Plautus Menaechmi 4.2

Henry Thomas Riley (Translator)

View: By Scene

Menaechmi. Plautus. Henry Thomas Riley (Translator). London. 1912.

Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.

Funding provided by NSF, NEH: Digital Libraries Initiative, Phase 2.

Current edition Perseus

Menaechmi, or The Twin Brothers (English) (Plautus. The Comedies of Plautus, Volume 1. Riley, Henry Thomas, translator. London: G. Bell and Sons, Ltd., 1912.)

Editions (1)
Menaechmi Perseus (Plautus. Plauti Comoediae, Volume 1. Leo, Friedrich, editor. Berlin: Weidmann, 1895.) — 4.2 focus

Notes on the current edition

Menaechmi, or The Twin Brothers

1. Most worthy and great: Optumi maximi. This was properly an epithet of Jupiter, and is, perhaps, satirically applied to the little Gods, the great men of Rome . In the previous line he uses morus, the Greek word μωρός, signifying foolish, on account of its resemblance to the word mores, manner or custom.
2. Before the people: It is thought that he here refers to the three modes of trial in civil cases among the Romans — apud populum, before the people in the Comitia centuriata, or full assembly; in iure, before the Praetor, or his delegates, the Recuperatores or Iudices selecti, commissioned judges; and before the Aedile, or city officer. He says, that on being summoned to the concio, a cliens or dependant suddenly accosted him, and insisted on his defending him, which greatly detained him, but that in spite of the worthlessness of his client’s cause, he was at last successful in effecting a compromise.
3. That surety for him: He probably means that he gained time for his client to pay the debt, on condition of his giving bail or security that be would do so within a certain time.
4. The mantle makes: Palla pallorem incutit. In his alarm he cannot avoid a pun on the resemblance between palla, the mantle, and pallor, paleness. The meaning is, literally, the mantle strikes paleness into me; but an attempt is made in the Translation to imitate the play upon the words.
5. Such is the return: Sic datur. Literally, thus it is given, or on these terms it is lent. Some Commentators will have it, that these words are accompanied with a slap on the face, in which case they will be equivalent to there, take that. They may, however, simply mean, such are the terms on which you had my mantle, such are the results of your lending; her abuse and indignation, accompanied, perhaps, with a threat, being the foenus, or interest for the loan.
6. Wish for an owl: Tu, tu. He alludes to the note of the owl which to the Romans would seem to say tu, tu you you.