Strabo Geography 16.4

Hans Claude Hamilton (Translator), William Falconer (Translator)

View: By Section

Geography. Strabo. Hans Claude Hamilton (Translator), William Falconer (Translator). London. 1854-1857.

Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.

Funding provided by Tufts University.

Current edition Perseus

Geography (English) (Strabo. The Geography of Strabo, Vols. 1-3. Hamilton, Hans Claude, translator; Falconer, William, translator. London: Henry G. Bohn, 1854-1857.)

Editions (1)
Γεωγραφικά Perseus (Strabo. Strabonis Geographica, Vols. 1-3. Meineke, August, editor. Leipzig: Teubner. 1877.) — 16.4 focus

Notes on the current edition

Geography

1. Pliny, v. 21, mentions a place which he calls Massica, situated on the Euphrates, near the mouth of a canal which communicated with the Tigris near Seleucia. It is now called Masseib-khan, and is at a short distance above Babylon, on the borders of the desert. I do not know whether this is the Maecene of Strabo. Gossellin.
2. Strabo here refers to the marsh lakes now called Mesdjed Hosaïn, Rahémah, Hour, etc. The Chaldaeans whom he mentions occupied the country along the banks of the Euphrates to the coast of the Persian Gulf.
3. In Cashmir melons are now grown in the same manner. Humboldt remarks that the same contrivance is adopted in Mexico for the cultivation of vegetables.
4. Letronne here proposes to read Erythraean or Ethiopian Sea.
5. Mimosa Nilotica.
6. This is remarkable.
7. Cam Almanazil.
8. Mariaba was not the name of a city, but the title of a city acquired by the residence of their sovereigns. Mariana oppidum, says Pliny, vi. 32, significat dominos omnium. The capital was called Saba, now Sabbea; and the country in which it is situated is called Sabieh.
9. Yemen.
10. The people of Hadramaüt.
11. The extent was six times as large as the Delta.
12. Ailah, or Hoele, or Acaba-Ila.
13. C. ii. § 30.
14. The ruins are still visible at Abu-Keyschid.
15. Deire, or the neck, so called from its position on a headland of the same name, was a town situated on the African shore of the straits of Babel-Mandeb, at their narrowest part.
16. The Troglodytica extended along the western side of the Arabian Gulf, from about the 19th degree of latitude to beyond the strait. According to Pliny, vi. c. 34, Sesostris conducted his army as far as the promontory Mossylicus, which I think is Cape Mete of the modern kingdom of Adel. Gossellin.
17. The 60 and 200 stadia assigned to the straits refer to the two passages there to be found. The 60 stadia agree with the distance of the eastern cape of Babelmandeb, the ancient Palindromos, to the island Mehun; and the 200 stadia to the distance of this island from the coast of Africa. In this last interval are the six islands of which Strabo speaks.
18. This passage has sometimes been mistaken to mean, that the region producing myrrh and cinnamon refers to the southern coast of Arabia. Our author here speaks of the coast of Africa, which extends from the Strait of Babelmandeb to Cape Guardafui. This space in following the coast is 160 or 165 leagues, which are equivalent to 5000 olympic stadia. Gossellin.
19. The long and interesting passage from § 5 to the end of § 20 is taken from Artemidorus, with the exception of a very few facts, which our author has taken from other sources, accompanied by observations of his own. On comparing this fragment of Artemidorus with the extracts of Agatharchides preserved by Photius, and the description of Arabia and Troglodytica which Diodorus Siculus (b. iii. 31) says he derived from Agatharchides, we find an identity, not only in almost all the details, but also in a great number of the expressions. It is, therefore, evident that Artemidorus, for this part of his work, scarcely did anything more than copy Agatharchides. Agatharchides, in his youth, held the situation of secretary or reader to Heraclides Lembus, who (according to Suidas) lived in the reign of Ptolemy Philometor. This king died B. C. 146. He wrote a work on Asia in 10 books, and one on Europe in 49 books; a geographical work on the Erythraean Sea in 5 books; a treatise on the Troglodyae in 5 books; and other works. He wrote in the Attic dialect. His style, according to Photius, was dignified and perspicuous, and abounded in sententious passages, which inspired a favourable opinion of his judgment. In the composition of his speeches he was an imitator of Thucydides, whom he equalled in dignity, and excelled in clearness. His rhetorical talents also are highly praised by Photius. He was acquainted with the language of the Ethiopians, and appears to have been the first who discovered the true cause of the inundations of the Nile. See Smith, art. Agatharchides.
