Notes on the current edition
Geography
1.
Corais and Groskurd offer only 27 Fragments; Kramer has 57, his numbers running from 1 to 58 inclusive, except that number 42 is missing; Müller-Dübner have the same 57, though they correct the numbering from 42 to 57; Meineke, like Kramer, has no number 42, but changes Kramer’s 1 to 1a and inserts seven new fragments,1, 11a, 16a, 16b, 23a, 58a, and 58b (the last two being 59 and 60 in the present edition). The present editor adds 28 more. Of these, five (1b, 16c, 27a, 55a, 61) are quotations from Strabo himself; nine (11b, 20a, 21a, 45a, 47a, 51a, 55b, 58) are from Stephanus Byzantinus; twelve (1c, 12a, 15a, 16d, 16e, 25a, 44a, 47b, 50a, 62, 63, 64) are from the notes of Eustathius on the Iliad and Odyssey; and two (65, 66) from his notes on the geographical poem of Dionysius Periegetes. All these fragments from Eustathius, except no. 62, are citations from “the Geographer,” not from “Strabo,” and so is 23a, which Meineke inserted; but with the help of the editor, John Paul Prichard, Fellow in Greek and Latin at Cornell University, starting with the able articles of Kunze on this subject (
Rheinisches Museum,
1902, LVII, pp. 43 ff. and
1903, LVIII, pp. 126 ff.), has established beyond all doubt that “the Geographer” is “Strabo,” and in due time the complete proof will be published. To him the editor is also indebted for fragment no. 66 (hitherto unnoticed, we believe), and for the elimination of certain doubtful passages suggester by Kunze. Meineke’s numbers, where different from those of the present edition, are given in parentheses.The rest of Book VII, containing the description of Macedonia and Thrace, has been lost, but the following fragments, gathered chiefly from the Vatican and Palatine Epitomes and from Eustathius, seem to preserve most of the original matter.Manuscript A has already lost a whole quaternion (about 13 Casaubon pages = about 26 Greek pages in the present edition) each of two places, namely, from
ἡ Λιβύη (2. 5. 26) to
περὶ αὐτῆς (3. 1. 6) and from
καθ’ αὑτούς to
ῥεντῖνος ἐνάμιλλος (5. 4. 3). In the present case A leaves off at
μετὰ δέ (7. 7. 5) and resumes at the beginning of Book VIII. Assuming the loss of a third quaternion from A, and taking into account that portion of it which is preserved in other manuscripts,
Ὄγχησμον (7. 7. 5) to
μυθωδέστερον (7. 7. 12), only about one-sixth of Book VII is missing; and if this is true the fragments here, although they contain some repetitions, account for most of the original matter of the missing one-sixth.
2.
i.e., a city called Dodona.
3.
“Pigeons.”
4.
“Pigeons.”
5.
The senators at Sparta were called “gerontes,” literally “old men,” “senators.”
6.
Cp. 4. 1. 5.
7.
The phrase was used in reference to incessant talkers (Stephanus Byzantinus, s.v.
Δωδώνη).
8.
Gortynium (or Gortynia) was situated in Macedonia, to the south of the narrow pass now called “Demir Kapu,” or (in Bulgarian) “Prusak.”
9.
Now Sirkovo, to the north of the Demir Kapus Pass.
10.
The words to be supplied here are almost certainly “the narrow pass on the south.”
11.
The Vardar.
12.
The Vistritza.
13.
Vardusia.
14.
It is uncertain what mountain Strabo refers to (see Pauly-Wissowa, s.v. “Bertiskos”).
15.
Now the Char-dagh.
16.
Now the Perim-dagh.
17.
Now the Despoto-dagh.
18.
Now the Balkan Mountains.
19.
See 7. 7. 4.
20.
Cp. 7. 7. 8.
21.
Cp. 6. 3. 2.
22.
The name appears to have been derived from the Macedonian Argos, i.e., Argos Oresticum (7. 7. 8).
23.
i.e., the name of the tribe which corresponds to the name of the city.
24.
“A city in Macedonia” (
Etymologicum Magnum, s.v.)
25.
i.e., not with the
e, as is
Βοττεάτης the ethnic of
Βόττεα (see
Etym. Magn., l.c.), but with the
i, as is
Βοττιαῖοι.
26.
sc. Botteia.
27.
The country was called “Bottiaea” (6. 3. 6), “Bottia,” and “Bottiaeis,” and the inhabitants “Bottiaei” (6. 3. 2). See Pauly-Wissowa, s.v.
Βόττια and
Βοττική and Meritt,
Am. Jour. Arch.,
1923, pp. 336 ff.
28.
i.e., the preposition “amphi” (“on both sides of”) and the noun “Axius” (the “Axius” River).
29.
sc. Strabo.
