[112]
Soc.
Well then, do you now find that the many agree with themselves or each other 112a about just and unjust men or things?Alc.
Far from it, on my word, Socrates.Soc.
In fact, they differ most especially on these points?Alc.
Very much so.Soc.
And I suppose you never yet saw or heard of people differing so sharply on questions of health or the opposite as to fight and kill one another in battle because of them.Alc.
No, indeed.Soc.
But on questions of justice or injustice I am sure you have; 112b and if you have not seen them, at any rate you have heard of them from many people, especially Homer. For you have heard 1 the Odyssey and the Iliad?Alc.
I certainly have, I suppose, Socrates.Soc.
And these poems are about a difference of just and unjustAlc.
Yes.Soc.
And from this difference arose the fights and deaths of the Achaeans, and of the Trojans as well, and of the suitors of Penelope in their strife with Odysseus.Alc.
That is true.Alc.
That is true.Soc.
Then are we to say that these people understand those questions, on which 112d they differ so sharply that they are led by their mutual disputes to take these extreme measures against each other?Alc.
Apparently not.Soc.
And you refer me to teachers of that sort, whom you admit yourself to be without knowledge?Alc.
It seems I do.Soc.
Then how is it likely that you should know what is just and unjust, when you are so bewildered about these matters and are shown to have neither learnt them from anyone nor discovered them for yourself?.Alc.
By what you say, it is not likely.Soc.
There again, Alcibiades, do you see how unfairly you speak?Alc.
In what ?Soc.
In stating that I say so.Alc.
Why, do you not say that l do not know about the just and unjust?Soc.
Not at all.Alc.
Well, do I say it?Soc.
Yes.Alc.
How, pray ?Soc.
I will show you, in the following way. If I ask you which is the greater number, one or two, you will answer two?Alc.
Yes, I shall.Soc.
How much greater?Alc.
By one.Soc.
Then which of us says that two are one more than one?Alc.
I.Soc.
And I was asking, and you were answering?Alc.
Yes.Alcibiades 1. Plato. Walter Rangeley Maitland Lamb (Translator). Cambridge, MA. 1927.
Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.
Funding provided by The Annenberg CPB/Project.