Notes on the current edition
Geography
1.
For map of Crete, see Insert in Map VIII at end of Loeb Vol. IV.
2.
“Ram’s Forehead.”
3.
The text is corrupt (see critical note), and no known MS. contains a number for the breadth of the island. Moreover, the Greek words (either three or four) contained in the MSS. at this point are generally unintelligible. According to measurements on Kiepert’s wall map, however, the maximum dimensions are
1400 x 310 stadia.
4.
On Hieronymus, see notes on 8. 6. 21 and 9. 5. 22.
5.
All MSS. omit something here (see critical note). Jones conjectures “(it is) about two hundred stadia” in breadth (the breadth of the western end as given in 10. 4. 2).
6.
“White.”
7.
A very close estimate (for the same estimate, see 8. 5. l).
8.
Eratosthenes probably said “a thousand less,” but no number is given in the MSS. (see critical note).
9.
“Cretans of the old stock.”
10.
Hom. Od. 19.175
11.
See 5. 2. 4, where the same passage is quoted.
12.
Staphylus of Naucratis wrote historical works on Thessaly, Athens, Aeolia, and Arcadia, but only a few fragments are preserved. The translator does not know when he lived.
13.
Andron (fl. apparently in the fourth century B.C.) wrote a work entitled
Kinships, of which only a few fragments remain. It treated the genealogical relationships between the Greek tribes and cities, and appears to have been an able work.
14.
Hom. Od. 19.177
.
15.
Andron fancifully connects this adjective with “tricha” (“in three parts”), making it mean “three-fold” (so Liddell and Scott q.v.), but it is surely a compound of
θρίξ and
ἀΐσσω (cp.
κορυθάϊξ), and mans “hairshaking,” or, as translated in the above passage from Homer, “of waving plumes.”
16.
i.e., as composed of three cities instead of four.
17.
“Triple.crest” (of a helmet).
18.
“Made of hair.”
19.
Hom. Od. 19.178
.
20.
Hom. Il. 2.647
and
17.611
.
21.
The goddess of child-birth.
22.
So
Diod. Sic. lc
, but see
Hdt. 3.122
.
23.
The thought, if not the actual Greek words, of the passage here omitted from the Greek MSS. can be supplied from
Diod. Sic. 5.78
, who, like Strabo, depends much upon Ephorus for historical material: “(Cnossus in the) part of the island which inclines towards Asia, Phaestus on the sea, turned towards the south, and Cydonia in the region which lies towards the west, opposite the Peloponnesus”.
24.
Cydonia, as well as Cnossus.
25.
See 10. 4. 14.
26.
We should say “every eight years,” or “every ninth year.”
27.
Hom. Od. 19.178
28.
Five different interpretations of this passage have been set forth, dependent on the meaning and syntax of
ἐννέωρος: that Minos (1) reigned as king for nine years, (2) was nine years old when he became king, (3) for nine years held converse with Zeus, (4) every nine years held converse with Zeus, and (5) reigned as king when he had come to mature age. Frazer (
Paus. 3.2.4
adopts the first. Butcher and Lang, and A. T. Murray, adopt the second.
Heracleides of Pontus On the Cretan Constitutions 3
seems to have adopted the third, saying that Minos spent nine years formulating his laws. But
Plat. Minos 319c
and
Plat. Laws 624
says that Minos visited the cave of his father “every ninth year” (
δι’ ἐνάτου ἔτους); and Strabo (as 16. 2. 38 shows) expressly follows Plato. Hence the above rendering of the Homeric passage. Apart from the above interpretations, Eustathius (note on Odyssey 10.19, on a different passage) suggests that
ἐννέωρος might pertain to “nine seasons, that is, two years and one month” (the “one month,” however, instead of “one season,” seems incongruous). This suggests that the present passage might mean that Minos held converse with Zeus during a period of one season every other year.
29.
Hom. Il. 13.450
30.
Plat. Laws 631b, 693e, 751dff., 950
.
31.
The fourth book of his history was so entitled.
32.
The Mediterranean.
33.
Hom. Il. 2.646
34.
“Eighty” seems to be an error for “eight.”
35.
10. 4. 6.
36.
Aratus Phaenomena 33
37.
“Dictya.”
38.
Strabo refers, respectively, to the distance by land to Aptera and by sea, but his estimates are erroneous (see Pauly-Wissowa s.v. “Aptera”).
39.
Hom. Il. 2.648
40.
Epimenides was a wizard, an ancient “Rip Van Winkle,” who, according to Suidas, slept for sixty of his one hundred and fifty years. According to
Diogenes Laertius 1.110
, he went to Athens in “the forty sixth Olympiad” (
596-593 B.C ) “and purified the city, and put a stop to the plague” (see Plutarch’s account of his visit in Solon’s time,
Plut. Sol. 12
). According to
Plat. Laws 642d
he went to Athens “ten years before the Persian war” (i.e.,
500 B.C.), and uttered the prophecy that the Persians would not come for ten years, and would get the worst of it when they came. But see Pauly-Wissowa s.v. “Epimenides.”
41.
10. 4. 7.
42.
Hom. Il. 2.647
.
43.
Hom. Il. 2.649
.
44.
Hom. Od. 19.174
.
45.
The grandson of Minos.
46.
i.e., that Homer was speaking of his own time.
47.
i.e., that ten were razed by the enemies of Idomeneus.
48.
Hom. Od. 3.191
(Nestor speaking).
49.
Nestor.
50.
Literally, “Herds” (cf. the Boy Scout “Troops”).
51.
Pyrrhicus (see 10. 3. 8).
52.
This Althaemenes, therefore, is not to be confused with the Althaemenes who was the grandson of Minos.
53.
i.e., of Laconia (see 8. 5. 4).
54.
“Old Men,” i.e., “Senators.”
55.
“Horsemen,” i.e., “Knights.”
56.
The later Spartan name was “Syssitia” or “Philitia” (sometimes “Phiditia”).
57.
Alcman Fr. 22 (Bergk)
58.
Others translate
ἐκφέρουσι in the sense of delivering blows.
59.
Possibly an error for “wooden.”
60.
The literal meaning of the word seems to be “those who were chosen as stand-bys” by lovers.
61.
Famous.
62.
i.e., “lover” or “sweetheart.”