπερ
after
ἴσος
, cp.
Lys. or. 19 § 36
ἡγοῦντο... τὰ ἐκεῖ...εἶναι ἴσα ὥσπερ τὰ ἐνθάδε
.) Those who reject v. 533 omit to notice that, without it, the words
οὐκ ἴσον καμὼν ἐμοί
would be unintelligible. Cp.
Aesch.
Ag. 1417
ἔθυσεν αὑτοῦ παῖδα, φιλτάτην ἐμοὶ
|
ὠδῖν’
.
mvp-comment-312-4
This assertion of the mother's superior claim is a counterpart to the doctrine of Athena in
Aesch.
Eum. 658
f.,
οὐκ ἔστι μήτηρ ἡ κεκλημένου τέκνου
|
τοκεύς, τροφὸς δὲ κύματος νεοσπόρου
. Cp. above,
Aesch. Eum. 366
n.
mvp-comment-313-1
τοῦ χάριν, τίνων
504
mvp-comment-313-2
The alternative, which most editors have preferred, is to take
τίνων
as the participle. But there is an insuperable objection to this, which seems to have escaped notice. The words,
τοῦ χάριν τίνων
; could mean only, ‘paying a debt of gratitude
for what?’ They could not mean, ‘paying a debt of gratitude
to whom?’ The latter would be
τῷ χάριν τίνων
; See (
e.g.)
Aesch.
P. V. 985
καὶ μὴν ὀφείλων ἂν τίνοιμ’ αὐτῷ χάριν
:
Aesch.
Ag. 821
τούτων θεοῖσι χρὴ πολύμνηστον χάριν
|
τίνειν
. Hence the question,
τοῦ χάριν τίνων
; could not possibly be answered by
Ἀργείων
. For, evidently, the latter word could not mean, (‘for a benefit conferred by) the Greeks.’ A scholiast in the Baroccian MS. (cr. n. on 545), who explains
τοῦ χάριν τίνων
by
τίνος χάριν ἀποδιδούς
, plainly meant, ‘showing gratitude for what?’—and his paraphrase was correct; only he overlooked the context.
mvp-comment-314-1
ἀλλ’ οὐ μετῆν
505
mvp-comment-315-1
ἀλλ’ ἀντ’ ἀδελφοῦ δῆτα
506
κτανὼν
507
mvp-comment-315-2
ἀντὶ ἀδελφοῦ
508
mvp-comment-315-3
τἄμ’
509
mvp-comment-316-1
παῖδες … διπλοῖ
510
mvp-comment-316-2
540 f. Nauck would prefer a single verse in place of these two, viz.
οὓς Ἰφιγενείας εἰκὸς ἦν θνῄσκειν πάρος
.
mvp-comment-317-1
ἢ
511
mvp-comment-317-2
ἢ τῶν ἐμῶν Ἅιδης
512
mvp-comment-318-1
δαίσασθαι
513
mvp-comment-318-2
The conj.
λῄσασθαι
514
mvp-comment-319-1
πανώλει
515
mvp-comment-319-2
παρεῖτο
516
mvp-comment-319-3
The sense does not absolutely require us to take
Μενέλεω δ’
517
mvp-comment-320-1
ἀβούλου
518
mvp-comment-320-2
κακοῦ γνώμην
519
mvp-comment-321-1
δοκῶ μέν
520
mvp-comment-321-2
εἰ καὶ
521
mvp-comment-322-1
εἰ φωνὴν λάβοι
522
mvp-comment-323-1
τοῖς πεπραγμένοις
523
mvp-comment-324-1
γνώμην δικαίαν σχοῦσα
524
mvp-comment-325-1
ἐρεῖς μὲν οὐχὶ
525
ἐρεῖς
526
ἐρεῖς … μ’ ὡς
527
mvp-comment-325-2
ἄρξασά τι λυπηρὸν
528
mvp-comment-325-3
τάδ’ ἐξήκους’
529
mvp-comment-326-1
τοῦ τεθνηκότος θ’ ὕπερ
530
mvp-comment-327-1
καὶ μὴν
531
mvp-comment-327-2
λόγους ἐξῆρχές με
532
mvp-comment-328-1
Clytaemnestra has argued that she was justified in slaying Agamemnon, because he had slain Iphigeneia. The topics of Electra's reply are as follows.
mvp-comment-328-2
(1) 558—562. The wife who slew her husband would be a criminal, even if the motive had been just retribution; but the real motive was her love for Aegisthus. (2) 563—576. Agamemnon was not a free agent in slaying Iphigeneia; the act was forced upon him by Artemis. (3) 577—583. Suppose, however, that he was a free agent, and wished to please his brother; still she was not justified in taking his life. (4) 584—594. And in any case her plea does not excuse her for living with the man who helped to slay her husband.—The speech then closes in a strain of reproach and defiance (595 —609).
mvp-comment-328-3
καὶ δὴ λέγω σοι
533
πατέρα
534
φὴς
535
mvp-comment-329-1
εἴτ’ οὖν … εἴτε
536
mvp-comment-329-2
λέξω
537
δείξω
538
mvp-comment-330-1
ὡς οὐ δίκῃ γ’
539
ἔσπασεν
540
πειθὼ
541
mvp-comment-331-1
κυναγὸν
542
mvp-comment-331-2
ποινὰς
543
mvp-comment-331-3
τὰ πολλὰ πνεύματ’ ἔσχ’
544
τὰ πολλὰ
545
ἔσχε
546
mvp-comment-331-4
Acc. to Aesch. (
Aesch.
Ag. 149
f.,
Aesch. Ag. 192
), the Greeks were detained by
adverse winds, blowing from the N.E. : and this seems to have been the account given in the
Cypria (
c. 776 B.C.), Proclus
Chrest. p. 455:
ἐπέσχεν αὐτοὺς τοῦ πλοῦ χειμῶνας ἐπιπέμπουσα
. But other authorities speak of a
calm. Thus
I. A. 9 ff.
οὔκουν φθόγγος γ’ οὔτ’ ὀρνίθων
|
οὔτε θαλάσσης· σιγαὶ δ’ ἀνέμων
|
τόνδε κατ’ Εὔριπον ἔχουσιν
. Schol.
Eur.
