Polybius Histories 10

Evelyn S. Shuckburgh (Translator)

Histories. Polybius. Evelyn S. Shuckburgh (Translator). London. 1889.

Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.

Funding provided by Robert B. Strassler.

Current edition Perseus

The Histories (English) (Polybius. Vols. 1-2. Shuckburgh, Evelyn S., translator. London, New York, NY: Macmillan and Co., 1889.)

Editions (1)
Ἱστορίαι Perseus (Polybius. Vols. 1-4. Büttner-Wobst, Theodor, editor. Leipzig: Teubner, 1893.) — 10.1 focus

Notes on the current edition

Histories

1. B.C. 209, Coss. Q. Fabius Maximus V. Q. Fulvius Flaccus IV.
2. The port of Brundisium was known long before. See Herod. 4. 99 . The Romans colonised the town in B. C. 244. See Livy, epit. 19 .
3. A common mistake to Scipio’s character.
4. Scipio’s use of religion compared with that of Lycurgus.
5. Scipio’s first exploit, B. C. 218.
6. line 5: everawed should read overawed.
7. See on 3, 66 .
8. Elected aedile, end of B. C. 217.
9. line 20: his brother would should read his brother would not.
10. Speech of Publius Scipio to the soldiers in Spain , B. C. 210.
11. Scipio crosses the Ebro , and swoops down upon New Carthage.
12. Scipio’s careful inquiries as to the state of things in Spain .
13. He determines to attempt New Carthage.
14. Gaius Laelius proceeds to New Carthage with the fleet,
15. Scipio by land. B.C. 209.
16. Dr. Arnold declares it all but an impossibility that an army should have marched the distance (not less than 325 Roman miles) in a week. Livy (26, 42) accepts the statement without question.
17. Mr. Strachan-Davidson explains this to mean from the sea to the lake, as Scipio’s lines would not have extended right round the lake to the other sea.
18. Description of New Carthage .
19. Escombrera ( Σκομβραρία). I must refer my readers to Mr. Strachan-Davidson’s appendix on The Site of the Spanish Carthage for a discussion of these details. See above 2, 13 ; Livy, 26, 42 .
20. Scipio discloses his intention of assaulting New Carthage .
21. The assault.
22. A sally of the defenders repulsed.
23. Difficulties of the escalade.
24. Towards evening Scipio renews the assault on the gate, to distract attention from his attack by way of the lagoon.
25. Scipio crosses the lagoon and gets his men upon the wall.
26. The city entered and given up to the sword.
27. Mago surrenders the citadel.
28. Sack of the city.
29. The Roman customs in the distribution of booty.
30. See 6, 33 .
31. Scipio’s treatment of the prisoners. The citizens are dismissed to their homes.
32. The skilled slaves are promised their freedom at the end of the war.
33. Some are drafted into the navy.
34. Mago is entrusted to Laelius.
35. This seems to be the distinction between the words γερουσιά and σύγκλητος. Cp. 36, 4 . The latter is the word used by Polybius for the Roman Senate; for the nature of the first see Bosworth Smith, Carthage and he Carthaginians, p. 27. It was usually called The Hundred. Mommsen ( Hist. of Rome ,, vol. ii. p. 15) seems to doubt the existence of the larger council: its authority at any rate had been superseded by the oligarchical gerusia.
36. The hostages.
37. The women.
38. Scipio’s continence.
39. Laelius sent to Rome with the news. B.C. 209.
40. Preparations for an advance.
41. Xen. Hellen. 3, 4, 17 : Aegsil. 1, 26
42. Euryleon Achaean Strategus, B.C. 210-209.
43. Birth, parentage, and education of Philopoemen b. B.C. 252
44. Elected Hipparch, B.C. 210. Cp. Plut. Phil. 7 , συχνὸς χρόνυς after the battle of Sallasia, B.C. 222.
45. The cavalry tactics of Philopoemen, B.C. 210-209.
46. This and the following chapter were formerly assigned to the description of Scipio’s proceedings in Spain and followed, ch. 20 . Hultsch, however, seems right in placing them thus, and assigning them to the account of the tactics of Philopoemen.