20. Ghela.
21. Kosseir.
22. Mouse Harbour, or Harbour of Venus.
23. Meleagrides.
24. Bender-el-Kebir.
25. Zemorget or Zamargat. The “Agathonis Insula” of Ptolemy.
26. Potlemy Philadelphus.
27. About 12 feet.
28. The whole of this description is so vague that it would be difficult to recognise the position of the places mentioned by Strabo without the assistance of scattered notices by other authors. The result of many comparisons leads me to fix upon 16° 58′ as about the latitude of Ptolemaïs Epitheras. Mount Taurus was 22 leagues higher up, and the harbour of the goddess Soteira 12 leagues beyond. Gossellin.
29. Letronne translates πτολεμαὶ͂ς πρὸς τῇ θήρᾳ as Ptolemaïs Epitheras; see c. iv. § 4.
30. Tacazze, which however does not appear to have such a branch.
31. These islands are to the north of Arkiko.
32. Gulf of Matzua.
33. From the position here assigned to the fortress of Suchus, it is impossible to place it at Suachem, as is commonly done. Gossellin.
34. An island Stratioton is mentioned in Pliny vi. 29, as though he had read in our author the word στρατιωτῶν, the island of soldiers. As the island of Strato is named only in this extract from Artemidorus, we might be tempted to correct the text of Strabo by the text of Pliny. But as it is not certain that the two authors speak of one and the same island, it is more prudent to make no change. Du Theil.
35. I am not acquainted with this place. The ancients speak only of one town of the name of Saba (c. iv. § 19). Was there a town Saba which gave its name to the Sabaïtic Gulf? but the one in question does not appear to have been situated there. Gossellin.
36. B. C. 658.
37. The modern Senaar corresponds with the territory of the Sembritae. See also b. xvii. c. i. § 2. Herodotus, b. ii. 30.
38. Tacazze.
39. The Blue Nile.
40. ἀκροδρύων is expressed in the Periplus of Agatharchides by the words τὸν καρπὸν πίπτοντα ἀπὸ τῶν δένδρων, the fruit falling from the trees. The Periplus adds another tribe, the Hylophagi, wood-eaters, who subsisted on the tender branches of certain trees. Strabo refers to them, b. xvii. c. ii. § 2, but without giving their name. The pods of the Lotus Zizyphus are eatable, and may here be meant.
41. Gymnetae. Between the Spermophagi and the Creophagi, Agatharchides places another people called Cynegetae. Strabo and Pliny do not mention them; but the sort of life the Gymnetae, of which they both speak, lead resembles that of the Cynegetae or Cynegi of Agatharchides and Diodorus Siculus (iii. 25). It seems therefore that these two authors, as well as Strabo and Pliny, meant here to speak of one and the same tribe of Ethiopian Gymnetae, which might have been distinguished by the particular name of Cynegetae, or Cynegi. Du Theil.
42. Above, c. ii. § 37.
43. Milkers of bitches.
44. This Berenice was also surnamed Epi Dire, because it was nearer the promontory Dire than the other cities of the same name. It is probably Bailul, about 12 leagues to the north-west of Assab.
45. Assab or As-Sab.
46. Below, Artemidorus calls it the harbour of Eumenes, § 13.
47. Agatharchides, as quoted by Diodorus Sic. iii. 27, says expressly that this bird is the ostrich. May it be the cassowary?
48. Groskurd supposes the name of this nation has been omitted in the text, and proposes Acridophagi, or Locust-eaters.
49. According to Agatharchides and Diodorus Sic. iii. 28, the habit of living on locusts produced a kind of winged louse in the interior of the body; but this is denied by Niebuhr.
50. Above, § 4.
51. Pliny, xiii. 17; xv. 13.
52. Perhaps Zeila. Strabo is here describing the coast of the modem kingdom of Adel.