Or. 647
ἐπειράθη τῆς θεοῦ ὀργιζομένης καὶ κατεχούσης τοὺς ἀνέμους
. Tzetzes on Lycophron 183
χολωθεῖσα δ’ ἐπὶ τούτῳ ἡ θεὸς τοὺς ἀνέμους κατέσχεν
. Ovid (
Met. 13. 183
) combines both versions:
exspectata diu, nulla aut contraria classi | Flamina sunt.
mvp-comment-331-5
It has been objected that vessels provided with oars need not have been detained by a calm. But the ships of the Greek fleet were not light craft. Each carried from 50 to 120 armed men, besides
σκεύη πολεμικά
: and the warriors were also the rowers (cp.
Thuc. 1. 10
). It is intelligible, then, that they should await the aid of wind before attempting the passage of the Aegaean. We must remember, too, the strong and shifting currents in the Euripus (
στονόεντα πορθμόν
,
Soph.
Ant. 1145
:
παλιρρόχθοις ἐν Αὐλίδος τόποις
,
Aesch.
Ag. 191
).
mvp-comment-331-6
We cannot well render:—(1)‘He
suffered those tedious winds,’—supplying
ὁ πατήρ
from v. 558. Nor: (2) ‘She
directed those tedious winds at Aulis,’—a version which would at least require
ἐπ’ Αὐλίδι
. Cp.
Ph. 1119
ἔχε
|
δύσποτμον ἀρὰν ἐπ’ ἄλλοις
.
mvp-comment-331-7
The conjecture
πλοῖα
547
mvp-comment-331-8
Αὐλίδι
548
mvp-comment-332-1
ἢ )γὼ φράσω
549
κείνης
550
mvp-comment-333-1
ὡς ἐγὼ κλύω
551
mvp-comment-333-2
θεᾶς … κατ’ ἄλσος
552
mvp-comment-333-3
παίζων
553
mvp-comment-333-4
ποδοῖν
554
mvp-comment-334-1
ἔλαφον
555
mvp-comment-334-2
στικτὸν
556
mvp-comment-334-3
κεράστην
557
mvp-comment-334-4
οὗ κατὰ σφαγὰς
558
mvp-comment-335-1
ἐκκομπάσας ἔπος τι τυγχάνει
559
βαλών
560
mvp-comment-335-2
This is the reason against taking
τυγχάνει
with
βαλών
, as=‘he shoots and hits’; cp.
Il. 15. 581
θηρητὴρ ἐτύχησε βαλών
:
Her. 3. 35
εἰ...τοῦ παιδὸς...βαλὼν τύχοιμι
. The vaunt must then
precede the hit.
mvp-comment-335-3
Others take
βαλὼν
561
ἔπος
562
mvp-comment-335-4
Monk, with Musgrave, took
σφαγὰς
563
mvp-comment-336-1
ἐκ τοῦδε
564
mvp-comment-336-2
μηνίσασα
565
mvp-comment-336-3
Λητῴα κόρη
566
mvp-comment-337-1
ὡς
567
ἀντίσταθμον
568
mvp-comment-337-2
ἐκθύσειε
569
mvp-comment-338-1
ὧδ’ ἦν
570
mvp-comment-338-2
τὰ … θύματ’
571
mvp-comment-338-3
λύσις
572
mvp-comment-338-4
πρὸς οἶκον
573
mvp-comment-339-1
πολλὰ
574
mvp-comment-339-2
ἀντιβὰς
575
mvp-comment-339-3
μόλις
576
mvp-comment-340-1
εἰ δ’ οὖν
577
mvp-comment-340-2
ἐρῶ γὰρ καὶ τὸ σόν
578
mvp-comment-341-1
τούτου … οὕνεκ’
579
mvp-comment-341-2
νόμῳ
580
mvp-comment-342-1
ὅρα
581
μὴ … τιθῇς
582
τίθης
583
mvp-comment-342-2
Here, either
τίθης
or
τιθῇς
would be suitable. (1) With
τίθης
:—‘See that, in making this rule, you
are not making woe for yourself.’ This means that to make the rule (as she is doing) is at once (logically) to make the woe. (2) With
τιθῇς
: —‘See
lest, in making this rule, you
make woe for yourself’:
i.e., the rule may have the woe as a consequence. The woe is a future contingency (583
εἰ δίκης γε τυγχάνοις
), against which Electra warns her. On the whole, I now prefer
τιθῇς
.
Cp. 1003
ὅρα κακῶς πράσσοντε μὴ μείζω κακὰ
|
κτησώμεθ’
: fr. 82
ἀλλ’ ὅρα μὴ κρεῖσσον ᾖ
.
mvp-comment-342-3
τιθεῖσα … νόμον
584
mvp-comment-343-1
εἰ γὰρ κτενοῦμεν
585
mvp-comment-343-2
πρώτη
586
mvp-comment-344-1
εἰσόρα
587
mvp-comment-344-2
οὐκ οὖσαν
588
mvp-comment-344-3
τίθης
589
mvp-comment-344-4
εἰ … θέλεις
590
mvp-comment-345-1
τῷ παλαμναίῳ
591
mvp-comment-345-2
πρόσθεν ἐξαπώλεσας
592
mvp-comment-346-1
παιδοποιεῖς
593
mvp-comment-346-2
Erigonè, daughter of Aegisthus and Clytaemnestra (Tzetzes on
Lyc. 1374
), was mentioned by the early cyclic poet Cinaethon (
Paus. 2. 18. 6
), and was the theme of Sophocles in his
Ἠριγόνη
. Hyginus (
Hyg.
Fab. 122
) notices a son of Aegisthus named Aletes, who gives his name to a play by Sophocles, but does not record the mother: see p. xliii note 4.
mvp-comment-346-3
εὐσεβεῖς
594
mvp-comment-346-4
κἀξ εὐσεβῶν
595
mvp-comment-346-5
By
τοὺς...πρόσθεν εὐσεβεῖς
Electra means Orestes and herself. Both are ‘cast out’ of their just rights. Cp.
O.T. 611
φίλον ...ἐσθλὸν ἐκβαλεῖν
.
Eur.
