[36]
Soc.
Because of his condition, he is suffering, but he remembers the pleasures the coming of which would bring him an end of his pain; as yet, however, he does not possess them. Well then, shall we say that he is 36a between the affections, or not?Pro.
Let us say so.Soc.
Shall we say that he is wholly pained or wholly pleased?Pro.
No, by Zeus, but he is afflicted with a twofold pain; he suffers in body from his sensation, and in soul from expectation and longing.Soc.
How could you, Protarchus, speak of twofold pain? Is not an empty man sometimes possessed 36b of a sure hope of being filled, and sometimes, on the contrary, quite hopeless?Pro.
Certainly.Soc.
And do you not think that when he has a hope of being filled he takes pleasure in his memory, and yet at the same time, since he is at the moment empty, suffers pain?Pro.
It cannot be otherwise.Soc.
At such a time, then, a man, or any other animal, has both pain and pleasure at once.Pro.
Yes, I suppose so.Soc.
And when an empty man is without hope of being filled, what then? Is not that the time when the twofold feeling of pain would arise, which you just now observed 36c and thought the pain simply was twofold?Pro.
Very true, Socrates.Soc.
Let us make use of our examination of those affections for a particular purpose.Pro.
For what purpose?Soc.
Shall we say that those pleasures and pains are true or false, or that some are true and others not so?Pro.
But, Socrates, how can there be false pleasures or pains?Soc.
But, Protarchus, how can there be true and false fears, or true and false expectations, or true and false opinions?Pro.
Opinions I would grant you, but not the rest.Soc.
What? I am afraid we are starting a very considerable discussion.Pro.
You are right.Soc.
And yet we must consider, thou son of that man, 1 whether the discussion is relevant to what has gone before.Pro.
Yes, no doubt.Soc.
We must dismiss everything else, tedious or otherwise, that is irrelevant.Pro.
Right.Soc.
Now tell me; for I am always utterly amazed by the same questions we were just proposing.Pro.
What do you mean?Soc.
Are not some pleasures false and others true?Pro.
How could that be?Soc.
Then, as you maintain, nobody, either sleeping or waking or insane or deranged, ever thinks he feels pleasure when he does not feel it, and never, on the other hand, thinks he suffers pain when he does not suffer it?Pro.
We have, Socrates, always believed that all this is as you suggest.Philebus. Plato. Harold North Fowler (Translator). Cambridge, MA. 1925.
Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.
Funding provided by The Annenberg CPB/Project.