Sir Richard C. Jebb The Attic Orators from Antiphon to Isaeos 2.20.7

View: By Chapter

The Attic Orators from Antiphon to Isaeos. Sir Richard C. Jebb. London. 1876.

Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.

Funding provided by National Endowment for the Humanities.

Current edition Perseus

The Attic Orators from Antiphon to Isaeos (English) (The Attic Orators from Antiphon to Isaeos. Jebb, Richard Claverhouse, author. London: Macmillan, 1876.)

Notes on the current edition

The Attic Orators from Antiphon to Isaeos

1. Dionys. Isae. 4.
2. See Overbeek, Die Antiken Schriftquellen zur Geschichte der Bildenden Künste bei den Griechen (1868), esp. pp. 67, 110, 204. Cf. Quint. XII. 10 §§ 1—6.—Can it be that, when Dionysios used this illustration, he had in his mind that place of the Poetics (I. 6) where Aristotle speaks of poets related to each other as Zeuxis to Polygnotos— ὁ μὲν γὰρ Πολύγνωτος ἀγαθὸς ἠθογράφος, ἡ δὲ Ζεύξιδος γραφὴ οὐδὲν ἔχει ἦθος —a comparison which so exactly and curiously suits the relationship between Lysias and Isaeos?
3. Hermog. περὶ ἰδεῶν B. C. 11 (Spengel Rh. Gr. II. 411).
4. Hermogenes on Isaeos.
5. ἁπλῶς: as opposed to the sense in which it includes the πανηγυρικὸς λόγος: vol. I. p. 90.
6. As to ‘fiery earnestness’ ( γοργότης), ‘finish’ ( ἐπιμέλεια) and ‘amplification’ ( περιβολή), in the language of Hermogenes, see vol. I. p 91 f.
7. ‘Grandeur’ ( μέγεθος, for which ἀξίωμα or ὄγκος is sometimes a synonym) denotes, for Hermogenes, one of those seven cardmal excellences of oratory which he finds in Demosthenes, his canon of eloquence: περὶ ἰδ, A. 1. This μέγεθος is, in its turn, composed of six specifie qualities ( ἰδέαι): and all of these, says Hermogenes, Isaeos has. They are:—1. σεμνότης, majesty. 2. The power of ‘amplifying ( περιβολή) just mentioned;—by which Hermog. means sometimes generalisation, sometimes development of an idea. 3. ‘Vigour,’ — ἀκμή, — a quality which springs, as a rule, from the union of the two next (see περὶ ἰδ. A. 10). ἀκμαῖος λόγος is a robust, sinewy eloquence, which presses the adversary hard. 4. τραχύτης, asperity: 5. λαμπρότης, brilliancy: 6. σφοδρότης, vehemence. [On the distinction between 4 and 6 see περὶ ἰδ. A. 7: τραχύτης is properly said of rebuking superiors—e.g. judges or ekklesiasts. σφοδρύτης, of rebuking (real or assumed) inferiors, e.g. ἀντίδικοι, or those whom the hearers like to hear censured: it is σφοδρότης when Demosth, assails Philip]Of these, 2 and 3 are named in the text: but we must bear in mind that the other four are understood .
8. Isae. 14.
9. καιρὸς ἴδιος: Hermog. περὶ μεθόδου δεινότητος c. 1: above, vol. I. 91.
10. ‘After all, one cannot help wondering, that, although Dionysius lived in the very age of Cicero, and was copied almost too closely by Quintilian, yet the name of Isaeus is not so much as mentioned in the rhetorical pieces of the two Romans’ (Sir W. Jones, Pref. Discourse, p. vi).Cicero, it is true, never mentions Isaeos. Quintilian, however, does once mention him—and then in not very select company. Speaking of the ‘Attici,’ he says (XII. 10 § 22), ‘Transeo plurimos, Lycurgum, Aristogitona, et his priores Isaeum, Antiphontem: quos, ut homines, inter sc similes, differentes dixeris specie.’ The style of Lykurgos was not highly esteemed by the Augustan or later critics; he is αὐξητικός and σεμνός, says Dionysios, but not ‘elegant or pleasing’ ( ἀστεῖος—ἡδύς ), vet. scrip. cens. 3. As to Aristogiton, the adversary of Demosthenes (see [Dem.] Orr. XXV. XXVI. and Deinarchos Or. II.), he was of small repute every way. Maximus Planudes speaks of that sycophantic oratory, ἡ συκοφαντική, ἧς ἡγήσαντο Ἀριστογείτων καὶ Ἡγήμων (Proleg. in Walz Rh. Gr. v. 214): and he is mentioned, with Phrynon and Philokrates, among the ἄδοξα πρόσωπα by the scholiast on Hermog., ib. IV. 90. The truth is that Quint. made no careful study of the Greek orators, except Isokrates, Demosthenes, and (in a measure) Lysias: but this treatment of Isaeos is especially remarkable.