El. 62
τεκοῦσα δ’ ἄλλους παῖδας Αἰγίσθῳ πάρα
|
πάρεργ’ Ὀρέστην κἀμὲ ποιεῖται δόμων.
mvp-comment-346-6
βλαστόντας
596
mvp-comment-346-7
ἐκβαλοῦσ’ ἔχεις
597
mvp-comment-347-1
πῶς ταῦτ’ ἐπαινέσαιμ’ ἄν
598
mvp-comment-347-2
ἢ
599
ἦ
600
καὶ τοῦτ’
601
ἄποινα
602
mvp-comment-348-1
αἰσχρῶς δ’
603
δ’
604
mvp-comment-348-2
ἐάν περ καὶ λέγῃς
605
mvp-comment-348-3
ἐχθροῖς γαμεῖσθαι
606
mvp-comment-348-4
These two verses, though not indispensable, seem genuine. Were they omitted, the transition from 592 to 595 would be somewhat abrupt.
mvp-comment-349-1
ἀλλ’ οὐ γὰρ
607
mvp-comment-349-2
πᾶσαν ἵης γλῶσσαν
608
mvp-comment-350-1
κακοστομοῦμεν
609
mvp-comment-350-2
καί σ’ ἔγωγε δεσπότιν
610
mvp-comment-350-3
εἰς ἡμᾶς
611
ἣ
612
mvp-comment-351-1
βίον μοχθηρόν
613
mvp-comment-351-2
ἔκ τε σοῦ
614
κακοῖς … ξυνοῦσα
615
mvp-comment-351-3
συννόμου
616
mvp-comment-352-1
ὁ δ’ ἄλλος
617
mvp-comment-352-2
χεῖρα σὴν
618
mvp-comment-352-3
τρίβει βίον
619
mvp-comment-352-4
603 The reason for writing
δή με σοὶ
620
δή μέ σοι
621
mvp-comment-352-5
μιάστορα
622
mvp-comment-353-1
τοῦδέ γ’ οὕνεκα
623
mvp-comment-354-1
εἰς ἅπαντας
624
mvp-comment-354-2
χρῇς
625
mvp-comment-354-3
στόμαργον
626
mvp-comment-355-1
τῶνδε τῶν ἔ|ργων ἴδρις
627
mvp-comment-355-2
σχεδόν τι
628
mvp-comment-355-3
οὐ καταισχύνω
629
mvp-comment-356-1
ὁρῶ μένος πνέουσαν
630
μένος πνέουσαν
631
mvp-comment-356-2
σὺν δίκῃ ξύνεστι
632
mvp-comment-356-3
Other interpretations are:—(1) ‘I see that Electra is wroth; but as to whether she is in the right, I see no concern (anywhere),’—a timid way of saying that
Clytaemnestra shows no such concern. So the schol. (2) ‘I see that Clytaemnestra is angry, but not that she cares whether she is right’:—an inference from some gesture. Both these versions rely on the fact that
φροντίδος
(612) is plainly an echo of
φροντίδ’
(611). But: (
a) it does not follow that
φροντίδ’
is not
Electra's thought. (
b) It is surely clear that
πνέουσαν
must be Electra; and (
c) as in
Ant. 471
f., the second clause naturally refers to the same person.
mvp-comment-357-1
ποίας δ’ ἐμοὶ δεῖ
633
ἐμοὶ
634
μοι
635
δεῖ
636
mvp-comment-357-2
Others understand: (1) ‘If Electra has no consideration for justice, why should I have any consideration for her,—
i.e., show her any tenderness?’ Or: (2) ‘If she heeds not justice, why should I heed her?’ Neither view seems well suited to the context.
mvp-comment-358-1
καὶ ταῦτα
637
mvp-comment-358-2
τηλικοῦτος
638
mvp-comment-358-3
ἆρα
639
mvp-comment-358-4
χωρεῖν ἂν
640
εἰς πᾶν ἔργον
641
mvp-comment-359-1
εὖ νυν ἐπίστω
642
mvp-comment-359-2
ἔξωρα
643
mvp-comment-359-3
προσεικότα
644
mvp-comment-360-1
ἀλλὰ … γὰρ
645
mvp-comment-360-2
ἡ … ἐκ σοῦ δυσμένεια
646
mvp-comment-360-3
ἐξαναγκάζει
647
αἰσχροῖς
648
mvp-comment-360-4
622 f. The word
θρέμμα
649
mvp-comment-360-5
ἦ σ’ ἐγὼ
650
mvp-comment-361-1
νιν
651
mvp-comment-361-2
εὑρίσκεται
652
mvp-comment-361-3
Cp. Milton,
Apology for Smectymnuus (in his
Prose Works, ed. Symmons, vol. I. p. 236): ‘I might also tell them [the prelates], what Electra in Sophocles, a wise virgin, answered her wicked mother, who thought herself too violently reproved by her the daughter: ‘'
Tis you that say it,
not I; you do the deeds, |
And your ungodly deeds find me the words.’’
mvp-comment-362-1
οὐ μὰ
653
mvp-comment-362-2
δέσποιναν
654
mvp-comment-362-3
Ἄρτεμιν
655
mvp-comment-362-4
θράσους τοῦδ’ οὐκ ἀλύξεις
656
μόλῃ
657
mvp-comment-363-1
ὁρᾷς
658
mvp-comment-363-2
ἐκφέρει
659
mvp-comment-363-3
The
v. l.
παρεῖσα
660
mvp-comment-364-1
οὐδὲ
661
mvp-comment-364-2
ὑπ’ εὐφήμου βοῆς
662
mvp-comment-364-3
ἐπειδὴ σοί γ’
663
mvp-comment-364-4
πᾶν λέγειν
664
mvp-comment-365-1
κελεύω
665
mvp-comment-365-2
τοὐμὸν στόμ’
666
mvp-comment-365-3
634 f. An altar, and probably an image, of Apollo stand before the palace. The attendant of Clytaemnestra carries offerings of various fruits, which she is now commanded to
raise, as with a gesture of solemn oblation (
ἔπαιρε
667
mvp-comment-365-4
ἡ παροῦσά μοι
668
mvp-comment-365-5
θύματα … πάγκαρπα
669
mvp-comment-366-1
λυτηρίους … δειμάτων
670
mvp-comment-366-2
ἀνάσχω
671
mvp-comment-367-1
κλύοις ἂν
672
mvp-comment-367-2
προστατήριε
673
mvp-comment-368-1
κεκρυμμένην
674
mvp-comment-368-2
οὐ γὰρ ἐν φίλοις
675
mvp-comment-369-1
πρὸς φῶς
676
mvp-comment-370-1
πολυγλώσσῳ
677
mvp-comment-370-2
σπείρῃ
678
mvp-comment-370-3
ματαίαν
679
mvp-comment-371-1
ὧδ’
680
mvp-comment-372-1
γὰρ
681
mvp-comment-372-2
δισσῶν ὀνείρων
682
mvp-comment-372-3
Jacobs Fr.(
ap. Wunder) understood, ‘
two dreams,’—as if Clyt.'s vision consisted of two parts,—the return of Agamemnon, and the growth from the sceptre (417—423). This seems forced. Still less can we assume that there was some second dream which Clyt. did not relate even to the Sun-god (425).
mvp-comment-372-4
Λύκεἰ ἄναξ
683
mvp-comment-373-1
ἐσθλά … ἐχθρά
684
mvp-comment-373-2
Cp.
