Soc.
But in some other lines he shifts his ground a little, saying—
Theognis 434-438 Bergk
(I think it runs thus)
96a
Could understanding be created and put into a man
many high rewards would they obtain
for he would have followed the precepts of wisdom: but not by teaching wilt thou ever make the had man good
Bergk 434-438.
You notice how in the second passage he contradicts himself on the same point?Men.
Apparently.
Soc.
Well, can you name any other subject in which the professing teachers are not only refused recognition as teachers of others, but regarded as not even understanding it themselves,
96b
and indeed as inferior in the very quality of which they claim to be teachers; while those who are themselves recognized as men of worth and honor say at one time that it is teachable, and at another that it is not? When people are so confused about this or that matter, can you say they are teachers in any proper sense of the word?
Men.
No, indeed, I cannot.
Soc.
Well, if neither the sophists nor the men who are themselves good and honorable are teachers of the subject, clearly no others can be?
Men.
I agree.
Soc.
And if there are no teachers, there can be no disciples either?
Men.
I think that statement is true.
Soc.
And we have admitted that a thing of which there are neither teachers nor disciples cannot be taught?
Men.
We have.
Soc.
So nowhere are any teachers of virtue to be found?
Men.
That is so.
Soc.
And if no teachers, then no disciples?
Men.
So it appears.
Soc.
Hence virtue cannot be taught?
Men.
It seems likely, if our investigation is correct. And that makes me wonder, I must say, Socrates, whether perhaps there are no good men at all, or by what possible sort of process good people can come to exist?
Soc.
I fear, Meno, you and I are but poor creatures, and Gorgias has been as faulty an educator of you as Prodicus of me. So our first duty is to look to ourselves, and try to find somebody who will have some means or other of making us better.
96e
I say this with special reference to our recent inquiry, in which I see that we absurdly failed to note that it is not only through the guidance of knowledge that human conduct is right and good; and it is probably owing to this that we fail to perceive by what means good men can be produced.
Men.
To what are you alluding, Socrates?
Meno. Plato. Walter Rangeley Maitland Lamb (Translator). Cambridge, MA. 1924.
Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.
Funding provided by The Annenberg CPB/Project.