53. The Periplus of the Erythraean Sea indicates on this coast a place called Niloptolemaeum, which appears to correspond with the mouth of the river Pedra. Gossellin.
54. Phleus schaeoris. Linn.
55. Daphnus Parvus of the Periplus of the Erythraean Sea.
56. Now Fellis or Fel, which signifies Elephant in Arabic.
57. I think that there is something here omitted and wanting in the text of Strabo, as he seems to make Artemidorus say, that a little after Mount Elephas we find the Horn, or the Cape of the South; for this last appellation appears to have been applied to Cape Guardafui. But this cape, from the time of Philadelphus, and consequently before the period in which Artemidorus wrote, was known by the name of the Promontory of the Aromatics; this author therefore could not have confounded it with the Southern Horn. I have already come to the conclusion that the Southern Horn corresponds with the Southern Cape of Bandel-caus, where commences the desert coast of Ajan, the ancient Azania, respecting which Artemidorus confesses that he was unable to procure any information. It therefore appears to me, that the description which this author must have given of the coast of Africa, from Mount Elephas to the Southern Horn, and which Strabo should have copied, is now wanting in the text. This omission seems to have been noticed by some copyist, who thought to supply it by naming again, to the south of Mount Elephas, the altars of Pytholaus, Lichas, Pythangelus, and Leon, which Artemidorus had already spoken of, and which navigators meet with on the west, and before arriving at Mount Elephas. Gossellin.
58. The text of this paragraph is corrupt; but the reading followed is that suggested in a note by Kramer.
59. λέων μ́ρμηξ. Agatharchides calls them μυρμηκολέων, and Aelian simply μύρμηξ. What animal is intended by the name is uncertain. In b. xv. c. i. § 44, the marmot seems to be described.
60. What the words ἐπὶ σειρὰν mean is doubtful. Casaubon supposes that some words are wanting in the text; Groskurd proposes to read ἀπὸ κεφαλῆς ἐπὶ οὐρὰν, from the head to the tail.
61. The passage is corrupt, and some words are wanting to complete the sense. Groskurd proposes, a span less.
62. Pliny, viii. 29.
63. Ancient authors, under the name of Sphinx, generally describe the ape, Simia troglodyte of Gmelin. Du Theil.
64. Simia innuus.
65. Simia cepus.
66. The spotted hyaena.
67. See b. xv. c. 1, § 45.
68. The juice of the berries is a strong purge.
69. Above, § 5.
70. The bay of Heroopolis is the modern bay of Suez. In the text Aelanitic bay, which is an error of the author or of the copyist.
71. An altar to Poseidon (Neptune), which was erected by Aristo, whom one of the Ptolemies had sent to explore the Arabian Gulf.
72. φοινικων, a grove of palm trees, is taken as a proper name by Diodorus Siculus, b. iii. 41.
73. Sheduan. The Saspirene insula of Ptolemy.
74. Ras Mahomet, which terminates the south of the peninsula formed by the two bays, the Aelanitic running up to Petra, and that of Heroopolis running up to Suez. The meaning of Strabo seems to be, that this cape is in a direction due south of Petra and Palestine.
75. There is a wide difference of opinion among geographers with regard to the position of this important tribe in the modern map of Arabia. See Smith, art. Minaei.
76. The Maraneitae appear to me to be the same people whom other geographers call Pharanitae, and who received their name from their proximity to Cape Pharan, now Ras Mahomet. Gossellin.
77. Diodorus Siculus, iii. § 41, following Agatharchides, narrates the fact with greater precision. The Garindaei took advantage of the absence of the greater part of the Maraneitae, and put to death those that remained. They then laid in wait for and massacred all those who were returning from the festival.
78. Gulf of Akaba.
79. Light vessels. Diodorus Sic.
80. Thamud, formerly occupied by the ancient Thamudeni.
81. Shaur and Iobab?
82. Gibel Seik, Gibel el Hawene, and Gibel Hester.
