[301]
Str.
Such states, then, it seems, if they are to imitate well, so far as possible, that true form of government— 301a by a single ruler who rules with science—must never do anything in contravention of their existing written laws and ancestral customs.Y. Soc.
You are quite right.Str.
Then whenever the rich imitate this government, we call such a state an aristocracy; and when they disregard the laws, we call it an oligarchy.Y. Soc.
Yes, I think we do.Str.
And again, when one man rules according to laws 301b and imitates the scientific ruler, we call him a king, making no distinction in name between the single ruler who rules by science and him who rules by opinion if they both rule in accordance with laws.Y. Soc.
Yes, I think we do.Str.
Accordingly, if one man who is really scientific rules, he will assuredly be called by the same name, king, and by no other; and so the five names of what are now called the forms of government have become only one. 1Y. Soc.
So it seems, at least.Str.
But when a single ruler acts in accordance with neither laws nor customs, but claims, 301c in imitation of the scientific ruler, that whatever is best must be done, even though it be contrary to the written laws, and this imitation is inspired by desire and ignorance, is not such a ruler to be called in every instance a tyrant?Y. Soc.
Certainly.Str.
Thus, we say, the tyrant has arisen, and the king and oligarchy and aristocracy and democracy, because men are not contented with that one perfect ruler, and do not believe that there could ever be any one worthy of such power or 301d willing and able by ruling with virtue and knowledge to dispense justice and equity rightly to all, but that he will harm and kill and injure any one of us whom he chooses on any occasion, since they admit that if such a man as we describe should really arise, he would be welcomed and would continue to dwell among them, directing to their weal as sole ruler a perfectly right form of government.Y. Soc.
Certainly.Str.
But, as the case now stands, since, as we claim, no king is produced in our states who is, like the ruler of the bees in their hives, by birth pre-eminently fitted from the beginning 301e in body and mind, we are obliged, as it seems, to follow in the track of the perfect and true form of government by coming together and making written laws.Y. Soc.
Yes, I suppose we are.Statesman. Plato. Harold North Fowler (Translator). Cambridge, MA. 1925.
Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.
Funding provided by The Annenberg CPB/Project.