30.
Cp. 7. 3. 19.
31.
sc. Strabo.
32.
Hom. Il. 2.751
33.
Hom. Il 13.301
34.
Including Lower Macedonia (cp. Frag. 12).
35.
Hom. Il. 13.301
36.
Cp. Frag. 14.
37.
See 9. 5. 22, from which this
Fragment is taken.
38.
Our text of Strabo mentions only seven. Benseler’s Lexicon names nine and Pauly-Wissowa eight.
39.
Otherwise unknown.
40.
Tafel, Kramer, Meineke, and Forbiger think that Strabo wrote “Pelagonia” instead of “Pellaea” (or “the Pellaean country”) and that “the city” which the Erigon leaves “on the left” is Heracleia Lyncestis (now Bitolia), for “Pellaea” seems to be used by no other writer and the Erigon leaves “the city” Pella “on the right,” not “on the left.” But both this fragment and Frag. 22 contain other errors which seem to defy emendation (cp. C. Müller,
Index Variae Lectionis); for example, both make the Haliacmon empty between Dium and Pydna (and so does
Ptolemaeus, 3.12
). But lack of space requires that this whole matter be reserved for special discussions.
41.
The text as it stands seems impossible, for Thessaloniceia, not Alorus, was in the innermost part of the gulf—unless, indeed, we assume that Strabo wrongly identified Alorus with Thessaloniceia. In any case, we should probably interpret “it” as referring to “the Thermaean Gulf” and “its” as meaning “Thessaloniceia’s.”
42.
Cp. Frag. 22.
43.
Hom. Il. 2.849
44.
Hom. Il. 21.158
45.
See Frag. 23.
46.
Now the Gallico.
47.
Also spelled “Cisseus” (wrongly, it seems), as in Frag. 24 q.v.
48.
Hom. Il. 11.223
49.
sc. “the mouth of the” (cp. Frag. 20).
50.
Cp. Frag. 20.
51.
Hom. Il. 2.849
52.
Cp. Frag. 20.
53.
Hom. Il. 2.850
54.
The usual meaning of “aea” in Homer is “earth.”
55.
Hom. Il. 2.850
56.
The Greek dative and accusative forms, respectively, of Aia).
57.
Now Doxa.
58.
Cape Paliuri.
59.
Cp. Frag. 21.
60.
Cp. 5. 4. 4, 6.
61.
Cp. 6. 1. 12.
62.
Demetrius.
63.
Ephorus.
64.
The Amazons.
65.
“Beetle-death.”
66.
Cape Nymphaeum (now Hagios Georgios) is meant.
67.
Derrhis and Nymphaeum (cp. Frag. 32).
68.
The same as “Canastraeum” (Fr. 25 and 31).
69.
Now Kavala.
70.
Now in ruins near Nizvoro.
71.
Now Mesta.
72.
See footnote on “Datum,” Frag. 36.
73.
Now Filibedjik (see footnote on “Datum,” Frag. 36.
74.
Now Pirnari.
75.
The third watch of the night.
76.
See Frag. 18.
77.
One of the foremost Macedonian generals (b. 497-d.
319 B.C.); also the father of Cassander.
78.
The same Apollonia mentioned in Frag. 33. It was razed to the ground by Philip. It must have been somewhere between Neapolis and the mouth of the Nestus. Cp. Frag. 32, where Neapolis is spoken of as marking the northern limit of the gulf.
79.
Now Kapronisi.
80.
“Nine Roads.”
81.
Appian Bellum Civile 4.105
and also Harpocration say the Datum was the earlier name of Philippi and that Crenides was the name of the same place in still earlier times. Leake (
Northern Greece, Vol. III, pp. 223-4), Kiepert (
Alte Geographic 315), Forbiger (Strabo Vol. II, p. 140, footnote, 175), Besnier (
Lexique Geog. Ancienne s.v. “Neapolis”), Lolling (
Hellenische Landeskunde, 220, 230) identify Datum with Neapolis. But Heuzey (quoted by Philippson, Pauly-Wissowa s.v. “Datum”) tries to reconcile these disagreements and the above statement of Strabo by assuming that originally Datum was that territory east of Mt. Pangarum which comprised the Plain of Philippi, the basin of the Angites River (including Drabescus now Drama), and the adjacent coast; and that later Neapolis (now Kavala) was founded on the coast and Datum was founded on the site of Crenides, and still later the city of Datum was named Philippi.
82.
Heracleia Sintica (now Zervokhori).
83.
Now Tachyno (Leake,
Northern Greece, Vol. III, p. 229).
84.
The site of the city Doberus is uncertain (see Pauly-Wissowa, s.v.), though it appears to have been somewhere near Tauriana.
85.
