1051–1200
Electra. Lewis Campbell. ed. Lewis Campbell. Oxford. 1879.
Electra. Lewis Campbell. ed. Lewis Campbell. Oxford. 1879.
Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879) (OCR draft) (English) (Commentary (Lewis Campbell, 1879))
Provisional text from uncorrected OCR; expect errors.
mvp-comment-593-1 τολμᾷς 1
mvp-comment-594-1 οὔ σοι μὴ μεθέψομαι 2
mvp-comment-595-1 καὶ τὸ θηρᾶσθαι κενά 3 καὶ 4
mvp-comment-595-2 κενά 5
mvp-comment-596-1 ὅταν γὰρ 6
mvp-comment-596-2 βεβήκῃς 7
mvp-comment-597-1 ἄνωθεν 8
mvp-comment-597-2 οἰωνοὺς 9
mvp-comment-598-1 ἐσορώμενοι 10 ἀφ’ ὧν 11
mvp-comment-599-1 εὕρωσι 12
mvp-comment-599-2 ἐπ’ ἴσας 13
mvp-comment-600-1 ἀλλ’ οὐ τὰν 14
mvp-comment-601-1 τὰν οὐρανίαν Θέμιν 15
mvp-comment-602-1 ἀπόνητοι 16
mvp-comment-603-1 χθονία 17 βροτοῖσι 18
mvp-comment-603-2 φάμα 19
mvp-comment-603-3 Some write Φάμα 20
mvp-comment-604-1 κατά … βόασον 21
mvp-comment-604-2 μοι 22
mvp-comment-605-1 Ἀτρείδαις 23
mvp-comment-605-2 ἀχόρευτα 24 ὀνείδη 25
mvp-comment-606-1 νοσεῖ 26 δή 27
mvp-comment-607-1 τὰ δὲ πρὸς τέκνων 28
mvp-comment-607-2 διπλῆ φύλοπις 29
mvp-comment-607-3 οὐκέτ’ ἐξισοῦται 30 φιλοτασίῳ διαίτᾳ 31
mvp-comment-607-4
It is also possible, though (I think) less natural, to take the dat.
mvp-comment-608-1 σαλεύει 32
mvp-comment-609-1 Ἠλέκτρα, †τὸν ἀεὶ πατρὸς 33
mvp-comment-609-2 Hence it is now generally held that this verse is corrupt. But no certain correction has yet been proposed. The word ἀεὶ 34 πατρὸς 35
mvp-comment-609-3 Far the best conjecture is Heath's, ἁ παῖς, οἶτον ἀεὶ πατρὸς 36
mvp-comment-610-1 πάνδυρτος 37
mvp-comment-611-1 οὔτε … τε 38
mvp-comment-611-2 τὸ … μὴ βλέπειν 39
mvp-comment-612-1 διδύμαν … Ἐρινύν 40
mvp-comment-613-1 τίς ἂν εὔπατρις 41
mvp-comment-614-1 οὐδεὶς τῶν ἀγαθῶν <γὰρ> 42 τῶν ἀγαθῶν 43
mvp-comment-615-1 ζῶν κακῶς 44
mvp-comment-615-2 νώνυμος 45
mvp-comment-616-1 πάγκλαυτον αἰῶνα κοινὸν 46
mvp-comment-616-2 εἵλου 47
mvp-comment-617-1 τὸ μὴ καλὸν καθοπλίσασα 48 ἀπολακτίσασα 49
mvp-comment-617-2 If καθοπλίσασα 50
mvp-comment-617-3
(1) ‘Having vanquished dishonour’ (schol.
mvp-comment-617-4 (2) ‘Having made ready an unlovely deed’: i.e., the vengeance on the murderers.—See Appendix.
