Notes on the current edition
Introduction to Commentary on Sophocles: Philoctetes
1.
Other literature of the subject.
2.
At v. 1437 Heracles promises to send Asclepius to Troy,—a passage which has groundlessly been regarded as inconsistent with the mention of the Asclepiadae in 1333. If the
Philoctetes at Troy was the earlier play, this may be an allusion to it,— like that to the
Antigone in the
Oedipus Coloneus (v. 1410 n.).
3.
Greek plays.
4.
The
Φιλοκτήτης
by Achaeus of Eretria (a contemporary of Sophocles) dealt with the hero's adventures at Troy. See Nauck,
Trag. Graec. Fragm. p. 755 (2nd ed.). The poet Antiphon (
c. 400 B.C.) also wrote a
Φιλοκτήτης
, if Meineke is right in altering
Ἀντιφάνους
to
Ἀντιφῶντος
in Stobaeus
Flor. 115. 15 (Nauck, p. 793). The
Φιλοκτήτης
mentioned by Suidas among the works of Philocles may have been that of his uncle Aeschylus, as Otto Ribbeck suggested (
Rom. Tragöd. p. 376).
5.
In
Eth. N. 7. 8 (p. 1150
b 9) the Philoctetes of Theodectes is cited as an instance of a man fighting against pain which at last overcomes him. A schol. there (
Anecd. Paris. vol. I. p. 243, 15) says that this poet represented him as
τὴν χεῖρα δεδηγμένον
, and as exclaiming,
κόψατε τὴν ἐμὴν χεῖρα
. The last words are doubtless a mere paraphrase.
6.
Ar.
Ach. 411.
The Sicilian Epicharmus had written a piece on Philoctetes; and Strattis, one of the latest poets of the Old Comedy (
c. 412—384 B.C.), had taken the same theme. The ascription of a play on this subject to Antiphanes (of the Middle Comedy) is perhaps erroneous: see p. xxxi, n. 3.
7.
Attius.
8.
Ribbeck (
Scenicae Rom. poesis fragm. pp. 308 ff.) thinks that Attius followed Euripides, for the most part, in his general design, but borrowed occasional touches from Aeschylus, Sophocles, and the minor Greek dramatists. The impossibility of solving the question is sensibly recognised by Schneidewin (
Philologus IV. p. 656) and Milani (
Mito di F., p. 47). One point of interest may, however, be noticed. Attius made
some one tell the same story which is told by the Neoptolemus of Sophocles—viz., that Odysseus still held the armour of Achilles (see fr. 16). But no one could use this fiction with so much effect as the person chiefly aggrieved. Perhaps, then, Attius followed Sophocles in associating Odysseus with Neoptolemus.
9.
Euphorion.
10.
Flor. 59. 16. Tzetzes on Lycophron 911.
11.
Tzetzes on
Lyc. 911
παυθεὶς τῆς ἄλης, Ἀλαίου Ἀπόλλωνος ἱερὸν κτίζει
. Others connect
ἀλαῖος
with
ἀλέα
(Welcker,
Götterl. I. p. 465).