The text, which even Meineke retains, is translated as it stands, but Strabo probably wrote as follows: “one has Paeonia and the region round about Doberus on the left, whereas on the right one has the parts round about Rhodope and the Haemus Mountain.
86.
Now Beschikgoel.
87.
Hom. Il. 21.141
88.
i.e., “the chanting of the paean.”
89.
The cry to Titan.
90.
See Frag. 34.
91.
In
42 B.C., after which it was made a Roman colony.
92.
Now Balastra.
93.
Now, perhaps, Kurnu.
94.
Now Bourougoel.
95.
That is, the town of the royal palace, as “Camici” (6. 2. 6) was the “royal residence” of Cocalus.
96.
“Strong Village.”
97.
Xantheia was situated on the mountain now called Xanthi.
98.
Now Maronia.
99.
Now Ismahan.
100.
Literally, “Heads of the Thasii”; referring, apparently, to certain headlands occupied by Thasians.
101.
Hom. Il. 1.594
102.
cp.
Thuc. 2.98
103.
Cape Makri.
104.
Caracoma (or Characoma, meaning a fortress?) is otherwise unknown.
105.
Now Tulsa.
106.
Now Ipsala.
107.
sc. Strabo.
108.
The younger brother of Perseus, whom Perseus regarded as his heir.
109.
Aemilius Paulus Macedonicus, in his second consulship,
168 B.C., defeated Perseus near Pydna.
110.
sc. Strabo.
111.
Bizye (now Viza) was the home of King Tereus (in the story of Philomela and Procne) and was the residence of the last Thracian dynasty, which was of the stock of the Odrysae.
112.
Now Varna.
113.
Now Enos.
114.
Gulf of Saros.
115.
7. 58.
116.
Now called by the Turks “Kavatch Su.”
117.
7. 58.
118.
sc. Strabo.
119.
The better spelling of the name is “Elaeus.”
120.
Now Yeni-scheher.
121.
“Length” here means “breadth” (see Frag. 51).
122.
i.e., “Bitch’s Monument”; according to one story Hecabe (Hecuba) was metamorphosed into a bitch.
123.
The text reads “two hundred and eighty,” but this is clearly an error of the copyist.
124.
On this meteor, see
Aristot. Meterologica 1.7
, and
Pliny Nat. Hist. 2.58
125.
Now Gallipoli.
126.
“Long Wall.”
127.
“White Strand.”
128.
“Sacred Mountain.”
129.
Also spelled “Selymbria.”
130.
What is now Schandu, apparently.
131.
Now the Isle of Marmara.
132.
This work consisted of thirty books, and was written as an interpretation of Homer’s catalogue (62 lines) of the Trojan forces (
Hom. Il. 2.816-877
), as Strabo says elsewhere (13. 1. 45).
133.
Frag. 51 (Bergk)
134.
Hom. Il. 9.359
135.
Peiroüs.
136.
Hom. Il. 4.520
137.
Hom. Il. 2.844, 4.519
138.
Hom. Il. 2.845
139.
The Cicones, themselves inhabitants of Thraces.
140.
The particular Thracians whose territory ended at Aenus, or the Hebrus River.
141.
The argument of this misunderstood passage is as follows; Certain writers (1) make the Homeric Thrace extend as far as Crannon and Gyrton in Thessaly (Fr. 14, 16); then (2) interpret Homer as meaning that Peiroüs was the leader of all Thracians; therefore (3) the Homeric Hellespont extends to the southern boundary of Thessaly. But their opponents regard the clause “all who are shut in by strong-flowing Hellespont” as restrictive, that is, as meaning only those Thracians who (as “Aenus” shows) were east of the Cicones, or of Hebrus. Strabo himself seems to lean to the latter view.
142.
sc. Strabo.
143.
That is, his
Geography, previously mentioned.
144.
This fragment and its context, as found in
Athenaeus 14.75
, requires special investigation. If the text of Atheaeus is right, he misquotes Strabo at least once. For the latter “in his Third Book” (3. 4. 11) speaks of “Cantabrian,” not “Cibyric,” hams. Again, the reading of the Greek text for “he” (in “he knew”) present a grammatical problem; Kaibel makes “he” refer to Pompey, but it must in that context, refer to Strabo. And did Strabo really say that he knew Poseidonius? Or could he have known him? (See 16. 2. 10, where Strabo speaks of Poseidonius as “most widely-learned of all philosophers of out times.”) Moreover, how could Poseidonius have been an associate of that Scipio (Africanus Minor) who captured Carthage? Is not Atheaeus confusing Poseidonius with Polybius, who was with Scipio at the destruction of Carthage? Or is he not confusing Poseidonius with Panaetius (see Casaubon-Schweighaüser,
Animadv. in Athenaeum, Vol. VII, p. 645)?