mvp-comment-618-1 φέρειν 51
mvp-comment-618-2 ἐν ἑνὶ λόγῳ 52
mvp-comment-619-1 καθύπερθεν 53
mvp-comment-619-2 τεῶν 54 τῶν 55 τοσόνδ’ 56
mvp-comment-620-1 ὑπόχειρ 57
mvp-comment-621-1 μοίρᾳ … οὐκ ἐν ἐσθλᾷ βεβῶσαν 58
mvp-comment-622-1 μέγιστα … νόμιμα 59
mvp-comment-622-2 ἔβλαστε 60
mvp-comment-622-3 τῶνδε φερομέναν ἄριστα 61 τῶνδε 62
mvp-comment-622-4
I formerly understood:—‘in respect to these laws, prospering full well’:
mvp-comment-623-1 τᾷ Ζηνὸς εὐσεβείᾳ 63 Διὸς 64 Ζηνὸς 65
mvp-comment-624-1 εἰσηκούσαμεν 66
mvp-comment-624-2 ὀρθῶς θ’ 67 δ’ 68 θ’ 69 τε 70 δέ 71
mvp-comment-624-3 ἔνθα 72
mvp-comment-625-1 Αἴγισθον 73 ᾤκηκεν 74
mvp-comment-626-1 ἀλλ’ 75
mvp-comment-626-2 χὡ φράσας 76
mvp-comment-626-3 ἀζήμιος 77
mvp-comment-627-1 τίς … φράσειεν ἄν 78
mvp-comment-627-2 ποθεινὴν 79
mvp-comment-627-3 κοινόπουν 80
mvp-comment-628-1 τὸν ἄγχιστον 81
mvp-comment-629-1 ἴθ’, ὦ γύναι 82
mvp-comment-630-1 οὐ δή ποθ’ 83
mvp-comment-631-1 τὴν σὴν κληδόν’ 84
mvp-comment-631-2 Στρόφιος 85
mvp-comment-632-1 φέροντες 86 κομίζομεν 87
mvp-comment-633-1 τοῦτ’ ἐκεῖν’ 88
mvp-comment-633-2 πρόχειρον 89
mvp-comment-633-3 ἄχθος 90
mvp-comment-634-1 κέκευθεν 91
mvp-comment-634-2
1122 Cp.
Aesch.
P. V. 637
mvp-comment-635-1 δότε 92 ἥτις ἐστί 93
mvp-comment-635-2 ἐπαιτεῖται 94
mvp-comment-635-3 πρὸς αἵματος 95
mvp-comment-635-4 φύσιν 96
mvp-comment-636-1 ψυχῆς Ὀρέστου λοιπόν 97
mvp-comment-636-2 ἀπ’ ἐλπίδων 98
mvp-comment-636-3 Then οὐχ ὧνπερ 99
mvp-comment-636-4
Other possibilities are the following. (1) Keeping both
mvp-comment-636-5
(2) Still keeping
mvp-comment-636-6
(3) Keeping
mvp-comment-636-7
On the whole, I retain the traditional reading, though not without a suspicion that either
mvp-comment-637-1 νῦν μὲν γὰρ 102
mvp-comment-637-2 οὐδὲν ὄντα 103
mvp-comment-637-3 βαστάζω 104
mvp-comment-637-4 λαμπρὸν 105
mvp-comment-638-1 ὡς ὤφελον 106
mvp-comment-638-2 The v.l. ὤφελες 107 κλέψασα 108
mvp-comment-638-3 τοῖνδε 109
mvp-comment-638-4 κἀνασώσασθαι 110
mvp-comment-638-5 φόνου 111
mvp-comment-639-1 ὅπως … ἔκεισο 112
mvp-comment-639-2 τύμβου πατρῴου 113
mvp-comment-640-1 φυγὰς 114
mvp-comment-641-1 ἐν 115
mvp-comment-641-2 φίλαισι 116
mvp-comment-642-1 λουτροῖς σ’ ἐκόσμης’ 117
mvp-comment-643-1 ἄθλιον βάρος 118
mvp-comment-644-1 ἐν ξέναισι χερσὶ κηδευθεὶς 119
mvp-comment-644-2 σμικρὸς … ὄγκος 120
mvp-comment-645-1 τῆς ἐμῆς … τρ. ἀνωφελήτου 121
mvp-comment-645-2 παρέσχον 122
mvp-comment-646-1 ἢ κἀμοῦ 123
mvp-comment-646-2 μητρὸς … φίλος 124
mvp-comment-646-3
The schol. on 1146 has,
mvp-comment-647-1 οἱ κατ’ οἶκον 125 ἦσαν 126
mvp-comment-647-2 ἀλλ’ ἐγὼ τροφός 127
mvp-comment-648-1 ἀδελφὴ σοὶ 128
mvp-comment-648-2 προσηυδώμην 129
mvp-comment-649-1 ἐκλέλοιπε 130
mvp-comment-649-2 θανόντι 131
mvp-comment-649-3 συναρπάσας 132
mvp-comment-649-4 θύελλ’ 133
mvp-comment-650-1 τέθνηκ’ ἐγὼ σοί 134 σοί 135 τέθνηκ’ ἐγώ σοι 136
mvp-comment-650-2
Others explain: (1) ‘I am dead
because of thee’; ‘thou hast been the death of me.’ The dat. is then like that in
Ai. 1128
mvp-comment-651-1 μήτηρ ἀμήτωρ 138
mvp-comment-651-2 ἧς 139
mvp-comment-651-3 1160—
mvp-comment-652-1 οἴμοι μοί 140
mvp-comment-653-1 κελεύθους 141
mvp-comment-653-2 ἀπώλεσας 142
mvp-comment-653-3 δῆτ’ 143
mvp-comment-654-1 τοιγὰρ σὺ δέξαι μ’ 144
mvp-comment-654-2 τὴν μηδὲν 145
mvp-comment-654-3 τὸ μηδὲν 146
mvp-comment-655-1 μετεῖχον τῶν ἴσων 147
mvp-comment-655-2 μὴ ἀπολείπεσθαι 148
mvp-comment-656-1 τοὺς 149 θανόντας 150
mvp-comment-657-1 θνητοῦ 151 θνητὸς 152
mvp-comment-657-2 φρόνει 153
mvp-comment-658-1 πᾶσιν γὰρ ἡμῖν 154 τοῦτ’ 155
mvp-comment-659-1 φεῦ φεῦ, τί λέξω 156
mvp-comment-659-2 λόγων 157 ποῖ 158 ἀμηχανῶν 159
mvp-comment-660-1 It is well to observe the delicately gradual process which leads up to the recognition.
