[294]
Str.
You got ahead of me a little with your question, Socrates; 294a for I was just going to ask whether you accepted all I have said, or were displeased with anything. But now it is clear that we shall have to discuss the question of the propriety of government without laws.Y. Soc.
Of course we shall.Str.
In a sense, however, it is clear that law-making belongs to the science of kingship; but the best thing is not that the laws be in power, but that the man who is wise and of kingly nature be ruler. Do you see why?Y. Soc.
Why is it?Str.
Because law could never, by determining exactly what is noblest 294b and must just for one and all, enjoin upon them that which is best; for the differences of men and of actions and the fact that nothing, I may say, in human life is ever at rest, forbid any science whatsoever to promulgate any simple rule for everything and for all time. We agree to that, I suppose?Y. Soc.
Yes, of course.Str.
But we see that law aims at pretty nearly this very thing, like a stubborn and ignorant man 294c who allows no one to do anything contrary to his command, or even to ask a question, not even if something new occurs to some one, which is better than the rule he has himself ordained.Y. Soc.
True; the law treats each and all of us exactly as you describe.Str.
So that which is persistently simple is inapplicable to things which are never simple?Y. Soc.
I suppose so.Str.
Why in the world, then, is it necessary to make laws, since law is not the most perfect right? 294d We must ask the reason for this.Y. Soc.
Yes, of course.Str.
Well, there are here at Athens , as in other cities, classes for practice in athletics to prepare for contests in running or the like, are there not?Y. Soc.
Yes, a great many of them.Str.
Now let us recall to mind the orders given by the professional trainers when they are in charge of such classes.Y. Soc.
What do you mean?Str.
They think they cannot go into details in individual cases and order what is best for each person’s physique; 294e they think they must employ a rougher method and give a general rule which will be good for the physique of the majority.Y. Soc.
Good.Str.
And therefore they nowadays assign equal exercise to whole classes; they make them begin at the same time and stop at the same time, whether they run or wrestle or practise any other kind of bodily exercise.Y. Soc.
That is true.Statesman. Plato. Harold North Fowler (Translator). Cambridge, MA. 1925.
Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.
Funding provided by The Annenberg CPB/Project.