Aesch.
Pers. 217
, where the Chorus are advising Atossa how to propitiate the gods after her dream:
εἴ τι φλαῦρον εἶδες, αἰτοῦ τῶνδ’ ἀποτροπὴν τελεῖν
, |
τὰ δ’ ἀγάθ’ ἐκτελῆ γενέσθαι σοί τε καὶ τέκνῳ σέθεν κ.τ.λ.
mvp-comment-373-3
ἔμπαλιν μέθες
685
mvp-comment-374-1
εἴ τινες
686
mvp-comment-375-1
ἀλλ’ ὧδε
687
mvp-comment-375-2
ἀβλαβεῖ βίῳ
688
mvp-comment-376-1
δόμους
689
mvp-comment-376-2
ἀμφέπειν
690
mvp-comment-376-3
φίλοισι
691
mvp-comment-377-1
εὐημεροῦσαν
692
mvp-comment-377-2
καὶ τέκνων
693
ὅσων
694
mvp-comment-377-3
We might also take
τέκνων
as standing, by attraction, for
τέκνοις
. When the antecedent is thus attracted, it usually comes after the relative (
O.C. 56); but sometimes precedes it, as in
Tr. 151
f.
τότ’ ἄν τις εἰσίδοιτο
... | ...
κακοῖσιν
(for
κακά
)
ο<*>ς ἐγὼ βαρύνομαι
. In examples of the latter kind, however, the acc. (and not, as it would be here, the dat.) is elsewhere the case attracted. In favour of taking
τέκνων
as partitive, it may be added that this suits the distinction between two groups of
τέκνα
. By
ὅσων
she means Chrysothemis, Iphianassa, and the offspring o<*> her union with Aegisthus (157; 589).
mvp-comment-377-4
ἐμοὶ … πρόσεστιν
695
mvp-comment-378-1
πᾶσιν ἡμῖν
696
mvp-comment-379-1
τὰ δ’ ἄλλα πάντα
697
mvp-comment-379-2
660 Following the directions given in vv. 39 ff., the Paedagogus now appears as a
ξένος Φωκεύς
. Cp.
O.T. 924 ff., where the messenger from Corinth presents himself to Iocasta and the Chorus.
mvp-comment-379-3
πῶς ἂν εἰδείην
698
mvp-comment-380-1
ἦ καὶ
699
mvp-comment-380-2
ἐπεικάζων κυρῶ
700
mvp-comment-380-3
πρέπ<*> γὰρ
701
mvp-comment-381-1
μάλιστα πάντων
702
mvp-comment-381-2
ἥδε σοι κείνη πάρα
703
mvp-comment-381-3
666 f. The
ὦ
704
χαῖρε
705
mvp-comment-382-1
ἐδεξάμην τὸ ῥηθέν
706
mvp-comment-382-2
Instant recognition of an utterance as well-omened was a way of appropriating the omen. The proper formula was
δέχομαι τὸν οἰωνόν
or
τὸν ὄρνιν
(
Her. 9. 91
;
Ar.
Pl. 63
). But
δέχομαι
alone was enough (
Xen.
An. 1. 8. 17
: cp.
Aesch.
Ag. 1653
δεχομένοις λέγεις θανεῖν σε
). The phrase used here recurs in
Her. 8. 114
δεξάμενος τὸ ῥηθὲν ἀπαλλάσσετο
: cp. also
Eur.
El. 622
προσηκάμην τὸ ῥηθέν
.
mvp-comment-382-3
εἰδέναι … σου
707
mvp-comment-383-1
Φανοτεὺς
708
mvp-comment-383-2
πρᾶγμα πορσύνων μέγα
709
mvp-comment-384-1
τὸ ποῖον
710
mvp-comment-385-1
ἐν βραχεῖ ξυνθεὶς
711
mvp-comment-386-1
τί φής, τί φής
712
ξεῖνε
713
mvp-comment-386-2
ταύτης
714
mvp-comment-387-1
νῦν τε καὶ πάλαι
715
mvp-comment-388-1
οὐδέν εἰμ’ ἔτι
716
mvp-comment-389-1
τὰ σαυτῆς πρᾶσς’
717
mvp-comment-389-2
διόλλυται
718
mvp-comment-390-1
κἀπεμπόμην
719
καὶ … φράσω
720
mvp-comment-391-1
γὰρ
721
mvp-comment-392-1
πρόσχημ’ ἀγῶνος
722
Ἑλλάδος
723
mvp-comment-392-2
πρόσχημα
724
mvp-comment-392-3
Δελφ. ἄθλων
725
mvp-comment-393-1
ὀρθίων
726
mvp-comment-393-2
δρόμον … οὗ πρώτη κρίσις
727
mvp-comment-394-1
εἰσῆλθε
728
mvp-comment-395-1
ἰσώσας * τἀφέσει
729
τῇ φύσει
730
mvp-comment-395-2
Now there is evidence that the customary order for the foot-races was, 1.
δόλιχος
, 2.
στάδιον
, 3.
δίαυλος
. See Boeckh
C. I. G. no. 1590 and 1591 (referring to games at Thespiae,
circ. 240 B.C.): also no. 2214 (games at Chios,
circ. 100—80 B.C.).
Paus. 6. 13. 3
(of the athlete Polites at Olympia),
δολίχου τε ἐν ἡμέρᾳ τῇ αὐτῇ καὶ παραυτίκα σταδίου λαβὼν νίκην προσέθηκε διαύλου σφίσι τὴν τρίτην
. It would agree, then, with the words
οὗ πρώτη κρίσις
(684) if the
δόλιχος
were meant here. [As to
Legg. 833 D, see Appendix.]
mvp-comment-395-3
For
ἄφεσις
as=‘starting-place,’ cp. Suidas (
s.v.
ἀπὸ γραμμῆς
):
γραμμῆς, ἣν ἄφεσιν καὶ βαλβῖδα καλοῦσιν
:
Paus. 6. 20. 9
ᾗ τοῖς σταδιοδρόμοις ἄφεσις πεποίηται
:
id. 5. 15. 5
ἐν δὲ τῶν ἵππων τῇ
ἀφέσει, ἐν μὲν τῷ ὑπαίθρῳ τῆς ἀφέσεως κ.τ.λ.