mvp-comment-660-2 (i) 1176—1187. She is surprised that her woes should affect the stranger, and he hints that they are his own. (ii) 1188 —1198. She is thus led to speak more in detail of her sorrows, and of her despair,—caused by her brother's death. (iii) 1199—1204. He once more expresses his pity,—and this time in words which cause her to ask whether he can be a kinsman. He does not give a direct answer, but inquires whether the Chorus are friendly, and is assured that they are so.
mvp-comment-660-3 The preparation is now complete: the actual disclosure follows. (i) 1205— 1210. He asks her to give him the urn which is in her hands: she entreats that she may be allowed to keep it, and to pay it the last honours. (ii) 1211—1217. He tells her that she ought not to mourn for her brother. ‘Why,’ she asks: ‘if these are his ashes?’ ‘They are not so,’ he replies,—taking the urn from her hands. (iii) 1218—1221. ‘Where, then,’ she asks, ‘is his grave?’ ‘The living have no grave.’ ‘He lives?’ ‘Yes,—as surely as I live.’
mvp-comment-660-4 ἔσχες ἄλγος 160
mvp-comment-661-1 κλεινὸν 161
mvp-comment-662-1 Bergk has an ingenious (though, I think, mistaken) theory concerning this passage. Seeing that v. 1180 resembles v. 1184, he suggests that 1180 was an inferior variant for 1184: and, on similar grounds, that 1183 was a feebler substitute for 1179. That is, there were two different texts of this passage. ( a) In one of them, the better, verses 1180 and 1183 were absent, and the rest stood in this order, 1178, 1181, 1182, 1179, 1184. ( b) In the other, verses 1179 and 1184 were absent, and the rest stood in this order, 1178, 1181, 1182, 1183, 1180. The present text arose from an attempt to harmonise the other two.
mvp-comment-662-2 We have only to read the dialogue with attention to perceive that this hypothesis of variants is arbitrary. Verse 1183 expresses sympathy in a more definite and emphatic manner than v. 1179: verse 1184 expresses surprise more directly and decidedly than v. 1180. There is a gradual accentuation of the stranger's interest and of Electra's perplexity. This development is the internal proof that our text has not arisen from a dittographia.
mvp-comment-662-3 καὶ μάλ’ 162
mvp-comment-663-1 ταλαίνης 163 συμφορᾶς 164
mvp-comment-664-1 οὐ 165
mvp-comment-665-1 ἀτίμως 166 κἀθέως 167
mvp-comment-666-1 ἢ )μὲ 168
mvp-comment-666-2 δυσφημεῖς 169 ἄλλην 170 ξένε 171
mvp-comment-667-1 ἀνύμφου 172
mvp-comment-667-2 τροφῆς 173
mvp-comment-668-1 τί δή ποτ’ 174 μοι 175 ἐπισκοπῶν 176 τί 177
mvp-comment-669-1 ἐν τῷ … τῶν εἰρημένων 178
mvp-comment-670-1 ὁρῶν σὲ 179 σὲ 180 σε 181 τῶν ἐμῶν 182 σέ 183
mvp-comment-670-2 ἐμπρέπουσαν 184
mvp-comment-671-1 πόθεν 185
mvp-comment-672-1 εἶτα 186
mvp-comment-672-2 δουλεύω 187
mvp-comment-673-1 ἀνάγκῃ … προτρέπει 188
mvp-comment-674-1 ἐξισοῖ 189
mvp-comment-675-1 χερσὶν 190 λύμη βίου 191
mvp-comment-676-1 οὑπαρήξων 192
mvp-comment-677-1 προὔθηκας 193
1053. mvp-comment-502-1 Cp. Ant. 69, 70, οὔτ᾽ ἄν, εἰ θέλοις ἔτι | πράσσειν, ἐμοῦ γ᾽ ἂν ἡδέως δρῴης μέτα.
1054. mvp-comment-503-1 θηρᾶσθαι κενά] ‘Το seek for what is vain,' as the sympathy of Chrysothemis has proved itself to be.