47. A fragment of a speech of some Macedonian orator as to the Aetolians making an alliance with Rome .
48. Alliance between Aetolians and Rome against Philip, negotiated by Scopas and Dorimachus, B. C. 211. See Livy, 26, 24 .
49. On the margin of one MS. the following is written, which may be a sentence from the same speech, or a comment of the Epitomator: A confederacy with democratic institutions always stands in need of external support, owing to the fickleness of the multitude.
50. King Philip’s conduct at Argos after presiding at the Nemean games, B. C. 208. See Livy, 27, 30 , 31.
51. War between Antiochus the Great (III.) and Arsaces III., King of the Parthians. B.C. 212-205. See above, 8, 25.
52. Description of Media, and of the palace at Ecbatana .
53. See 5, 44 .
54. This goddess is variously called Anaitis ( Plut. Artax. 27 ) and Nanea ( 2 Macc. 1, 13 ). And is identified by Plutarch with Artemis, and by others with Aphrodite.
55. The nature of the desert between Media and Parthia .
56. Antiochus prepares to cross it: Arsaces orders the wells to be choked.
57. Antiochus arrives at Hecatompylos .
58. Antiochus determines to follow Arsaces into Hyrcania.
59. The ascent of Mount Labus.
60. The battle on the summit of Mount Labus.
61. He reaches Tambrax.
62. Capture of Sirynx.
63. B. C. 208. Coss. M. Claudius Marcellus, T. Quinctius Crispinus. The two Consuls were encamped within three miles of each other, between Venusia and Bantia , Hannibal had been at Lacinium in Bruttii, but had advanced into Apulia . Livy, 27, 25-27 .
64. Death of the Consul M. Claudius Marcellus.
65. This proverb perhaps arose from the frequent employment of the non-Hellenic Carians as mercenaries. Cp. Plato, Laches, 187 B ; Euthydemus, 285 B ; Euripides, Cyclops, 654 .
66. Fiat experimentum in corpore vili
67. An incident in the attempt of Hannibal to enter Salapia , under cover of a letter sealed by the ring of the dead Consul Marcus. Livy, 27, 28 .
68. Winter of B.C. 209-208. See supra. ch. 20 . The adhesion of Edeco, prince of the Edetani.
69. Edeco is followed by other tribes. B. C. 209-8.
70. Andobales and mandonius abandon Hasdrubal.
71. See 9, 11 .
72. Early in B. C. 208, Scipio moves
73. southward to attack Hasdrubal in the valley of the Baetis. Livy, 27, 18 -19.
74. Andobales joins Scipio.
75. Hasdrubal changes his position to one of superior strength.
76. Scipio arrives.
77. Scipio successfully assaults Hasdrubal’s position.
78. Hasdrubal retreats, and makes for the Pyrenees .
79. Scipio’s self-restraint.
80. Scipio occupies the position evacuated by the Carthaginians.
81. Winter of B. C. 208-207.
82. King Philip undertakes to aid the Achaean league, and other Greek states, against a threat-ened attack of the Aetolians in alliance with Rome , B. C. 208. Cp. Livy, 27, 30 . See above Bk. 9, ch. 28-42 .
83. The improvement introduced by Aeneas Tactitus.
84. This passage does not occur in the extant treatise of Aeneas; but is apparently referred to ( ch. 7, § 4 ) as being contained in a preparatory treatise ( παρασκευαστικὴ βίβλος).
85. The drawbacks to this method.
86. The improved method of Cleoxenus and Democlitus.
87.
The grouping of these letters will be as follows:— 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 α ζ λ π φ 2 β η μ ρ χ 3 γ θ ν σ ψ 4 δ ι ξ τ ω 5 ε κ ο υ
88. Antiochus in Parthia , B.C. 209-5. See ch. 31 .
89. The entrance of the Nomad Scythians into Hyrcania .
90. Polybius confuses the Tanais (Don) with another Tanais or Iaxartes flowing into the south-east part of the Caspian.
91. King of Bactria , see 11, 34 .
92. Battle on the river Arius between Antiochus and the Bactrians.