—Dindorf notes that in Aristeides vol. I. p. 339 the words
τῆς ἀφέσεως
were corrupted to
τῆς φύσεως
.
mvp-comment-395-4
The proposed versions of the vulgate
τῇ φύσει
731
mvp-comment-396-1
νίκης … γέρας
732
mvp-comment-397-1
χὥπως μὲν
733
mvp-comment-397-2
Others explain:—
οὐκ οἶδα δὲ ὅπως τοιοῦδ’ ἀνδρὸς ἔργα καὶ κράτη λέγω σοι παῦρα ἐν πολλοῖς
: ‘I do not know how to describe his deeds to you briefly, when they were so many.’ The place of
οἶδα
can be justified by
O.T. 1251. But: (1) thus construed, the words ought to mean, ‘I do not know how to describe his deeds
as few.’ The other meaning would require
ἐν παύροις
, or the like. And (2)
ἐν πολλοῖσι
is then awkward.
mvp-comment-398-1
ὅσων
734
mvp-comment-398-2
εἰσεκήρυξαν
735
mvp-comment-398-3
βραβῆς
736
mvp-comment-399-1
δρομων διαύλων
737
mvp-comment-399-2
On the whole, I should incline to delete 691, and alter
τούτων
in 692 to
ἄθλων
.
mvp-comment-400-1
ἐνεγκὼν
738
mvp-comment-400-2
τἀπινίκια
739
mvp-comment-401-1
ὠλβίζετ’
740
ἀνακαλ
741
mvp-comment-401-2
Ἀγαμέμνονος
742
mvp-comment-401-3
ἀγείραντος
743
mvp-comment-402-1
καὶ ταῦτα μὲν τοιαῦθ’
744
mvp-comment-402-2
βλάπτῃ
745
mvp-comment-402-3
ἰσχύων
746
mvp-comment-403-1
ἄλλης ἡμέρας
747
mvp-comment-403-2
ἱππικῶν
748
mvp-comment-404-1
ἡλίου τέλλοντος
749
mvp-comment-404-2
The Pythian hippodrome was in the Crisaean plain (180 n.), near its upper or northern end, where the rocky gorge of the river Pleistus opens upon a level tract. The site of Crisa, on a spur of Parnassus, overlooked it from the north, and Delphi from the north-east. Beautiful as was Olympia, the scene of the Pythian festival was unrivalled in the grandeur of its natural surroundings.
mvp-comment-405-1
Ἀχαιός
750
mvp-comment-406-1
Λίβυες
751
mvp-comment-406-2
ζυγωτῶν
752
ἐπιστάται
753
mvp-comment-407-1
κἀκεῖνος
754
mvp-comment-407-2
ἐν τούτοισι
755
ἐπὶ
756
mvp-comment-407-3
Θεσσαλὰς … ἵππους
757
mvp-comment-408-1
ξανθαῖσι
758
mvp-comment-408-2
πώλοις
759
mvp-comment-408-3
Μάγνης
760
mvp-comment-409-1
λεύκιππος
761
mvp-comment-409-2
Αἰνιὰν
762
mvp-comment-410-1
τῶν θεοδμήτων
763
mvp-comment-411-1
ἄλλος
764
ἐκπληρῶν
765
mvp-comment-412-1
στάντες
766
mvp-comment-412-2
†ὅθ’ αὐτοὺς
767
ὅθ’
768
ἵν’
769
ὅτ’
770
mvp-comment-412-3
βραβῆς
771
οἱ τεταγμένοι
772
mvp-comment-412-4
710 *
κλήρους ἔπηλαν
. I should much prefer to read
αὐτοῖς
in 709: but
αὐτοὺς
is defensible, and I refrain from change. Two views are possible; the first is generally received, and is perhaps simplest. (1)
αὐτοὺς
depends on
κλήρους ἔπηλαν
as=
ἐκλήρωσαν
: cp.
Ar.
Eccl. 683
κληρώσω πάντας
, ‘I will place them all by lot,’
ἕως ἂν
|
εἰδὼς ὁ λαχὼν ἀπίῃ κ.τ.λ.
See above on 123,
Ar. Eccl. 556.
(2)
κλήρους ἔπηλαν καὶ
=
κλήρους πήλαντες
, a parenthetic construction (
διὰ μέσου
), so that
αὐτοὺς
is governed by
κατέστησαν
only, and
δίφρους
is a second acc., defining
αὐτούς
, as in
μέθες με...χεῖρα
(
Soph.
Ph. 1301
).
See on 466
f.
mvp-comment-412-5
ἔπηλαν
773
mvp-comment-413-1
χαλκῆς
774
mvp-comment-413-2
ὑπαὶ
775
mvp-comment-413-3
οἱ δ’
776
mvp-comment-414-1
ὁμοκλήσαντες
777
mvp-comment-415-1
ἐν δὲ
778
mvp-comment-415-2
κροτητῶν
779
mvp-comment-415-3
I formerly took
κροτητῶν
as=‘welded,’ ‘hammered,’ with ref. to the metal-work of the chariots: cp.
Il. 23. 503
ἅρματα δὲ χρυσῷ πεπυκασμένα κασσιτέρῳ τε
: 10. 438
ἅρμα δέ οἱ χρυσῷ τε καὶ ἀργύρῳ εὖ ἤσκηται
: 4. 226
ἅρματα ποικίλα χαλκῷ
. (Cp. Helbig,
H. E. p. 90.) For this sense of
κροτεῖν
, cp. Pind. fr. 194
κεκρότηται χρυσέα κρηπὶς...ἀοιδαῖς
.
mvp-comment-416-1
φορεῖθ’
780
mvp-comment-417-1
κέντρων
781
mvp-comment-417-2
ὡς ὑπερβάλοι
782
τις
783
mvp-comment-417-3
χνόας
784
mvp-comment-417-4
φρυάγμαθ’ ἱππικά
785
mvp-comment-418-1
ὁμοῦ γὰρ ἀμφὶ νῶτα
786
mvp-comment-418-2
τροχῶν βάσεις
787
mvp-comment-418-3
εἰσέβαλλον
788
mvp-comment-419-1
ὑπ’ αὐτὴν
789
mvp-comment-419-2
ἐσχάτην στήλην
790
mvp-comment-420-1
ἔχριμπτ’ ἀεὶ σύριγγα
791
ἔχριμπτ’
792
mvp-comment-420-2
δεξιὸν δ’ ἀνεὶς κ.τ.λ.