1058-1097. mvp-comment-504-1 The Chorus lament, for Agamemnon's sake, over the quarrel between his daughters, which is added to the other troubles of his house, including the supposed death of Orestes, and express their admiration of Electra's attitude. Addressing her in the second strophe, they encourage her with words of sympathy and commendation. While Orestes lived, they bade her hope and trust. Now that they believe him to be dead, they are carried away by the heroism of her despair. That Electra remains upon the stage appears from infr. 1105.
1058-1065. mvp-comment-505-1 Agamemnon is forgotten by his daughter Chrysothemis, and by others who owed him gratitude. In this the human race shows itself inferior to the prudent stork. But though men forget, the gods remember, and will soon exact the penalty.
1058. mvp-comment-506-1 φρονιμωτάτους] Cp. esp. Plat. Polit. 263 D, οἷον δοκεῖ τὸ τῶν γεράνων, where, in a similar spirit of bitterness, the stork is again preferred to man. The expression (οιωνούς) is generalized, as elsewhere in Sophocles.
1059-1060. mvp-comment-507-1 τροφᾶς.. εὕρωσι] ‘Caring in respect of nurture for those from whom they are sprung, and from whom they have experienced good.' For the double genitive, cp. Trach. 108, ἀνδρὸς δεῖμα φέρουσαν ὁδοῦ, and for the subjunctive, cp. supr. 771, μίσος ὧν τέκῃ.
1060. mvp-comment-508-1 τάδ᾽ οὐκ ἐπ᾽ ἴσας τελοῦμεν] 'Do we not equally fulfil this duty?' For the adverbial expression (ἐπ᾽ ἴσας, sc. μοίρας), cp. Trach. 727, ἐξ ἑκουσίας.
1061. mvp-comment-509-1 ἀλλ᾽ οὐ *τάν] For the omission of μά, which the MSS. insert against the metre, cp. Ant. 758, ἀλλ᾿ οὐ, τόνδ' Ὄλυμπον : infr. 1239.
1064. mvp-comment-510-1 οὐρανίαν] Cp. Ο. Τ. 865-7, νόμοι . . οὐρανίαν | δι' αἰθέρα τεκνωθέντες.
1065. mvp-comment-511-1 δαρὸν οὐκ ἀπόνητοι] Sc. οὐ τελοῦμεν ταῦτα. The subject is ἡμεῖς, i.e. οἱ ἄνθρωποι, but the sentence, although general in form, is pointed at
1065-1066. mvp-comment-512-1 those who take part with Aegisthus. (In failing thus) 'we do not long escape from trouble.' For the passive form in ἀπόνητοι, see Essay on L. § 31. pp. 53. 4, § 53. p. 98 a, and cp. esp. Trach. 102, ποθουμένᾳ, and note.
1066. mvp-comment-513-1 ὦ χθονία.. φάμα] Ο human voice that piercest underground!' βροτοῖσι is really equivalent to a genitive, depending on the verbal notion in φάμα. More literally, Rumour on the part of mortals.' The language presupposes a communion of the living and the dead, so that the power of Rumour about things on earth is believed to extend to the world below.
1067. mvp-comment-514-1 οἰκτρὰν ὅπα] 'With lamentable sound.' ὅπα is cogn. acc. Compare with ll. 1066-8, Aesch. Pers. 639 foll. ἀχόρευτα φέρουσ᾽ ὀνείδη] · With saddening reproachful news.'
1070. mvp-comment-515-1 Various corrections of νοσεῖ have been attempted, of which Wecklein's ὀνοστά is the most ingenious. Others are νοσεῖ δή, νοσεῖται, νοσεύει, to which one more may be added, νοσώδη. The point especially indicated in this line is the supposed death of Orestes, which leaves the house of Agamemnon apparently without hope of healing or purgation.
1071-1072. mvp-comment-516-1 τὰ δὲ πρὸς τέκνων . . διαίτᾳ] (1) Most editors agree in understanding this to mean, 'While between his two children a quarrel has arisen that puts an end to the harmony of loving intercourse.' But (a) would Sophocles put φύλοπις for a private quarrel? Or (b) can φ. οὐκέτ᾽ ἐξισοῦται be construed so as to mean νείκει διίστανται? Another interpretation seems possible, if we may suppose the Chorus to have been carried away by the visionary hopes of Electra. Then (2) διπλή φύλοπις might be taken to mean the 'two-fold war-cry,' i.e. the combination of the two sisters for hostile purposes, which had seemed possible, supr. 448-71 (note esp. ll. 453-6), and which Electra had depicted in such glowing colours in supr. 967-89. This combination 'is no longer evenly maintained in concord,' since Chrysothemis has renounced her part in it. Or (3) φύλοπις may have lost its hostile association and be used etymologically (Essay on L. $ 54. p. 100 d) for 'the combined voice of the family' as a symbol of fraternal concord. The two sisters no longer 'speak the same thing.' This explanation may be further modified by taking διπλῆ τo mean 'divided.' 'The voices of their children are disparted and no longer harmoniously sustained in a life of affection.'
