Appian of Alexandria Civil Wars 2.11.82

Horace White (Translator)

View: By Chapter

Civil Wars. Appian of Alexandria. Horace White (Translator). New York. 1899.

Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.

Current edition Perseus

The Roman History: The Civil Wars (English) (Appianus. The Roman History of Appian of Alexandria, Volume 2: The Civil Wars. White, Horace, translator. New York: The Macmillan Company. London: Macmillan and Co. Ltd. 1899.)

Editions (1)
Ἐμφυλίων Πρώτη Perseus (Appianus. Appiani Historia Romana, Volume 2. Mendelssohn, Ludwig, editor. Leipzig: Teubner, 1881.) — 2.11.82 focus

Notes on the current edition

Civil Wars

1. Caesar puts his own loss at thirty centurions and 200 private soldiers, and Pompey’s at 15,000 killed and 24,000 prisoners. We must infer that Appian was not acquainted with Caesar’s Commentaries, for if he had been he would most probably have quoted him here instead of referring in a loose way to exaggerating writers.
2. The affair of Crastinus is mentioned by Caesar, by Florus, and by Plutarch in his life of Pompey and again in his life of Caesar. The reference here made to Asinius Pollio has led to much discussion in the learned world, touching the sources from which Appian and Plutarch drew. The words used by Crastinus are almost identical in the three passages (one of Appian and two of Plutarch), and this leads Wynne, Hulleman, and Hermann Peter to believe that both authors borrowed from Pollio’s history. Vollgraff on the other hand contends that as Pollio wrote in Latin it would have been little less than miraculous if both of them had used the same Greek words in translating it. He considers it remarkable also that the only reference made to Pollio’s writings by either of them should have been here, and that both of them mentioned incidentally the fact that Pollio himself took part in the engagement. All of these coincidences may be explained if we suppose that both Plutarch and Appian took the facts from a common Greek source; that is, from some author who took them from Pollio. (See Vollgraff’s Greek Writers of Roman History, Leyden, 1880.)