793
mvp-comment-420-3
Sophocles has in mind the words of Nestor to Antilochus,
Il. 23. 336
τὸν δεξιὸν ἵππον
|
κένσαι ὁμοκλήσας, εἶξαί τέ οἱ ἡνία χερσίν·
|
ἐν νύσσῃ δέ τοι ἵππος ἀριστερὸς ἐγχριμφθήτω
, |
ὡς ἄν τοι πλήμνη γε δοάσσεται ἄκρον ἱκέσθαι
|
κύκλου ποιητοῖο
(‘so that just the nave of the well-wrought wheel may seem to graze it’).
mvp-comment-421-1
πρὶν μὲν
794
ἔπειτα δ’
795
mvp-comment-421-2
ἕστασαν
796
mvp-comment-422-1
ἄστομοι
797
mvp-comment-422-2
βίᾳ φέρουσιν
798
mvp-comment-422-3
ἐκ δ’ ὑποστροφῆς
799
mvp-comment-423-1
τελοῦντες κ.τ.λ.
800
mvp-comment-423-2
The Aenian, closely followed by the others, had just completed his sixth
δίαυλος
, or double course, in the hippodrome:
i.e., he had just passed, for the sixth time, round the goal nearest to the starting-place, and was on the point of beginning his seventh course. Just as he was passing the goal, his horses bolted. Hence he could not work them quite round into the track. They turned out of the left-ward curve (
ἐξ ὑποστροφῆς
), and ran straight on. Meanwhile, one of the two Libyan chariots had swept round the goal in a wider circle, on the Aenian's right. The Aenian's horses dashed head-foremost into the Libyan's team, striking it on the left side.
mvp-comment-423-3
In the four - horse chariot - race at Olympia the number of double courses was
twelve. Hence the goal farthest from the starting-place is
δωδεκάγναμπτον... τέρμα δρόμου
|
ἵππων
(
Pind.
O. 3. 33
: cp.
Pind.
O. 2. 55
,
Pind. O. 6. 75
,
Pind.
P. 5. 33
). If the
ἱππικὸν
(=4 stadia) be taken as the length of one double course in the hippodrome, twelve such courses give about 51/2 English miles. (Cp. art.
Hippodromus in Smith's
Dict. Ant., 3rd ed., p. 965
a.)
mvp-comment-423-4
Βαρκαίοις ὄχοις
801
mvp-comment-424-1
ἐξ ἑνὸς κακοῦ
802
ἔθραυε καὶ ἐνέπιπτε
803
mvp-comment-424-2
ναυαγίων
804
mvp-comment-424-3
Κρισαῖον … πέδον
805
mvp-comment-425-1
γνοὺς δ’
806
mvp-comment-425-2
κἀνοκωχεύει
807
mvp-comment-425-3
κλύδων’
808
mvp-comment-426-1
ἔσχατος μὲν
809
mvp-comment-426-2
ὑστέρας ἔχων
810
φέρων
811
πίστιν φέρων
812
mvp-comment-426-3
Those who read
ὑστέρας δ’
understand, ‘last, indeed,
but last by his own choice.’ This is possible, but less simple. The
μὲν
after
ἔσχατος
probably led to the insertion of
δ’
.
mvp-comment-426-4
Wunder cp.
Acad. Pr. 2. 29. 94
Ego enim,
ut agitator callidus,
prius quam ad finem veniam,
equos sustinebo.
mvp-comment-427-1
ὅπως δ’ ὁρᾷ
813
mvp-comment-428-1
ἐνσείσας.
814
mvp-comment-429-1
κἀξισώσαντε ζυγὰ
815
mvp-comment-429-2
τότ’ … ἄλλοθ’
816
mvp-comment-429-3
ἄλλος … ἅτερος
817
mvp-comment-429-4
κάρα προβάλλων
818
mvp-comment-429-5
For
προβάλλων
819
mvp-comment-430-1
τοὺς μὲν ἄλλους πάντας
820
mvp-comment-430-2
ἀσφαλεῖς
821
mvp-comment-430-3
ὠρθοῦθ’
822
ὀρθὸς ἐξ ὀρθῶν δί‐
823
φρων
824
mvp-comment-431-1
λύων ἡνίαν ἀριστερὰν
825
mvp-comment-432-1
χνόας
826
μέσας
827
mvp-comment-433-1
ἀντύγων
828
mvp-comment-433-2
σὺν δ’ ἑλίσσεται
829
τμητοῖς
830
mvp-comment-434-1
διεσπάρησαν εἰς μέσον δρόμον
831
mvp-comment-434-2
Cp.
Il. 23. 467
ἔνθα μιν ἐκπεσέειν ὀΐω σύν θ’ ἅρματα ἆξαι
, |
αἱ δ’
[
sc.
ἵπποι
]
ἐξηρώησαν, ἐπεὶ μένος ἔλλαβε θυμόν
(‘rushed out of the course’).
mvp-comment-435-1
στρατὸς
832
mvp-comment-435-2
δίφρων
833
mvp-comment-435-3
ἀνωλόλυξε
834
mvp-comment-435-4
οἷ’ … οἷα
835
mvp-comment-436-1
φορούμενος πρὸς οὖδας
836
mvp-comment-436-2
ἄλλοτ’
837
mvp-comment-436-3
οὐρανῷ σκέλη προφαίνων
838
mvp-comment-437-1
διφρηλάται
839
mvp-comment-437-2
κατασχεθόντες
840
mvp-comment-438-1
κέαντες
841
mvp-comment-438-2
ἐν βραχεῖ χαλκῷ
842
mvp-comment-438-3
μέγιστον
843
mvp-comment-438-4
σῶμα … σποδοῦ
844
mvp-comment-438-5
Cp.
Aesch.
Ag. 440
(Ares)
πυρωθὲν ἐξ Ἰλίου
|
φίλοισι πέμπει βραχὺ
|
ψῆγμα δυσδάκρυτον, ἀντήνορος σποδοῦ γεμίζων λέβητας εὐθέτου
.