1072. mvp-comment-517-1 σαλεύει] 'Endures the storm.' Essay on L. § 58. p. 105.
1075-1076. mvp-comment-518-1 τὸν ἀεὶ .. στενάχουσ] Everlastingly mourning for her sire (πατρός, gen. of cause), unhappy maiden.' τὸν ἀεί, sc. χρόνον. Cp. Ο. C. 1584, 1701, and notes. If this 'idiotism' is rejected, it is necessary to have recourse to conjecture here, as well as to a forced explanation of the passages in the Oedipus Coloneus. Schndw. conjectures Ηλέκτρα πότμον ἀεὶ πατρός (retaining μá in the strophe): and this is adopted by Wecklein. Paley, Ἠλ. τὸν ἀεὶ πότμον (‘The irrevocable fate of death'). Dind., τὸν ἑὸν πότμον.
1077. mvp-comment-519-1 For the correction, *πάνδυρτος for πανόδυρτος, cp. Ο. Τ. 1219, *δύρομαι
1077-1080. mvp-comment-520-1 (MSS. ὀδύρομαι). And for the sense, cp. supr. 148 foll.
1078-1080. mvp-comment-521-1 οὔτε. Ἐρινύν] ‘Not avoiding death, but willing to die, if she may but destroy the twofold Evil Power.' Cp. supr. 399, 956, 7. Electra has only spoken of killing Aegisthus. But see note on supr. 987 foll. There is here a reminiscence of Aesch. Cho. 438, ἔπειτ' ἐγὼ νοσφίσας ὀλοίμαν.
1081. mvp-comment-522-1 τίς ἂν.. βλάστοι] When shall one' (i. e. another) arise, so worthy of a noble sire?'-i. e. Noble at once in birth and nature. Cp. Ant. 38, εἴτ᾿ εὐγενὴς πέφυκας, εἴτ᾿ ἐσθλῶν κακή. And see the strained use of the same word in supr. 858 (ἐλπίδων) εὐπατρίδων.
1082-1086. mvp-comment-523-1 οὐδεὶς.. εἵλου] (1) According to Hermann's explanation of these lines, they state with greater calmness the reason of Electra's action, for which the preceding words express unbounded admiration. It would be hard to find a parallel for Electra's conduct, and yet it is that which every noble mind would choose. The truth is (γάρ), no one of noble strain is willing to live on in misery, degradation, and oblivion. Even so thou, O my daughter, didst choose the lot which all men share and all lament' (viz. death), 'so as, arming' (against thyself acc. to Herm. acc. to Schol. 'subduing'-) 'the power of wrong, to win a twofold renown, in being celebrated for wisdom as well as for the highest filial duty.' Cp. Trach. 721, 2, ζῆν γὰρ κακῶς κλύουσαν οὐκ ἀνασχετόν, | ἥτις προτιμᾷ μὴ κακὴ πεφυκέναι : Αj. 479, 80, ἀλλ᾿ ἡ καλῶς ζῆν ἢ καλῶς τεθνηκέναι τὸν εὐγενῆ χρή. Two points in this interpretation admit of doubt, the use of αἰῶνα for the state of the dead, and the meaning given to καθοπλίσασα. For the former, cp. O. С. 1551, 2, τὸν τελευταῖον βίον κρύψων ἐς "Αιδην, and note. Hermann's explanation of καθοπλίσασα, sc. κατὰ σεαυτοῦ, was an expedient which he adopted in order to avoid that of the Scholiast, καταπολεμήσασα καὶ νικήσασα, which appeared impossible. Either (2) the Scholiast should be followed in spite of analogy, or there is some corruption. Herm. doubtfully suggested καθιππάσασα. Other conjectures are καθυπνίσασα, καταπτύσασα. Qy. καθαγνίσασα (?), i.e. ' purging away as if by fire;' cp. supr. 70, δίκῃ καθαρτὴς πρὸς θεῶν ὡρμημένος : Eur. Or. 39, 40. ἐξ ὅτου σφαγαῖς θανοῦσα μήτηρ πυρὶ καθήγνισται δέμας, According to another line of interpretation (3), the connection is to this effect :- Electra is peerless, for none amongst the nobly-born are found to allow their glory to be soiled in a life of misery, as Electra does, choosing to share the common lot of affliction, if only she may subdue the criminals, etc. But εὔκλεια cannot =ἀγλαΐα ( supr. 211), and although the sentiment that the greater number of mankind are born to trouble is not un-Greek, it is hardly Sophoclean or appropriate here. Others would read κλεινὸν for κοινόν.
