Aristophanes Birds 523

ed. F. W. Hall, ed. William M. Geldart

View: By Card

Birds. Aristophanes. ed. F. W. Hall, ed. William M. Geldart. Oxford. 1906.

Sponsored by Perseus Project, Tufts University.

Funding provided by The Annenberg CPB/Project.

Current edition Perseus

Ὄρνιθες (Greek) (Aristophanes. Aristophanis Comoediae, Vol. 1. Hall, F. W. and Geldart, William M., editors. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1906.)

Translations (3)
Birds Perseus (Aristophanes. The Complete Greek Drama, Vol. 2. Anonymous, translator. O'Neill, Eugene; Oates, Whitney Jennings, editors. New York: Random House, 1938 (printing).) — 523 focus
Birds (OCR draft) Experimental (Anonymous translation, 1938 compilation; legacy Perseus source migration. Preserved separately from the revised canonical perseus-eng2 at the project owner's request.) — 523 focus
English (Sanjaya, generated; selected passages) (OCR draft) Experimental (Source: pnadelofficial/aristophanes-sanjaya, commit c319590c139e5603e71f0699caa0663d823af8ad. Machine-generated source annotations retained; see Sanjaya import audit for coverage and limitations.) — 523 focus

Commentary

Commentary (Sanjaya, generated; selected passages) (OCR draft) (Source: pnadelofficial/aristophanes-sanjaya, commit c319590c139e5603e71f0699caa0663d823af8ad. Machine-generated source annotations retained; see Sanjaya import audit for coverage and limitations.) focus

523. mvp-tlg0019-tlg006-sanjaya-com-eng1-20

Line 523

νῦν δʼ ἀνδράποδʼ ἠλιθίους Μανᾶς·
The phrase ἠλιθίους Μανᾶς presents a syntactic and lexical crux. While ἠλιθίους is a standard accusative plural adjective meaning 'foolish' or 'simple', Μανᾶς is not a standard nominative or accusative plural form of a known noun in this context. It is likely a corruption or a specific dialectal form of Μανῶν (the plural of Μᾶνας, a type of bird or a proper name) or perhaps a reference to the 'Manes' (spirits of the dead) in a comedic context, though the latter is less attested in Aristophanes. The accusative plural ἠλιθίους Μανᾶς suggests 'foolish Manes' or 'foolish birds,' but the exact identification of Μανᾶς is debated among scholars, with some proposing it as a variant of Μανῶν or a reference to a specific bird species. The textual variant here may stem from the difficulty of the form, with some manuscripts reading Μανᾶς while others may have different readings or emendations.