Suppl. 1130
σποδοῦ τε πλῆθος ὀλίγον ἀντὶ σωμάτων
|
εὐδοκίμων
. Propert. 2. 9. 13 (Briseïs with the ashes of Achilles),
et tanti corpus Achillei |
Maximaque in parva sustulit ossa manu.
mvp-comment-439-1
ἄνδρες Φωκέων
845
mvp-comment-439-2
ἐκλάχῃ
846
mvp-comment-440-1
τοιαῦτά σοι
847
ταῦτ’ ἐστίν
848
mvp-comment-440-2
ὡς μὲν ἐν λόγῳ
849
mvp-comment-440-3
τοῖς δ’ ἰδ., οἵπερ εἴδομεν
850
mvp-comment-440-4
764 f. The word
δεσπόταισι
851
mvp-comment-440-5
πρόρριζον
852
mvp-comment-441-1
ὦ Ζεῦ
853
mvp-comment-441-2
λέγω
854
mvp-comment-442-1
τῷ νῦν λόγῳ
855
mvp-comment-443-1
δεινὸν
856
mvp-comment-443-2
πάσχοντι
857
ὧν τέκῃ
858
mvp-comment-444-1
μάτην ἄρ’ ἡμεῖς κ.τ.λ.
859
mvp-comment-445-1
μάτην λέγοις
860
mvp-comment-446-1
ψυχῆς
861
mvp-comment-447-1
μαστῶν κ.τ.λ.
862
mvp-comment-447-2
ἀποστὰς
863
mvp-comment-447-3
ἀπεξενοῦτο
864
mvp-comment-448-1
φόνους
865
mvp-comment-449-1
ὥστ’ οὔτε … στεγάζειν
866
mvp-comment-449-2
ἐξ ἡμέρας
867
mvp-comment-449-3
στεψάζειν
868
mvp-comment-449-4
ὁ προστατῶν χρόνος
869
mvp-comment-449-5
διῆγε
870
mvp-comment-449-6
783 f. The perf.
ἀπήλλαγμαι
871
mvp-comment-449-7
μείζων
872
mvp-comment-450-1
τοὐμὸν
873
mvp-comment-450-2
ἐκπίνους’
874
mvp-comment-450-3
ἄκρατον
875
mvp-comment-450-4
νῦν δ’
876
mvp-comment-450-5
ἕκηλα
877
mvp-comment-450-6
οὕνεχ’
878
mvp-comment-450-7
ἡμερεύσομεν
879
mvp-comment-451-1
οἴμοι τάλαινα
880
mvp-comment-451-2
οἰμῶξαι
881
mvp-comment-452-1
ἆρ’ ἔχει καλῶς
882
mvp-comment-453-1
οὔτοι σὺ
883
mvp-comment-454-1
Νέμεσι
884
mvp-comment-454-2
τοῦ θανόντος ἀρτίως
885
mvp-comment-454-3
Nemesis is the goddess who requires that each man should receive his due (
Νέμεσιν ἀπὸ τῆς ἑκάστῳ διανεμήσεως
,
Mund. 7. p. 401
b. 13). The ‘Nemesis of the dead man’ is the avenger of wrong done to him; as the Greeks said
Δίκη τινός
(
Aesch.
Ag. 1432
),
Ἐρινύς τινος
. Cp. Aesch. fr. 266
ἡμῶν γε μέντοι Νέμεσις
(‘
our Nemesis’)
ἔσθ’ ὑπερτέρα
, |
καὶ τοῦ θανόντος ἡ Δίκη πράσσει κότον
. At Athens
Νεμέσεια
were certain rites in honour of the dead (
Dem. or. 41 § 11
),
ἐπεὶ ἡ Νέμεσις ἐπὶ τῶν ἀποθανόντων τέτακται
(Bekker
Anecd. I. 282). Nemesis appears in art, too, as a goddess of the dead (Baumeister,
Denkm., p. 1008).
mvp-comment-455-1
ἤκουσεν ὧν δεῖ
886
mvp-comment-455-2
κἀπεκύρωσεν
887
mvp-comment-456-1
οὔκουν … τάδε
888
mvp-comment-457-1
οὐχ ὅπως σε παύσομεν
889
mvp-comment-458-1
πολλῶν ἂν ἥκοις
890
ἔπαυσας
891
παύσαις
892
mvp-comment-458-2
πολλῶν
893
ἄξιος
894
τυχεῖν
895
mvp-comment-459-1
εὖ κυρεῖ
896
mvp-comment-459-2
800 f. With
πράξειας
897
mvp-comment-459-3
The emendations which aim at introducing
ἄν
seem, then, superfluous. The change of
καταξίως
898
πράξειας
899
mvp-comment-459-4
τοῦ πορεύς. ξένου
900
mvp-comment-460-1
τῶν φίλων
901
mvp-comment-461-1
ἆρ’ ὑμὶν
902
mvp-comment-461-2
ὧδ’
903
mvp-comment-462-1
ὥς μ’ ἀπώλεσας θανών
904
mvp-comment-463-1
ἀποσπάσας
905
αἵ
906
mvp-comment-464-1
μολεῖν
907
mvp-comment-465-1
δουλεύειν
908
mvp-comment-465-2
πάλιν
909
mvp-comment-466-1
ἆρά μοι καλῶς ἔχει
910
mvp-comment-467-1
τοῦ λοιποῦ χρόνου
911
mvp-comment-467-2
818 *
εἴσειμ’
, Hermann's correction of
ἔσσομ’
, is made certain by
ἀλλὰ τῇδε πρὸς πύλῃ
. No dative is needed to explain
ξύνοικος
912
mvp-comment-468-1
παρεῖσ’ ἐμαυτὴν
913
mvp-comment-468-2
αὐανῶ
914
mvp-comment-469-1
χάρις
915
mvp-comment-470-1
Kommos. 1st strophe, 823—835, =1st antistr., 836—848: 2nd str., 849—859, =2nd antistr., 860—870. For metres see Metrical Analysis. Changes of person occur within a verse (as in 829 ff.,
ΗΛ. φεῦ. ΧΟ. μηδὲν μέγ’ ἀΰσῃς. ΗΛ. ἀπολεῖς. ΧΟ. πῶς
; ). This indicates that the Chorus is here represented by the coryphaeus; it is, in fact, a lyric duet between the leader and Electra. Similar duets occur in
O. T. 649
—697 and
O. C. 510
—548, passages which further resemble this as being
κομμοί
inserted in
ἐπεισόδια
: also in the parodos of the
O. C.(as at 178 ff.), and its exodos (as at 1677 ff.): and in
Ph. 1081
—1217 (as at 1184 f.).
mvp-comment-470-2
These lyrics mark the climax of Electra's grief. The comforter vainly seeks to rouse her from despair.