1089. mvp-comment-524-1 σοφά τ᾿ ἀρίστα τε] 'Wise, as well as bravest,' or 'best, Wise, i. e. because holding fast the higher law. Cp. l. 1094.
1089. mvp-comment-524-2 Enter Orestes and Pylades, with attendants, as the ἄνδρες Φωκέων τεταγμένοι of supr. 759. The urn is carried, not by Orestes as might be expected from supr. 54. but by one of the attendants ( infr. 1123).
1090. mvp-comment-525-1 'Mayest thou live, I pray, as far superior to thy foes in wealth and might as now thou art fallen beneath them!' Cp. Hdt. 8. 60, τῶν ἐχθρῶν κατύπερθε γενέσθαι: ΙΙ. 16. 722.
1091. mvp-comment-526-1 *τεῶν is Hermann's correction of τῶν. Others (Lange, Wecklein) read τοσόνδ'.
1093. mvp-comment-527-1 ὑπὸ †χεῖρα] Hermann's conjecture, ὑπόχειρ (cp. ἐπίχειρ), has been received by subsequent editors. But, although it gives regularity to the metre, the word is not found elsewhere, and ὑπὸ χεῖρα appears idiomatic. Hermann himself (1839) read ὑπὸ χέρα.
1094-1095. mvp-comment-528-1 μοίρᾳ . . βεβῶσαν] Not placed in happy fortune.' Cр. О. С. 1358, 59, ὅτ᾽ ἐν πόνῳ | ταὐτῷ βεβηκὼς τυγχάνεις κακῶν ἐμοί.
1095-1097. mvp-comment-529-1 ἃ δὲ μέγιστ᾽ ἔβλαστε.. εὐσεβεία] Either (1) But prospering most highly, through Zeus-loved piety, in respect of those laws that are mightiest in their origin,' or (2) But endowed with the noblest gifts from those laws which are of mightiest origin, because of thy piety to Zeus.' For μέγιστ' ἔβλαστε, ср. О. Т. 865-72, Ant. 454-7. For the genitive τῶνδε in (2), see Essay on L. § 10. p. 14 b. And for τᾷ Ζηνὸς εὐσεβείᾳ in (1), cp. Phil. 1442, 3, ὡς τἄλλα πάντα δεύτερ᾽ ἡγεῖται πατὴρ | Ζεύς· ἡ γὰρ εὐσέβεια συνθνήσκει βροτοῖς. Wecklein reads ἄριστον αἶνον δι' εὐσέβειαν, Nauck, ἄριστα τὰν σὰν δι᾽ εὐσέβειαν.
1101. mvp-comment-530-1 ᾤκηκεν] Hath his abode.' The perfect tense ironically suggests the supposed permanence of Aegisthus' rule.
1104. mvp-comment-531-1 ποθεινήν] ‘Wishful, i. e. with desire to see them. It is a courteous phrase, for which cp. Shak. Mids. N. D. 1. 1, 'With duty and desire we follow you,'-but may have suggested to the spectators Orestes longing for his home and Electra's longing for him. For the active use of ποθεινός, cp. Eur. Phoen. 1737, ποθεινὰ δάκρυα.
1105. mvp-comment-532-1 τὸν ἄγχιστον] 'Nearest,' i.e. as daughter to the Queen. But the word is calculated to move Orestes, to whom Electra is indeed nearest. The masculine gives generality. Cp. supr. 1026, and note.
1110. mvp-comment-533-1 οὐκ οἶδα .. κληδόν] ‘I know not what report you speak of.' Orestes must seem ignorant of the coming of the Paedagogus, who professed to have been sent by Phanoteus, and had therefore nothing to do with Strophius, from whom Orestes is supposed to come. The evidence appears to flow through two channels, which are independent of each other.
1115. mvp-comment-534-1 Some editors punctuate after ἐκεῖνο, some do not punctuate at all between τοῦτ᾽ .. ἄχθος. The pause at σαφές seems on the whole most probable. Ah! here is that we heard of now made clear. I see the burden ready (as it would seem) to my hand.'
1116. mvp-comment-535-1 πρόχειρον may either mean (1) 'Before my hand,' i. e. ready to be taken up; or (2) Held in the hand' of another.'
1117. mvp-comment-536-1 τι .. τῶν Ὀρεστείων κακῶν] The litotes suggests not only his death, but the ruin of his house. Cp. ll. 1121, 2.
1123-1124. mvp-comment-537-1 οὐ γὰρ οὐσ'] The form of expression may be simply occasioned by antithesis. But friends of Strophius might have reason to suspect those about Aegisthus of being unfriendly to Orestes.