83. The harbour of Charmothas seems to be the ancient Iambo, the Iambia of Ptolemy, which now, from the accumulation of soil, is more than a day’s journey into the interior of the country. It is in a fertile territory. The Arabs call it Iambo el Nakel, or Iambo of Palm Trees, to distinguish it from the new Iambo situated on an arid soil on the seacoast. Al Charm, in Arabic, signifies a fissure or opening in the mountains. It seems as if the Greeks had formed the name Charmothas from this word, mistaking the epithet given to the narrow entrance of the harbour of Iambo for the name of the town itself. Gossellin.
84. The Debae occupied Sockia. The river which flows through the country is called Betius by Ptolemy.
85. ρὰ πλείω is Kramer’s correction for παλαιὰ.
86. Some are called by Diodorus Siculus, iii. 44, and Agatharchides, Asilaei and Casandres or Gasandres.
87. Instead of εὔομβρος, Groskurd reads πάμφορος, produces everything, following the fragments of Agatharchides and Diodorus Sic. b. iii. 44.
88. Groskurd’s correction, σιδήρου for ἀργύρον, in the text, is adopted. But the passage is probably corrupt, and after σιδήρου we may read κὰ δεκαπλάσιον τοῦ ἀργύρου, for ten times the quantity of silver, according to Bochart, and approved by Kramer.
89. The precise boundaries of Sabaea it is impossible to ascertain. The area we have presumed is comprised within the Arabian Sea W., the Persian Gulf E., the Indian Ocean S., and an irregular line skirting the desert, and running up in a narrow point to Idumaea N. See Smith, Dict. of Greek and Roman Geography, art. Saba.
Milton appears to have been acquainted with the following passage from Diodorus Siculus, b. iii. 46, descriptive of Sabaea : It is impossible to enumerate the peculiarities and nature of all these trees and plants, on account of the surpassing variety and body of perfume which fall upon and excite the senses, in a manner divine and beyond description. The mariner, as he sails even at a distance along the coast, has his share of enjoyment; for when the breezes of spring blow from off the land, the fragrance of the trees and shrubs is carried down to the shore; nor is it of the kind with which we are acquainted, proceeding from old and stored aromatics, but fresh and in full perfection from new-blown flowers, striking the inmost sense.
90. The same as Saba; see c. iv. § 2.
91. The above details derived from Artemidorus, and by him from Agatharchides, would not be found in Eratosthenes, who lived before the time of Agatharchides.
92. We must not confound this measure with the 5000 stadia mentioned in c. iv. § 4. The distance here in question is that taken along the southern coast of Arabia from the straits to Kesem, the ancient Cane, through which passes now, as in former times, the greater part of the perfumes collected in Hadramaut and Seger. But this harbour is about the middle, and not at the extremity of the cinnamon-bearing country. Gossellin.
93. Cardinal Noris places these facts in the year of Rome 730, and quotes, besides Strabo, the historian Josephus. In following the last author, the Cardinal places the death of Obodas in the prefecture of C. Sentius Saturninus, about the year of Rome 740. After the death of Obodas, Aeneas, afterwards called Aretas, took possession of the kingdom of the Nabataeans. Upon this Syllaeus, the late king’s minister, went to Rome, and declared before Augustus that Aeneas, or Aretas, had no right to the kingdom. How this corrupt minister was punished by Augustus may be seen in Nicolas of Damascus and in Josephus. This Aretas must have reigned for a long time, to at least the last years of Tiberius. Du Theil. The interest attaching to this expedition, which promises so much for the elucidation of the classical geography of Arabia, has hitherto served only still further to perplex it. The author of the article Marsyabae in Smith’s Dict. of Greek and Roman Geography, where the subject is discussed at some length.
94. Called also Arsinoë, b. xvii. c. i. § 25. It was near Heroopolis, or Suez.
95. Koft.
96. This name is variously written in manuscripts. If Negra be adopted, as by Letronne, it’s not the same town as the city of the Negrani above mentioned, which was in the interior; but, as Kramer observes, Mire corrupta est haec ultima libri pars.
97. B. xvi. c. iv. § 2.
98. See above, § 2.
99. This reminds us of the prophet Elijah and John the Baptist.
100. Od. iv. 84.
101. This subject was discussed in b. i. c. ii. § 34.