mvp-comment-470-3
ποῦ ποτε
916
mvp-comment-470-4
φαέθων
917
mvp-comment-470-5
ἐφορῶντες
918
mvp-comment-470-6
κρύπτουσιν
919
mvp-comment-471-1
τί δακρύεις
920
mvp-comment-472-1
μηδὲν μέγ’ ἀΰσῃς
921
mvp-comment-472-2
ἀΰσῃς
922
mvp-comment-473-1
ἀπολεῖς
923
mvp-comment-474-1
τῶν … οἰχομένων
924
φανερῶς
925
ἐλπίδα
926
mvp-comment-475-1
κατ’ ἐμοῦ τακομένας
927
ἐπεμβάσει
928
κατ’ ἐμοὶ τακομένᾳ
929
mvp-comment-476-1
οἶδα γὰρ
930
mvp-comment-476-2
Ἀμφιάρεων
931
ἄνακτα
932
mvp-comment-477-1
χρυσοδέτοις ἕρκεσι
933
γυναικῶν
934
mvp-comment-477-2
κρυφθέντα
935
mvp-comment-477-3
Some vase-paintings, representing the departure of Amphiaraüs for Thebes, show Eriphylè carrying the bribe in her hand. In one of these, on a very ancient vase from Caere, it appears as a necklace of large white pearls (Baumeister,
Denkm. p. 67): in another, on a lekythos from Cervetri (Roscher,
Lex.p. 295), it is a collar, with projecting rays.
mvp-comment-478-1
ἒ ἔ· ἰώ
936
mvp-comment-479-1
πάμψυχος
937
mvp-comment-479-2
The cult of Amphiaraüs had its chief seat in Boeotia, but afterwards spread thence to Argos, and throughout Greece. He was a chthonian deity, like Melampus; associated with Dionysus, and then with the Apollinar
μαντική
. The
Ἀμφιάρειον
near Thebes, a dream-oracle, was consulted by Mardonius (
Her. 8. 134
). In later times the shrine near Oropus was more famous ( I.
Paus. 34. 2
).
mvp-comment-480-1
φεῦ
938
mvp-comment-480-2
φεῦ δῆτ’
939
ὀλοὰ γὰρ
940
ἐδάμη
941
ὀλοὰ
942
mvp-comment-480-3
ἐδάμη
943
ναί
944
mvp-comment-481-1
μελέτωρ
945
mvp-comment-481-2
Amphiaraüs was avenged by his son Alcmaeon ,—the counterpart, in this story, of Orestes. Before setting out for Thebes, the seer had charged him with this duty. Eriphylè, bribed once more, prevailed upon her son to lead the Epigoni against Thebes. After its fall, he returned to Argos, and slew her. Pursued by the Erinyes, he fled to Psophis in Arcadia, and there was purified. He was the subject of a play by Sophocles, and of two by Euripides,—the first,
ὁ διὰ Ψωφῖδος
(produced in 438 B.C.), dealing with his absolution, and the second,
ὁ διὰ Κορίνθου
, with a later episode. Acc. to a grammarian in
Anecd. Oxon. II. p. 337, 4, the form of the name used by Eur. was
Ἀλκμέων
.
mvp-comment-482-1
τὸν ἐν πένθει
946
mvp-comment-483-1
ἀναρπασθείς
947
mvp-comment-484-1
δειλαία δειλαίων
948
mvp-comment-485-1
ἴστωρ
949
mvp-comment-486-1
πανσύρτῳ … αἰῶνι
950
αἰῶνι
951
mvp-comment-486-2
The literal sense then is:—‘(I know this) by a life which, through all the months, is a turbid torrent of many things dread and horrible.’
πανσύρτῳ
seems rightly explained in one scholium as
πάντα σύροντι τὰ κακά
:
i.e., it has an active sense, like
χαλκόπλακτος
(484 n.),
ἀμφίπλακτος
(
Ph. 688
),
πανάλωτος
(
ἄτη
,
Aesch.
Ag. 361
). The genitive,
πολλῶν δεινῶν στυγνῶν τ’
, may depend upon it, as in
Soph.
Ant. 1184
f.
θεᾶς..προσήγορος
=
θεὰν προσηγοροῦσα
. But we might also join the genitive with
αἰῶνι
, as=‘a life
of’ (made up of) these things. For the verb
σύρω
in ref. to a torrent, cp.
Ar.
Eq. 527
διὰ τῶν ἀφελῶν πεδίων ἔρρει, καὶ τῆς στάσεως παρασύρων
|
ἐφόρει τὰς δρῦς
: Plut.
Mor.p. 5 F
πόλεμος χειμάρρου δίκην πάντα σύρων
. Thus
παμμήνῳ
952
mvp-comment-486-3
This view gives
πανσύρτῳ
a more forcible and more poetical sense than if it be taken as=‘swept together from every side.’ The meaning then would be, ‘a life, through all the months, of many dread horrors,
accumulated from every quarter,’—the epithet
πανσύρτῳ
being transferred from the troubles to the life itself. It would still, indeed, be possible to make
πανσύρτῳ
active; ‘a life which draws troubles together from all sides’; but such an active sense would be somewhat harsher, on this interpretation, than on that which supposes the image of a torrent.
mvp-comment-487-1
ἁθρήνεις
953
ἃ θροεῖς
954
ἃ θρηνεῖς
955
mvp-comment-488-1
μή μέ νυν
956
mvp-comment-488-2
παραγάγῃς
957
mvp-comment-488-3
ἵν’
958
mvp-comment-489-1
τί φής
959
mvp-comment-490-1
πάρεισιν ἐλπίδων ἔτι
960
mvp-comment-490-2
With the other reading,
εὐπατρίδων τ’
, both epithets belong to
ἐλπίδων
, and
ἐλπίδες κοινότοκοι εὐπάτριδές τε
mean, ‘hopes from brothers and princes,’—
i.e., ‘hopes from a princely brother’: the sense is unchanged, but the phrase is more artificial.
mvp-comment-490-3
That the MSS. have
εὐπατριδᾶν
is more significant than that they also have
τ’
, which might easily creep in. Suidas, who omits
τ’
, has
εὐπατριδᾶν
, or (in codd. A and C)
εὐπατριδῶν
: but the latter variant can hardly be said to confirm
εὐπατρίδων τ’
.—At 162 Orestes is called
εὐπατρίδαν
. The fem.
εὔπατρις
occurs at 1081.