1125. mvp-comment-538-1 ἢ.. φύσιν] ‘Or of his natural kin.' For πρὸς αἵματος, cp. Aj. 1305, τοὺς πρὸς αἵματος, and for φύσιν, see Essay on L. § 17. p. 25. 4, and cp. supr. 325-
1126-1128. mvp-comment-539-1 O sole memorial and relic of the living Orestes, dearest of mankind to me, how far otherwise than I had hoped do I receive thee! with thoughts how different from those with which I sent thee forth!" By a confusion to which double negatives are liable (Essay on L. § 29. p. 49), the negative implied in ἀπό is first expanded in a negative sense, and then ἀπό is resumed with ὧνπερ in a different (positive) sense. For a negative similarly ignored in the relative clause, cp. Ant. 1064-7, κάτισθι, μὴ πολλοὺς .. τελῶν | ἐν οἷσι, κ.τ.λ. Wecklein in l. 1128 reads οὐχ ὅνπερ with an inferior MS. • How contrary to my hopes I receive- not him whom I sent forth.'
1130. mvp-comment-540-1 λαμπρόν] 'Bright,' i.e. full of promise. Cp. supr. 685, εἰσῆλθε λαμπρός. ἐγώ has a pathetic, not a logical emphasis, and reminds the spectator that Electra's action at the critical moment was the saving of her father's house. Cp. supr. 12.
1131. mvp-comment-541-1 The v. r. ὡς ὤφελες (suggested by 1134) is far inferior to ὡς ὤφελον. The struggle of the intervening years now seems worse than yain.
1139-1140. mvp-comment-542-1 οὔτε .. βάρος] ‘Nor took up, as I should have done, from the all-consuming fire, the miserable remains.' See E. on L. § 8. p. 11. For βάρος, cp. Aesch. Ag. 442, βαρὺ ψήγμα, παμφλέκτου suggests that the fire has done its utmost. Cp. Od. 11. 220, 1, ἀλλὰ τὰ μέν τε πυρὸς κρατερὸν μένος αἰθομένοιο | δαμνᾷ, ἐπεί κε πρῶτα λίπῃ λεύκ᾿ ὄστεα θυμός. See Essay on L. $ 53. p. 98.
1143. mvp-comment-543-1 She now goes back in memory to the happier time before the death of Agamemnon.
1143-1144. mvp-comment-544-1 τῆς ἐμῆς ἀνωφελήτου] 'The care which of old I spent on thee-in vain!' τροφή is active here, as in Eur. Tro. 1187, αἵ τ᾿ ἐμαὶ τροφαί.
1145-1146. mvp-comment-545-1 οὔτε . . φίλος] ‘For never wast thou bound to thy mother by such close ties as thou wast to me.' φίλος implies reciprocal affection. Clytemnestra was already alienated from Agamemnon's offspring in those early days. καί marks the stress on ἐμοῦ. Cp. Ο.Τ. 94, ἢ καὶ τῆς ἐμῆς, κ.τ.λ.
1147. mvp-comment-546-1 And I was more thy nurse than the domestics were.' A natural picture of the fondness of an elder sister for a little brother.
1148. mvp-comment-547-1 (1) 'And thou didst ever call me "sister."" Or (2) And the sister of Orestes was the name by which I was ever called,' ie. I was the one sister who was specially connected with thee. At this word, as Wecklein observes, all doubt is removed from the mind of Orestes.
1152. mvp-comment-548-1 τέθνηκ᾽ ἐγώ σοι] 'I am dead because of thee,' or 'Thou hast been the death of me.' Cp. supr. 808, ὥς μ' ἀπώλεσας θανών: Eur. Androm. 334, τέθνηκα τῇ σῇ θυγατρὶ καί μ᾿ ἀπώλεσε. E. on L. § 13. p. 20.
1154-1156. mvp-comment-549-1 ἧς is governed first by φήμας, = περὶ ἧς, and is then placed in a more definite construction with τιμωρός. Essay on L. § 9. p. 13. 3.
1158. mvp-comment-550-1 προϋπεμψεν] The same word (l. 1155) is repeated in a different connection. See Essay on L. § 44. pp. 83, 84.
1159. mvp-comment-551-1 καὶ σκιὰν ἀνωφελῆ] 'And a vain shadow of thee;' i. e. the remembrance of him revived by the sight of the urn, an imagination which brought no help with it.
1160-1162. mvp-comment-552-1 For this short lyric (anapaestic) outburst, cp. especially Trach. 1085, 6, ὦναξ ᾿Αίδη, κ.τ.λ.
1161. mvp-comment-553-1 ὦ δέμας οἰκτρόν] ‘Poor form!' She sees in imagination the mangled body of Orestes: supr. 756.
1162-1163. mvp-comment-554-1 δεινοτάτας κελεύθους] Sent on a terrible journey;' i.e. dismissed from life by a calamitous death. Cp. Trach. 874, 5, βέβηκε Δῃάνειρα τὴν πανυστάτην | ὁδῶν ἁπασῶν ἐξ ἀκινήτου ποδός. Others explain this of the bringing of the ashes from Phocis to Argos.
1164. mvp-comment-555-1 Still gazing at the urn, she calls her brother by the most endearing name: Ant. 899, 915.
1169. mvp-comment-556-1 To die and share thy burial.'
1170. mvp-comment-557-1 She contrasts the tranquillity of the lifeless ashes before her with her own sorrow.
1171-1173. mvp-comment-558-1 Unable to give real consolation, the Chorus fall back on the common-place that loss is common to the race.' Ср. О. Т. 1319, 20, and note. For a speech of three lines in a similar position, cp. Aj. 784-6.
1174. mvp-comment-559-1 Orestes is overcome by compassion in witnessing Electra's grief for him, and, contrary to his first intention, now prepares to disclose himself to her.
1174-1175. mvp-comment-560-1 ποῖ .. ἔλθω] «Το what words must I have recourse, when I know not what to say?' Cp. Phil. 897-9, Ν. οὐκ οἶδ᾽ ὅποι χρὴ τάπορον τρέ τρέπειν ἔπος. Φ. ἀπορεῖς δὲ τοῦ σύ; μὴ λέγ', ὦ τέκνον, τάδε. Ν. ἀλλ᾽ ἐνθάδ᾽ ἤδη τοῦδε τοῦ πάθους κυρῶ.
1176. mvp-comment-561-1 Some omit the point after ἄλγος. Cp. supr. 316. In that case the pronoun í is again supposed to be equivalent to ὅ, τι.
1179-1187. mvp-comment-562-1 Before revealing himself, Orestes gazes fixedly at Electra, as if to realize by actual observation the depth of her misery, and in doing so utters brief ejaculations, to which she replies amazedly.
1181-1182. mvp-comment-563-1 O ruined form, disowned both of men and gods! ! El. Those inauspicious words of yours, O Stranger, can apply to none but me.'
1183. mvp-comment-564-1 'Alas, for thy forlorn and ill-starred life! For ἀνύμφου, cp. supr. 961, 2, πάρεστι δ᾽ ἀλγεῖν ἐς τοσόνδε τοῦ χρόνου | ἄλεκτρα γηράσκουσαν ἀνυμέναιά τε. And for τροφῆς = ' Condition,' cp. Ο. C. 362, ζητοῦσα τὴν σήν, ποῦ κατοικοίης, τροφήν.
1184. mvp-comment-565-1 Why, I pray thee, Stranger, dost thou thus look steadfastly and groan?' ἐπισκοπῶν] · With fixed look,'-as if studying something deeply.
1185. mvp-comment-566-1 How utterly ignorant was I of my own sorrow!'
1186. mvp-comment-567-1 ἐν τῷ .. τῶν εἰρημένων] · In what that has been said did you discern this?' τῶν εἰρημένων marks Electra's unconsciousness that it is the sight of herself and her condition, and not any word spoken, that has moved the 'stranger.'
1187. mvp-comment-568-1 In seeing the sight of thee clothed with many sorrows.' Perhaps a reminiscence of Aesch. Cho. 16-18, καὶ γὰρ Ἠλέκτραν δοκῶ | στείχειν ἀδελφὴν τὴν ἐμὴν πένθει λυγρῷ | πρέπουσαν. Cp. Eur. Suppl. 1056, πένθιμος πρέπεις ὁρᾶν.
1191. mvp-comment-569-1 πόθεν .. κακόν] Orestes, still maintaining his disguise, professes amazement at the sudden mention of a murder. In what quarter can have arisen the mischief you thus make known to me?' i. e. What crime is this, with the knowledge of which you seem so familiar? (Not, 'By whom perpetrated?' with which the answer of Electra does not correspond.)
1193. mvp-comment-570-1 Either (1) 'Who drives you into this bondage?' the dative being equivalent to εἰς with the acc.; cp. ἄχεϊ προτραπέσθαι. Or (2) 'Who thus compels you?'— ἀνάγκῃ, instr. dat. The former (1) is best. See Essay on L. § 11. p. 18, 3.
1194. mvp-comment-571-1 οὐδὲν ἐξισοῖ = οὐδὲν ποιεῖ ἴσον : οὐδέν, cogn. acc.
1195. mvp-comment-572-1 χερσίν, ἢ λύμῃ βίου] 'By violence, or oppression?'
1198. mvp-comment-573-1 ὃς ἦν] Cp. supr. 847. σποδόν] Sc. (1) τούτου, or (2) τοῦτον.
1200. mvp-comment-574-1 μόνος ποτέ] i.e. οὐδείς ποτε ἄλλος ἐπῴκτειρεν.